Controversial "Shanks is a hypocrite" is the dumbest thing

[Celestial D. Dragon]

No, he tried to sound cool like Shanks without even understanding what he meant.

We don't know who attacked first.

 

[Herrera95]

Okay.

Let's say your chilling in your house late at night and somebody jumped over the fence and tried to enter.

Who attacked first?

First of all Elbaf is not private property of Shanks. Anyone can get it and out freely.

Second, both Kid and Shanks are pirates, outlaws.

Third, we don't know who attacked first.

Forth, Kid isn't even at Elbaf yet he is at the sea.

 

[Stacks]

I mean Kidd got his crew and Shanks got his squad.... I doubt the two Giants would change much in Shanks's favor....

Same giants who got embarrassed by Mr.3 btw

 

[Herrera95]

They attacked first and he attacked back. He would say the same.

Maybe they attacked as a warning and he attacked back for whatever reason. His dialogue would be the same.

 

[Celestial D. Dragon]

They attacked first and he attacked back. He would say the same.

Maybe they attacked as a warning and he attacked back for whatever reason. His dialogue would be the same.

No.... They would 100 percent expect for him to attack back if they started attacking him. That dialogue would never exist if they attacked first.

 

[Stacks]

First of all Elbaf is not private property of Shanks. Anyone can get it and out freely.

Second, both Kid and Shanks are pirates, outlaws.

Third, we don't know who attacked first.

Forth, Kid isn't even at Elbaf yet he is at the sea.

Territories and countries borders extend to its near seas.

It was clearly stated that Kidd attacked first holy fuck.

As a man what would you if a another who you have history with and it said to be violent and shi

Would you not try to pend them off especially if you care about the islands citizen

 

[Herrera95]

No.... They would 100 percent expect for him to attack back if they started attacking him. That dialogue would never exist if they attacked first.

Headcannon.

 

[Stacks]

Headcannon.

@Celestial D. Dragon no way bro I give up

 

[Herrera95]

Territories and countries borders extend to its near seas.

That's real life not One Piece.

It was clearly stated that Kidd attacked first holy fuck.

No it wasn't.

As a man what would you if a another who you have history with and it said to be violent and shi

Would you not try to pend them off especially if you care about the islands citizen

Shanks doesn't care a shit. He wants Poneglyph.
[automerge]1677347264[/automerge]

@Celestial D. Dragon no way bro I give up

Shouldn't even have started.

 

[Stacks]

That's real life not One Piece.



No it wasn't.



Shanks doesn't care a shit. He wants Poneglyph.
[automerge]1677347264[/automerge]

Shouldn't even have started.

All you do is say head cannon and vibe bro.

He clearly cared bro and the pony's are just a bonus tbh

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Not only 2 giants there s more

I mean it's not like Shanks is gonna bring an army of giants. Literally the reason why Shanks has to get out of Elbaf in the first place...

 

[Celestial D. Dragon]

Headcannon.

Lmao, you really think, they'd expect Kid to just sit back and take being attacked, and do absolutely nothing, and then get shocked that he actually fought back? The same guy who tried to attack them in the past as a rookie, but for some reason, now that he's got some clout under his belt of defeating an Emperor, it would be an utter shock he would fight back?

Please....

 

[Herrera95]

All you do is say head cannon and vibe bro.

He clearly cared bro and the pony's are just a bonus tbh

All you do is giving headcannon information that is not on manga. That's why it is called headcannon.

You have the impression he started. That's headcannon. Manga is not clear about it.
[automerge]1677347438[/automerge]

Lmao, you really think, they'd expect Kid to just sit back and take being attacked, and do absolutely nothing, and then get shocked that he actually fought back? The same guy who tried to attack them in the past as a rookie, but for some reason, now that he's got some clout under his belt of defeating an Emperor, it would be an utter shock he would fight back?

Please....

"You really think" I'm not headcannoing here you and the author of this thread are. Manga is not clear about who started.

 

[Stacks]

All you do is giving headcannon information that is not on manga. That's why it is called headcannon.

You have the impression he started. That's headcannon. Manga is not clear about it.

Its stated he attacked them first...

And they have history what do you want shanks to do bro

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Same giants who got embarrassed by Mr.3 btw

Exactly.

 

[Herrera95]

Its stated he attacked them first...

And they have history what do you want shanks to do bro

It wasn't stated.

 

[Stacks]

It wasn't stated.

I'll give you 2 events.

When Mohawk arrive in the same island as shanks did his grunts attacked first?

When ace arrive in the same area as shanks did his crew atracked first?

Kidd clearly attacked first.. Everything about him say so.

 

[Celestial D. Dragon]

All you do is giving headcannon information that is not on manga. That's why it is called headcannon.

You have the impression he started. That's headcannon. Manga is not clear about it.
[automerge]1677347438[/automerge]


"You really think" I'm not headcannoing here you and the author of this thread are. Manga is not clear about who started.

There is no headcannon.... Rockstar popped in, and said "Boss he's attacking us. That means Kidd is the one doing the attacking.

Headcannon is you spinning it with "Well that could mean they attacked first, and they are surprised he is attacking back."

 

[Herrera95]

I'll give you 2 events.

When Mohawk arrive in the same island as shanks did his grunts attacked first?

When ace arrive in the same area as shanks did his crew atracked first?

Kidd clearly attacked first.. Everything about him say so.

His grunts were scared of Mihawk of course they wouldn't attack. Plus Mihawk is WSS which everybody easily recalls as a Yonko level threat. This is like saying they would attack Whitebeard, Big Mom or Kaido if they come in.

Shanks himself was already touching his sword ready to attack Ace if he didn't started to talk about Luffy.

We don't know who attacked first.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Y'all think a hot headed character like Kidd won't attack first lmao.....