General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
You might like Yamato, and he's made a strong impression, ticks off a lot of boxes. But he doesn't give me the impression of being a character planned very far in advance, which is one advantage Carrot has in her favor. Oda knew she would be in the war, and planted her into the story and the hearts of the crew years ago. That connection to the crew, both on WCI and now on Onigashima, is another advantage: only Luffy knows of Yamato's existence, which will need to be addressed and doesn't look like it will be anytime soon.
Yamato is emulating Oden to a fault. Is that all he'll ever want to be? Because while the SHs admired and were inspired by their mentors, they are their own selves, and not trying to be someone else. And if Yamato does break out a bit more and try to be his own person, who's to say what he'll decide to do? Maybe traveling the world is something he'd want to do for himself and not just because of Oden, but he also could decide he'd want to stay in Wano with Kaido gone and Momo more accepting of him, especially if he stops trying to replace his dad.
Being relevant is important, and she definitely has a part to play in the future, but it doesn't equate to being an actual SH pirate. Vivi chose to remain a princess and lead her country. She hasn't shown any change in strength, and even if she reunites with the crew at some point, how will she contribute when the others spent two years intensely training?
He should have joined then, but it's the same deal as the end of FI: he had something else he needed to take care of first, and he only signed the contract, so to speak, when he came back for good. His absence from the volume table of contents and all the color spreads for two years supports that.
Yamato is emulating Oden to a fault. Is that all he'll ever want to be? Because while the SHs admired and were inspired by their mentors, they are their own selves, and not trying to be someone else. And if Yamato does break out a bit more and try to be his own person, who's to say what he'll decide to do? Maybe traveling the world is something he'd want to do for himself and not just because of Oden, but he also could decide he'd want to stay in Wano with Kaido gone and Momo more accepting of him, especially if he stops trying to replace his dad.
Being relevant is important, and she definitely has a part to play in the future, but it doesn't equate to being an actual SH pirate. Vivi chose to remain a princess and lead her country. She hasn't shown any change in strength, and even if she reunites with the crew at some point, how will she contribute when the others spent two years intensely training?
He should have joined then, but it's the same deal as the end of FI: he had something else he needed to take care of first, and he only signed the contract, so to speak, when he came back for good. His absence from the volume table of contents and all the color spreads for two years supports that.
First off, that's a load of bullshit considering how she was introduced. How the fuck else is she going to get introduced if she can't leave the fucking Island? She's been held prisoner for 20 years on Onigashima... What bloody fucking way is she going to get introduced? If we had to get to Onigashima in the first place just to know her existence... It's very unique.. Who are you to say, that's not how you introduce a character... Are you fucking writer whose been making a popular manga for 20 plus years? Or are you just putting your subjective view on it.
Everything else you've said is just dumb fluff to make it seem as if you have a point.
Everything else you've said is just dumb fluff to make it seem as if you have a point.
Scabbard storyline needs to reach is climax first and official matchups need to happen before we can likely expect Carrot/Yamato/Jinbe/Zoro flashbacks remotely. I wouldn't expect a Kaido/Yamato flashback until at least Act 4 at this point when Yamato has more interaction with Kaido directly. Similarly, I wouldn't expect a Carrot flashback until her fight with Pero about Pedro. Zoro's is a weird one. I still think King is the reason the Shimotsuki are dead, not Kaido, so potentially King executed his father and he will talk about how he reminds him of Kozaburo. Jinbe I just feel needs to have his scar explained but that would insinuate someone in Wano caused it.
Yeah, God, ALL I want is to have the same argument with another stubborn Carrot stan once again...almost 200 pages of that in this thread, we definitely need more. Check out my older posts, this has all been covered pretty effectively by me and the other Yamato supporters 
Yeah, God, ALL I want is to have the same argument with another stubborn Carrot stan once again...almost 200 pages of that in this thread, we definitely need more. Check out my older posts, this has all been covered pretty effectively by me and the other Yamato supporters
I think your full of yourself when you talk like you think you just know how it's going to go. Get off that high horse.
Why the fuck would Oda introduce Yamato... "added characters on our side go brr" As if we didn't have enough people on our side already.
Anything you can come up with, is all speculation. What we do know is, Yamato had a connection to Ace which ties her to Luffy, and as well as wanting to be Oden and fulfilling his dreams, She will accomplish it. She also desired to leave Wano.
In what fucking world do you live in, convey's that she's not as important and will just "stay behind" after what we already know about her? You have to do some major reaching to have her go 180 on her desires.
Why the fuck would Oda introduce Yamato... "added characters on our side go brr" As if we didn't have enough people on our side already.
Anything you can come up with, is all speculation. What we do know is, Yamato had a connection to Ace which ties her to Luffy, and as well as wanting to be Oden and fulfilling his dreams, She will accomplish it. She also desired to leave Wano.
In what fucking world do you live in, convey's that she's not as important and will just "stay behind" after what we already know about her? You have to do some major reaching to have her go 180 on her desires.
Hey guys, let's not let our experiences with the common rude and vulgar posts subconsciously effect the way we read and respond to posts.
It's okay to disagree but responding with passive aggression and profanity is uncalled for.
The constant passive aggression and profanity can have a subconscious effect, making us interpret civil posts in a combative way, therefore causing negative responses.
It's okay to disagree but responding with passive aggression and profanity is uncalled for.
The constant passive aggression and profanity can have a subconscious effect, making us interpret civil posts in a combative way, therefore causing negative responses.
- Status