Oda can’t do this shit to me man
You guys need to reread the sentence
Rockstar didn't take lid arm.
Kid didn't lose his arm to Shanks! (Shanks didn't cut it)
and Shanks sent Rockstar to give Kid a message with 2 choice to choose from.
Also Kid never said Shanks took his arm
Rather "he lost it in the battle against RHP"
Meaning he lost it one way or another while fighting RHP...
Kid was a newbie rookie (Top vet at best)
There's a reason Limejuice brought up Kid when they were at Wano. He seems irritated which means he probably didn't win against Kid, same way Snack was looking salty when hearing about SNs coz he got an L from Urouge.
Rookie Kid vs Limejuice, Kid dominates but perhaps Benn /Roo blow his arm away.
Theb Kid went on a year later to face a SC at tottoland