If Oda wrote a One Piece Spinoff, what would be the best spinoff series?


  • Total voters
    313
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
What is the purpose of shanks coming to wano again? :kaidowhat:
Haven’t realized by now? Shanks the type of guy who will enter a war to say he will “end” it after both sides already suffered heavy casualties. :kobeha:

So to finally “start” finding One Piece after the highest active bounties are taken out by New Era? But wait, instead of confronting the former little boy who just defeated Kaido after saying “it’s almost time for us to meet again” with an Admiral currently present to boot, he excuses himself with Bartolomeo to “save his credibility.” :denzimote:

Shanks is probably back on his way to Gorosei to snitch again to confirm Luffy intel on him awakening Nika God. Seems that’s all he’s good for lmao.
 
Imo (pure hopium):

- Hachinosu for some quick Blackbeard lore, Bonney is there, so is Crocodile. Leads to.....

- Vira for Vegapunk/Kuma/Sabo/Bonney stuff next (it's a Revolutionary liberated country now and was teased as a potential future island before Laugh Tale). I assume Kuma needs to be saved by Vegapunk, if it's even possible. This might also lead to....

- Elbaf for Usopp plot and the 4th RP. Maybe Vegapunk stuff actually ties into that due to Gigantification. But I expect Urogue and potentially another Sky Island up the giant tree to be related. Big world lore stuff. The crew finds the 4th RP but realizes the need something at Lodestar to complete the puzzle with the RPs (they dont directly tell you island locations or something).

- Lodestar and 1st encounter with Shanks and Blackbeard (same time yes). Blackbeard steals Luffy's Poneglyph copies (but Robin already made a map to Laugh Tale), Shanks betrays Luffy on an ideological level. All motivations are revealed here. One Piece at its darkest and most dire.

- Laugh Tale is about halfway back through the New World. The World War has been escalating this entire time. Blackbeard fights Luffy and falls here. Shanks already has taken One Piece, long before either Blackbeard or Luffy arrived.

- Final War against the WG/Marines at New Marineford and Mariejois. Luffy gets revenge for Ace on Akainu. Big things happen with the Ancient weapons to destroy Mariejois and subsequently Fishman Island. Shanks uses One Piece for its intended lore reason against the WG, but for his own motivations. Shanks also takes the WG National Treasure, with in conjunction with One Piece, allows him to do "something" at God Valley. Luffy and crew follow him there after recovering

- Que final arc against Shanks (Mihawk is there for Zoro) at God Valley at the close of the war. Ending is cataclysmic shit and comes full circle with the story. Luffy wins, returns the hat in a very vindictive way, becomes PK and achieves his dreams, dies, everyone cries, bittersweet ending.


One Piece bias masterpiece . Only needs 500 more chapters to achieve it.

:pepecopium:
Probably the last fight has nothing to do with pirates..The D clan against their old enemy..And also, Luffy's relationship with Elbaf may be deep..A large straw hat can be associated with elbaf..For example, he was a prince who separated his way from elbaf..It may be one of the most important arcs of the future:zorothink:
 
Haven’t realized by now? Shanks the type of guy who will enter a war to say he will “end” it after both sides already suffered heavy casualties. :kobeha:

So to finally “start” finding One Piece after the highest active bounties are taken out by New Era? But wait, instead of confronting the former little boy who just defeated Kaido after saying “it’s almost time for us to meet again” with an Admiral currently present to boot, he excuses himself with Bartolomeo to “save his credibility.” :denzimote:

Shanks is probably back on his way to Gorosei to snitch again to confirm Luffy intel on him awakening Nika God. Seems that’s all he’s good for lmao.
Shanks>Big Mom btw
 
Haven’t realized by now? Shanks the type of guy who will enter a war to say he will “end” it after both sides already suffered heavy casualties. :kobeha:

So to finally “start” finding One Piece after the highest active bounties are taken out by New Era? But wait, instead of confronting the former little boy who just defeated Kaido after saying “it’s almost time for us to meet again” with an Admiral currently present to boot, he excuses himself with Bartolomeo to “save his credibility.” :denzimote:

Shanks is probably back on his way to Gorosei to snitch again to confirm Luffy intel on him awakening Nika God. Seems that’s all he’s good for lmao.
💀
Post automatically merged:

Shut the fuck up
 
Mihawk has literally nothing to do with anybody save Shanks lol and you know this.

Ask yourself, where else would it happen and with what group? Zoro isn't getting some magical EoS fight after the story is over. It'll happen during the story.
Zoro vs Mihawk is about a duel of swordsmen, the worst thing Oda can do for the characters is to wrap that duel in a larger plot.
 
Probably the last fight has nothing to do with pirates..The D clan against their old enemy..And also, Luffy's relationship with Elbaf may be deep..A large straw hat can be associated with elbaf..For example, he was a prince who separated his way from elbaf..It may be one of the most important arcs of the future:zorothink:
Imo, I think it should always be about pirates and end as a pirate story, even if it gets grandiose with the WG/Marine stuff.

This is why I believe it'll be Blackbeard or Shanks in the end. I just personally think Shanks because thematically the story started on the basis of Shanks giving Luffy the hat and inspiring him to be a pirate.

But we'll have to wait and see I guess how the next few arcs turn out.
 
