Wrong, in chapter 1k she literally says that she wants to go to sea to live freely like Oden, what she said as a child was just that because of all her adventuring she would become strong enough to help Wano, thats not the reason why she wants to leave. That's why she also said in chapter 1016 that after Kaido is done she is still going to leave with Luffy, that wouldnt make sense if her whole reason to leave was to power up to fight Kaido
General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
THis is part of what I call the "negative reputation" and I categorized that already in the "symbolic reach" of each strawhats. You can find that here on my blog here. (Just to let you know that you are not teaching me anything new here)
So as you can see, this is not an "introduction", this is a bad reputation. At first glance you would indeed thing that Carrot has none.. then you think about it a bit more deeper. In fact, CArrot has two thing, one in the story, and one in the meta:
- Carrot is a mink. By essence, Mink thought to be hostile and cannibals creatures by human.
&
- In the "meta", in other word in life, a rabbit is the worst thing you can bring on a ship. By essence, having a rabbit on a ship is seen by sailor as a VERY BAD omen. Sailors are sometimes not even allowed to spell the words "Rabbit" on a boat. This for a very good reason: Rabbit likes to whew on everything and especially the ropes of the boats so having rabbits on board is a very legitimate fear.
The thing is, Oda loves to play with common archetypes and legends. And ALL the mugiwara are supposed to represent monsters and demon. Carrot has been gifted that twice. Once by the simple fact that she is a rabbit, and second because her transformation is literally inspired by the werewolf one.
And here you have it. A bad reputation for Carrot. Not directely given by the story, but by the real life.
Exactly and to stay there.
Like I said, it's not about the relationships, it's about the ideals.
[automerge]1646505507[/automerge]
One does not exclude the other. What I said was right until she met Ace. That's a fact.
So as you can see, this is not an "introduction", this is a bad reputation. At first glance you would indeed thing that Carrot has none.. then you think about it a bit more deeper. In fact, CArrot has two thing, one in the story, and one in the meta:
- Carrot is a mink. By essence, Mink thought to be hostile and cannibals creatures by human.
&
- In the "meta", in other word in life, a rabbit is the worst thing you can bring on a ship. By essence, having a rabbit on a ship is seen by sailor as a VERY BAD omen. Sailors are sometimes not even allowed to spell the words "Rabbit" on a boat. This for a very good reason: Rabbit likes to whew on everything and especially the ropes of the boats so having rabbits on board is a very legitimate fear.
The thing is, Oda loves to play with common archetypes and legends. And ALL the mugiwara are supposed to represent monsters and demon. Carrot has been gifted that twice. Once by the simple fact that she is a rabbit, and second because her transformation is literally inspired by the werewolf one.
And here you have it. A bad reputation for Carrot. Not directely given by the story, but by the real life.
Exactly and to stay there.
Like I said, it's not about the relationships, it's about the ideals.
[automerge]1646505507[/automerge]
One does not exclude the other. What I said was right until she met Ace. That's a fact.
So why did oda put when kaido asks Yamato if she thinks she going to leave wano and she says yes I am going to out to sea with kaido? Then omg ODA IS THE CREATOR OF ONE PIECE NOT U OKAY, keep coping with that stupid theory u have
[automerge]1646506615[/automerge]
Still haven't given her a straw hats introduction so I am sorry if u have to tell you the story in your own way
[automerge]1646506702[/automerge]
Okay u think if Yamato didn't have the cuff on u think she would have leave with ace?
[automerge]1646506792[/automerge]
Omg u literally say Yamato is closer to the samurai 😭 when she isn't
[automerge]1646506615[/automerge]
Still haven't given her a straw hats introduction so I am sorry if u have to tell you the story in your own way
[automerge]1646506702[/automerge]
Okay u think if Yamato didn't have the cuff on u think she would have leave with ace?
[automerge]1646506792[/automerge]
Omg u literally say Yamato is closer to the samurai 😭 when she isn't
Last edited:
Even when carrot hasn't been shown to join but he will go in deep explain why she is joining when she hasn't been in the story like that but that's is his ego 🤷♀️.
[automerge]1646512905[/automerge]
On Twitter type CarrotForNakama and search for Yamato and u will see them who have time to make up stuff like this, please
[automerge]1646512905[/automerge]
On Twitter type CarrotForNakama and search for Yamato and u will see them who have time to make up stuff like this, please
Hm... I would say because I'm basing my point of view on narrative deconstruction and crafting knowledge that I spent years training. At this point, this is a simple case of self confidence. Can I be wrong ? Yes of course it's possible but is it likely ? Not in the slighlest.. precisely because my knowledges are sharp on the subject. In other word, in all those years I add no reason to doubt myself on this subject. In fact it was rather the opposite (the battle for Dressrosa, the battle for Whole cake, THe battle for Sanji). etc.
Of course he has. In fact Carrot had two introductions: A antagonistic one (an introduction that all the strawhats are sharing=, and a character one (the one made to develop even more her character) I talked about that HERE in my blog:
Definitely yes.
Not in term of relationships, in term of ideal and characterization. But it looks like you won't understand that point however I turn it around..
Actually, I'm never on reddit and I hardly comment back on twitter like I use to nowaday
Because she has tho.... Not being in the story for a 30 minutes event doesn't mean that Carrot is not important no more.
Jinbe was at the Helm period. Th fact that he looked at Carrot for a few second doesn't change that.
And it's enough.
Of course he has. In fact Carrot had two introductions: A antagonistic one (an introduction that all the strawhats are sharing=, and a character one (the one made to develop even more her character) I talked about that HERE in my blog:
Definitely yes.
Not in term of relationships, in term of ideal and characterization. But it looks like you won't understand that point however I turn it around..
Actually, I'm never on reddit and I hardly comment back on twitter like I use to nowaday
Because she has tho.... Not being in the story for a 30 minutes event doesn't mean that Carrot is not important no more.
Jinbe was at the Helm period. Th fact that he looked at Carrot for a few second doesn't change that.
And it's enough.
- Status