General & Others One Piece inconsistencies

[Buusatan94]

The waterfall issue with the BMP not being able of crossing the waterfall after King pushed them back despite Perospero having clearly all the abilities to make them escalate it with his candy constructions and other BMP like Daifuku having the means to lift their siblings and possibly the entire ship above it with their books and genie respectively.

Same for Perospero coming alone to Onigashima.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Sir Crocodile power at Alabasta. From sandstrom that can cover up a city to be unable to even touch Luffy in CQC...

 

[Paperchampion23]

I will repeat what I said in another thread.

Sanji somehow knowing of the Clear Clear fruit and wanting it in Thriller Bark since a child yet he wondered why Luffy was drowning in Baratie’s climax.

Hell, Trebol having properties of a damn Logia despite being just a big dude covered in snot as a Paramecia.

Your second point actually makes sense. Trebol had a small thin body in that mucus.

You should have used Katakuri. He literally uses his DF as a logia at points, yet he's a Paramecia

 

[Momoheechulkabe9000]

I don't get how becoming a Warlord would help Law get to that room when PH was clearly off limits for him too.

Isn't that the point of being a pirate with no allegiance to the WG ? To do whatever you want whenever and wherever.

If I recall Law was like a little brother to DD and he even intended to give him the Heart seat.

If I were DD I would be wary of Law especially if his status and ambition keep growing to rival my own influence and power.
Didn't Oda see what happen in Scarface between Tony and Frank ?

Law's plan really depended on Luffy coincidentally coming across this island and going against the Log pose which is really contrived when you think about.

I can see why Oda stated that Law was never meant to be that important.

 

[LolonoisZolo]

Kaido himself is a huge inconsistency...
The character who wants to die but not really...who wants huge war but not really...
Wtf !

 

[bhacha2000]

There is no way Rayleigh and Roger crew did not know Roger had a wife/gf since navy been searching for her. Not even single Roger come to rescue Ace. Instead most put their support on Luffy. What a good nakama Roger had there

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

I don't get how becoming a Warlord would help Law get to that room when PH was clearly off limits for him too.

Isn't that the point of being a pirate with no allegiance to the WG ? To do whatever you want whenever and wherever.

If I recall Law was like a little brother to DD and he even intended to give him the Heart seat.

If I were DD I would be wary of Law especially if his status and ambition keep growing to rival my own influence and power.
Didn't Oda see what happen in Scarface between Tony and Frank ?

Law's plan really depended on Luffy coincidentally coming across this island and going against the Log pose which is really contrived when you think about.

I can see why Oda stated that Law was never meant to be that important.

I think he became a warlord so the marine stop chase him.
His plan was to slack around in PH without problems with the navy and wait until he get a chance to fucks up Doflamingo, which isn't really impressive when you think on that.

 

[Midnight Delight]

Sir Crocodile power at Alabasta. From sandstrom that can cover up a city to be unable to even touch Luffy in CQC...

Even by today's standards him being able to make a sandstorm that travel across a huge island like Alabasta is something only High Tiers have shown something comparable to. Same goes to Enel being able to kill people from kilometres away with the combination of his fruit and island range CoO

Maybe Logias are truly automatic high tier and Caribou's swamp fruit and Smoker's smoke fruit just happened to be the exception

 

[Charlotte Horchata]

You should have used Katakuri. He literally uses his DF as a logia at points, yet he's a Paramecia

Well, the point of Katakuri being a Special Paramecia, not just Paramecia, is that in practice he works like a Logia.

Sir Crocodile power at Alabasta. From sandstrom that can cover up a city to be unable to even touch Luffy in CQC...

Crocodile couldn't create a sandstorm that would cover up a whole city; he could start it and the natural laws of the desert would do the rest, which is very different. Crocodile himself admitted the sandstorm would become so big he wouldn't be able to control it anymore, so it isn't about his personal strength.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Crocodile couldn't create a sandstorm that would cover up a whole city; he could start it and the natural laws of the desert would do the rest, which is very different. Crocodile himself admitted the sandstorm would become so big he wouldn't be able to control it anymore, so it isn't about his personal strength.

I disagree; Sir Crocodile is the only character we saw who can start sandstrom of this lvl which made it his thing. Beside if you claim this doesn't count as his personal strengh than the Ark Maxim doesn't count as Enel's? The clima-tact & Zeus doesn't count as Nami's? Both characters use the "natural laws" of storm clouds to enhance thier abilties, does it's count?
If you answer is yes than why Sir Crocodile who doesn't use tools can't consider it his own power?

 

[Charlotte Horchata]

I disagree; Sir Crocodile is the only character we saw who can start sandstrom of this lvl which made it his thing. Beside if you claim this doesn't count as his personal strengh than the Ark Maxim doesn't count as Enel's? The clima-tact & Zeus doesn't count as Nami's? Both characters use the "natural laws" of storm clouds to enhance thier abilties, does it's count?
If you answer is yes than why Sir Crocodile who doesn't use tools can't consider it his own power?