How about BB completely destroys the WG and becomes King of the World (Rocks dream), while Luffy finds One Piece and becomes King of the Pirates.
Final battle King of the World vs King of the Pirates
what about the plot regarding the giant strawhat that imu has and his relationship to joyboy?
i feel like whatever luffy learns after finding the one piece definitely has to do with imu and achieving whatever the previous joyboy couldn't.
 

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
I mean we can agree to disagree then, since I have a different perspective regarding this. Sure, Kaido took a gauntlet, but that gauntlet was used for Luffy to power up to his current state, with current Luffy being arguably >= Kaido, since Kaido himself in his flashback said that Joyboy is the one who will take him down, and Kaido surely did not have in mind for Joyboy to take him down after a gauntlet. That was rather an absolute statement of Joyboy being the one to surpass him. And since Kaido was a silver medalist, while Roger was the Pirare King, the peak of what you can achieve, having put the world to heel with power according to Kaido, I think such a glorious position will be achieved and surpassed by the current era. Hence "worse generation".
You are ignoring all the context and taking that Joyboy statement as absolute... Agree to disagree is inevitable. :kriwhat:
 
My problem is with this is that, you can just make jokes out of plot lines that were previously serious.

It’s okay if Oda wants to be playful with battles, but making Luffy vs Kaido a gag after all the build up just killed the tension and made it boring. The same will happen if Luffy fights BB/Akainu/Imu because they’ve all been shown as serious characters.
BB is the least serious top tier of the lot if we exclude BM, the man got hit in the crotch by Bonney after hitting on her, had his raft drown before Skypeia, got clown diffed by Magellan,etc He was always meant to be Goofy.
 
Though I think we have to be open to the possibility to that either Shanks or Blackbeard are successful in reaching LT before Luffy and taking something.

For example I can (very biasedly) see Shanks taking One Piece from Laugh Tale, unbeknownst to anyone. Whilst Luffy and Blackbeard are on a race to get there and fight completely over becoming Pirate King after Blackbeard already having committed some pretty serious atrocities, potentially with ancient weapons. He gets to Laugh Tale somehow without the RPs or steals them from Luffy.

Then Luffy beats Blackbeard, but doesn't "become" PK because while he found the True history and meaning behind everything, Shanks took One Piece for X reason.

Then que final war on 3 fronts

- Luffy's side
- Shanks' side
- WG/Marines

Where Luffy then fights Akainu and Im, then at the close of the Great War, fights Shanks to bring the series full circle (maybe at God Valley or something). He becomes PK and fulfills his second dream and potentially even dies in the process.

But, I'm already super biased about this idea Lol.
that doesn't sound bad at all, i'm also biased as i don't like seeing shanks defeated/killed by blackbeard. specially now that everyone is expecting it.
 
I mean we can agree to disagree then, since I have a different perspective regarding this. Sure, Kaido took a gauntlet, but that gauntlet was used for Luffy to power up to his current state, with current Luffy being arguably >= Kaido, since Kaido himself in his flashback said that Joyboy is the one who will take him down, and Kaido surely did not have in mind for Joyboy to take him down after a gauntlet. That was rather an absolute statement of Joyboy being the one to surpass him. And since Kaido was a silver medalist, while Roger was the Pirare King, the peak of what you can achieve, having put the world to heel with power according to Kaido, I think such a glorious position will be achieved and surpassed by the current era. Hence "worse generation".
Yes but what happened was a gauntlet battle, Joyboy taking him down isnt mutually exclusive with JB needing help which he did.

Luffy is going to get stronger than Kaido but not right now.
 
Zoro vs Mihawk is about a duel of swordsmen, the worst thing Oda can do for the characters is to wrap that duel in a larger plot.
That's exactly what's going to happen lol. Zoro doesn't get special treatment outside of the confines of this series. The story is about Luffy. Zoro will achieve his dreams within the confines of Luffy's story.

Expecting Zoro to fight Mihawk randomly at the end without a plot seems like a very weird and baseless ask. I have zero idea why people think this is happening.

Mihawk will be involved in the final plot, not be a nothing character until everything is over. That make zero sense lol
 
Haven’t realized by now? Shanks the type of guy who will enter a war to say he will “end” it after both sides already suffered heavy casualties. :kobeha:

So to finally “start” finding One Piece after the highest active bounties are taken out by New Era? But wait, instead of confronting the former little boy who just defeated Kaido after saying “it’s almost time for us to meet again” with an Admiral currently present to boot, he excuses himself with Bartolomeo to “save his credibility.” :denzimote:

Shanks is probably back on his way to Gorosei to snitch again to confirm Luffy intel on him awakening Nika God. Seems that’s all he’s good for lmao.
The issue is with simple chekhov's gun. If you are bringing shanks to wano then have him do something in wano. It is such trash writing for him to simply go away after coming to wano.
 
Mihawk has literally nothing to do with anybody save Shanks lol and you know this.

Ask yourself, where else would it happen and with what group? Zoro isn't getting some magical EoS fight after the story is over. It'll happen during the story.
It's Ben Beckman or no one, Zoro is not going to miss a SH vs Shanks fight.
No one has anything to do Mihawk and Zoro still fought him, your point?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top