Chapter Discussion What did Kidd do to Oda?

[BoaHancocksHusband]

That is just how you wanted oda to write things.
They said Barto needed punishment meaning they hadn't received enough yet.
Had they let them sail away the red hair flag would've become worthless and all the territories and people it protects would be in danger from pirates who kill the innocent like Kid

Kidd should have killed Yasopp.

 

[PrimordialGod95]

You’re not wrong but that’s the difference, kidd is shallow and small

what makes kidd shallow and small?

 

[Peroroncino]

Kidd should have killed Yasopp.

We all know what happened when he went up against a rhp commander

 

[BoaHancocksHusband]

We all know what happened when he went up against a rhp commander

Yasopp is weak and needed to sneak attack. Typical of Usopps bum family.

 

[Peroroncino]

Yasopp is weak and needed to sneak attack. Typical of Usopps bum family.

Yasopp is a legend in op, oda had to remove garp talking to usopp about him in Water 7, but it's as clear as day indication that he is insanely strong, the fact that he is the father of one of the SHs is also a clear giveaway because of the strong father cliche

 

[BoaHancocksHusband]

Yasopp is a legend in op, oda had to remove garp talking to usopp about him in Water 7, but it's as clear as day indication that he is insanely strong, the fact that he is the father of one of the SHs is also a clear giveaway because of the strong father cliche

YaSneak

 

[PrimordialGod95]

That is just how you wanted oda to write things.

and that's how he is depicting shanks to be. Ruthless, unapologetically and it would do whatever means necessary to reach his goals whether it is good or bad.

They said Barto needed punishment meaning they hadn't received enough yet.

like I said if you was going to do that he would have done so from the start when you already captured Barto.

Had they let them sail away the red hair flag would've become worthless and all the territories and people it protects would be in danger from pirates who kill the innocent like Kid

kid does not "innocents" for no reason unless provoked. Also kidd does show mercy a few times already.

 

[Peroroncino]

and that's how he is depicting shanks to be. Ruthless, unapologetically and it would do whatever means necessary to reach his goals whether it is good or bad.

like I said if you was going to do that he would have done so from the start when you already captured Barto.

kid does not "innocents" for no reason unless provoked. Also kidd does show mercy a few times already.

shanks is oda's self insert and therefore he is the avatar of goodness actually, you are trying to make him not to be because you're a kidd fan.
and the reason for why kid kills innocents is irrelevant, if he kills even a single one, he is a villain and will get a villain's end.
And it wasn't just one, shakky said he killed civilians wherever he went, and that was why he was more famous than luffy in sabaody.

 

[Roo]

so he did slaughter innocents

You’re reading a story where even Loki, the evil god of Norse mythology is a good guy

I highly doubt kid killed random civilians. If anything it was likely scumbag pirates like Bellamy

 

[PrimordialGod95]

shanks is oda's self insert and therefore he is the avatar of goodness actually

there's no statement saying that. Just like there's no statement of oda saying crocodile was introduced too early. I found no information on either of those two.

you are trying to make him not to be because you're a kidd fan.

I'm also a fan of shanks and the way he's being depicted it's just what it is.

if he kills even a single one, he is a villain and will get a villain's end.

he's not a villain he's a pirate maybe you don't know the difference cuz you too stuck up on morality when it comes to pirates when it really doesn't matter.

And it wasn't just one, shakky said he killed civilians wherever he went

yes she read it in a newspaper which are known to use propaganda. Like for instance Sabo was stated in the news to kill king cobra.

Post automatically merged: Mar 28, 2025

You’re reading a story where even Loki, the evil god of Norse mythology is a good guy

I highly doubt kid killed random civilians. If anything it was likely scumbag pirates like Bellamy

yeah they act like that kidd is going around islands killing random civilians for no reason.

 

[Peroroncino]

You’re reading a story where even Loki, the evil god of Norse mythology is a good guy

I highly doubt kid killed random civilians. If anything it was likely scumbag pirates like Bellamy

As long as we have no proof of that he did kill them

 

[Peroroncino]

there's no statement saying that. Just like there's no statement of oda saying crocodile was introduced too early. I found no information on either of those two.

I'm also a fan of shanks and the way he's being depicted it's just what it is.

he's not a villain he's a pirate maybe you don't know the difference cuz you too stuck up on morality when it comes to pirates when it really doesn't matter.

yes she read it in a newspaper which are known to use propaganda. Like for instance Sabo was stated in the news to kill king cobra.

Post automatically merged: Mar 28, 2025

yeah they act like that kidd is going around islands killing random civilians for no reason.

Your logic is very biased.
Kid kills the innocent but he's a good guy.
Shanks punishes Barto for endangering thousands and he's bad.

 

[Roo]

As long as we have no proof of that he did kill them

We had 0 proof that Loki was a good guy yet everybody and their grandmamas predicted he was going to be that

Oda is cliche, you guys should know better by now

 

[Peroroncino]

We had 0 proof that Loki was a good guy yet everybody and their grandmamas predicted he was going to be that

Oda is cliche, you guys should know better by now

We had clear proof when mosa said he was kind.
There's no such hints for kidd you are trying to gaslight readers into believing something that's not there

 

[Roo]

We had clear proof when mosa said he was kind.
There's no such hints for kidd you are trying to gaslight readers into believing something that's not there

Luffy literally reads peoples emotions and he likes Kid, that should be enough LMAO

 

[Peroroncino]

Luffy literally reads peoples emotions and he likes Kid, that should be enough LMAO

I don't know why you think he's always doing that 24/7 or what kind of emotion "I don't kill innocents" even is
But Luffy never had a problem siding with bad guys anyway.
And kidd himself said that they were not an alliance

 

[Roo]

I don't know why you think he's always doing that 24/7 or what kind of emotion "I don't kill innocents" even is
But Luffy never had a problem siding with bad guys anyway.
And kidd himself said that they were not an alliance

You’re literally reading a story that is about Luffy being a good judge of character

and this is not a Crocodile situation, Ivankov had to convince Luffy to free Croc. Luffy recruited Kid with a smile and then wrapped him around his hands to celebrate together, things you don’t do with someone you hate

the point is simple, Kid likely didn’t kill civilians becasue he’s not a bad person because you are reading a story where the “misunderstood character” is its most popular trope

 

[Peroroncino]

You’re literally reading a story that is about Luffy being a good judge of character

and this is not a Crocodile situation, Ivankov had to convince Luffy to free Croc. Luffy recruited Kid with a smile and then wrapped him around his hands to celebrate together, things you don’t do with someone you hate

the point is simple, Kid likely didn’t kill civilians becasue he’s not a bad person because you are reading a story where the “misunderstood character” is its most popular trope

and that same story told me kid is famous for killing innocents, multiple times on several islands

 

[Roo]

and that same story told me kid is famous for killing innocents, multiple times on several islands

Yeah and Zoro was a cold blooded devil

Like I said, you guys fall for the easiest tropes

 

[Peroroncino]

Yeah and Zoro was a cold blooded devil

Like I said, you guys fall for the easiest tropes

and then we saw that he wasn't, we have never seen that for kid