Questions & Mysteries Why are Vinsmokes so weak?

#85
Do you guys realize they no diffed 10,000 soldiers of an Emperor's crew, some top ministers included? Remove the candy bullets, and they take down Kaido's entire 40,000 force. If Luffy scrambled to gather 4,000 people, imagine how much Germa is worth.

The only people strong enough to solo the entire Germa army are Admirals and Yonkos. Katakuri or Marco can't solo all 5 Vinsmokes plus thousands of Germa soldiers.
 
#89
If you compare them to yonko army, then yes,
But if you compare them like sichibukai army, ie doflamingo or crocodile vinsmoke is waay more powerful


Also if vinsmoke come to east blue, the could easily defeat arlong, kreig or another SHP villain
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
#93
The Vinsmoke are strong period

5 VET to Low high tier with a powerful army and powerful techs is great.

Elbaf
Wano
Minks
Germa

Yeah the Vinsmokes are very weak. Reminds me of how weak Fisher Tiger ended up being after he was hyped to the moon and back when we first heard that he invaded Mariejois on his own to free the slaves.
Fisher Tiger wasn't weak at all.

His last fight can be underwhelming but it was a flashback and in Oda flashback there are no flashy things and everyone can die from a gun shot. Then he was just betrayed by humans again and was shocked and disgusted. Strawberry and the marine trapped him but I don't think Fisher had the will to put up a real fight.

The guy was stronger than Jimbo
The guy was a legend among all fish men
The guy was revered by everyone

Fisher tiger is among the best character in One piece.
 
#94
Defeating 10000soldiers+some Ministers are a really good feat, they take them down without much problems. And later they even could hold their own against the army on cocao island for hours. I don't think that the Vinsmoke where weak, it was just they face a Yonkou crew because that they looking "underwhelmed"(wouldn't even say underwhelmed because the Vinsmoke do make a great job though).

Let them face Dressrosa Doflamingo family and it would kinda look different.
 
#95
Were they really weak though? They trashed the 10000 soldiers and the ministers sent against them.
We are seeing during wano arc that numbers can be a problem, with zoro and the kid pirates having trouble dealing with it.

Also they had no problem against veteran level fighters, the only ones who trashed them were katakuri and big mom herself.

Ichiji and judge are probably around YC4, same for reiju with neji and Yonko being veteran level. They also have an infinite numbers of soldiers and weapons that they can create with their technology.
 
#96
germa as a whole is at best as strong as 5VA and a few battleships which is nothing

did oda hyped the mythical army too much ?
I mean Weak compared to who exactly?Their stronger than all the strawhats outside of the monster trio and jimbei. Judge Fought a Yonko commander and came out alright. He was also on par with Sanji in their exchange.We never see snack again but we see judge. You could argue Judge is around the monster trio area honestly. Ichiji could be on par with Sanji, possibly above, Generally Older siblings portrayed as stronger than Younger siblings in One Piece. Overall Their Not on the level of commanders but with their abilities, their probably around the tobi roppo. Judge is the strongest and could be near commander level or around there.
 
#97
Vimsmoke Family:
Feats
  • Judge: Was able to tango with Snack (low YC Commander level)
  • Ichiji: Destroyed Oven, smacked Perospero around a bit, wrecked Nusorte’s (or whatever his name is)
  • Niji: Clashed equally with Oven
  • Yonji: Strong enough to subdue Daifuku’s Genie (which is pretty powerful) & wrecked Yuen.
  • Reiju: Her abilities are dangerous enough for Smoothie (mid/high Commander level) to be wary of her.
We never saw Judge fight Snack.

Ichiji didn't destroy Oven, Oven was perfectly fine after Ichiji's attack

Ichiji only punched Perospero once, he did not smack him around a bit.

Niji only attacked Oven they did not clash

The rest are true.
 
Top