He's a sand logia in a desert and he himself confirmed that he just started a sandstorm he wouldn't be able to control eventually. This isn't the same as Crocodile himself creating a sandstorm capable of destroying a city from scratch. Any character, no matter their strength, would probably be able to do so by just creating a small sandstorm in the middle of the desert that would naturally grow.

Enel created the Ark Maxim. Nami is using a weapon from a Top Tier that, however, she can control. Crocodile depends on something he can't create nor control to achieve a sandstorm of such level. Simple as that. Take Crocodile out of the desert and he will be unable to perform such feat, unlike a Nami that actually understands and alters the weather whenever she wants in the limits of her capabilities.

A better comparison would be Nami using Big Mom's pre-created storm during the battle against the Enraged Army, and of course that wasn't a showing of Nami's level but a specific situation that she can't replicate. With Crocodile is exactly the same.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

He's a sand logia in a desert and he himself confirmed that he just started a sandstorm he wouldn't be able to control eventually. This isn't the same as Crocodile himself creating a sandstorm capable of destroying a city from scratch. Any character, no matter their strength, would probably be able to do so by just creating a small sandstorm in the middle of the desert that would naturally grow.

Enel created the Ark Maxim. Nami is using a weapon from a Top Tier that, however, she can control. Crocodile depends on something he can't create nor control to achieve a sandstorm of such level. Simple as that. Take Crocodile out of the desert and he will be unable to perform such feat, unlike a Nami that actually understands and alters the weather whenever she wants in the limits of her capabilities.

A better comparison would be Nami using Big Mom's pre-created storm during the battle against the Enraged Army, and of course that wasn't a showing of Nami's level but a specific situation that she can't replicate. With Crocodile is exactly the same.

The fact his power conditional doesn't mean it's not his power. By your logic if you take Nami the calima-tact she can't do nothing, Sir Crocodlie at least can create small sand tornados.
Also while Sir Crocodile can't control his sandstroms only set general direction for them, Nami can't recall her storm clouds once they set-off only dicharge them so both lack fine control.

 

[Charlotte Horchata]

The fact his power conditional doesn't mean it's not his power. By your logic if you take Nami the calima-tact she can't do nothing, Sir Crocodlie at least can create small sand tornados.
Also while Sir Crocodile can't control his sandstroms only set general direction for them, Nami can't recall her storm clouds once they set-off only dicharge them so both lack fine control.

But it does? If Crocodile's only "high tier" (or whatever you want to call him) feat is creating a small sandstorm and letting the desert do the rest out of any actual fighting context and without any control from Crocodile himself, how can you say it is his power? In all case it is the desert power, Crocodile isn't doing anything so amazing there, just creating something that will naturally grow while in the desert.

This isn't comparable to Nami's clima-tact; this would be more comparable to taking Crocodile's logia away from him. And Nami can create the storm cloud and discharge it at will, that's already way more than Crocodile, who in her context wouldn't even be able to discharge the storm cloud to begin with, only to create a small storm that would grow naturally and randomly release electricity.

 

[Dettles]

Ace fighting and losing to Blackbeard. Even seemingly using his strongest attack. Then parrying an Admiral's attack.

 

[Midnight Delight]

Ace fighting and losing to Blackbeard. Even seemingly using his strongest attack. Then parrying an Admiral's attack.

The Yami Yami No Mi was said to be The Gura Gura's Equal , the fact that it could absorb Ace's attack is more of a testament of it's strength than Ace being weak

 

[Buusatan94]

Ace fighting and losing to Blackbeard. Even seemingly using his strongest attack. Then parrying an Admiral's attack.

Well it was only because Ace's fire allowed him to match Aokiji since fire is the perfect counter to ice despite the large gap in power between the two.

 

[vikas]

Not sure if this is considered to be inconsistency in writing or not. But pudding and in extension third eye race made important with the voice of all things stuff and then it did not even matter. I don't like such plot points being raised just to give the info and not use it at all.
[automerge]1598765259[/automerge]

Kaido himself is a huge inconsistency...
The character who wants to die but not really...who wants huge war but not really...
Wtf !

His epithet itself feels fake...no one hurt him? Did anyone even use haki like oden or it was just marine fodders trying to execute him like with ace?

 

[bhacha2000]

Luffy claim immune of poison during Punk Hazard and still got poison on the way to WCI and Reiju save him...

 

[MugiwaraMaster]

Luffy claim immune of poison during Punk Hazard and still got poison on the way to WCI and Reiju save him...

Bingo.

Imagine Oda saying a Stone Fish is deadlier than Hyogyo’s blue ringed venom.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

I remember after Dressrosa they showed a Kano (Don Chinjao island) politician planning to go to the Reverie at Don Chinjao and co. place and he seemed to have some evil plan... but then that went nowhere,and Sai went to the Reverie. Aborted storyline?