Spoiler One Piece Chapter 998 Spoilers Discussion

What will happen in chapter 1000?

  • Total voters
    221
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
RayanOO

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
‎
#4,929
#4,929
duckman said:
There's some nonsense inconsistency here and no one wants to point it out, so I will.

King, Queen, and Jack have the same rank. They are all the All-Stars. There is no difference between them in their internal crew ranking.

Katakuri, Smoothie, and Cracker have the same rank.

You can't claim YC1 and YC2 and YC3 exist but then claim that bounties don't equal strength and thus can't be compared when you're conflating an internal crew ranking (Perforners/Commanders/Generasls) with an external metric (bounties) to begin with.
Click to expand...
I understand what you are saying here, and maybe I was not clear enough.

What i was saying is :

Snack had better rank than Perospero post Skip and was a Sweet commander, a thing Peros isn't. Snack also has only 100M bounty less than Peros while being 20 years younger. So we can think that Snack is the rising star and even if Peros is more experienced Snack is stronger than him, his rank as SC can prove it;

But Snack portayal and Perospero portrayal are quite different in WCI arc and even after. Snack was demoted from his SC rank, was barely introduced during the arc while Peros had a leading role all along, was not only the brain but also demonstrated his powers and versatility : Jimbe was worried about one of his candy structures, trapped the Vinz, Stomped Pedro etc. Even during Wano Peros has the leading role, has something with Marco and a hype arrow attack.

So Oda is giving a lot of importance to Peros compared to other, and even if he isn't a SC he is a main deal of the BMP. So comparing Snack and Peros some can consider that Peros is still above Sanck even if Snack was promoted (and demoted) as SC.

And then I compared with the Jack situation.

Jo said that maybe WsW and Jack were kinda the same as Snack and WsW where Peros could be said to be equal or stronger than Snack.

We can think that like Snack, Jack is the rising star of the BP but still inferior or equal than an more experienced warrior below him in rank (WsW here).

I said that I didn't think so for multiple reasons.

The main reason is portrayal : Jack has good portrayal overall : Mink main threat, fought Fuji and Sengoku, trunked by Zunisha and survived, fought the Minks in sulongs, was trashed by Sulong Dukes but they are uber strong and even Kaido said that jack was strong but the enemies were too much. Jack was also the first one hitting the billion mark, the hype effect was huge. Everyone imagined that Jack was the right hand of Kaido for a long time.

Compared to Snack portrayal, Jack's one is huge. Jack is a main character of Wano, still a All star even if he lost some times, hyped by Kaido, have good feats (against Minks) etc. So Oda didn't use Snack and Jack the same way. Jack has still some good hype and will deliver in an arc where the BP are the main foes and during a fighting arc (hybrid etc). While Snack bounty is good for 30, but it was introduced the last and after Kata, Cracker, Smoothie and Peros one, so the hype effect was not there at all. We were all like : okay he is strong. While Jack bounty even if lesser than Queen and King had a huge effect on the reader.
So for me Jack is not Snack.

Now WsW. WsW seems indeed the first or second most powerful F6 (with Drake). he seems also the most relevant one fighting wise : the guy dare to challenge the All star, wanted to capture Yamato, trapped Drake etc. He also seems strong, the guy has maybe an history with Jimbe. But he never outshined Jack for now. Kaido asked the All star if they were agree to the challenge and they both said yes without any hesitations and Jack didn't seem bothered. Jack is still more important and more relevant.

So for now I can't compare Snack/Peros to Jack/WsW
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top