General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
TBH even momo has more reason to sail with SHs than Carrot. @CarrotForNakama do u agree?
That's why I said, divide the strenght by two and you should get a prett good idea of her strengh around the one of a 300 M bounty man so around Brook. There is no need to make a comparison with Yamato here.
In this thread maybe.. in the community it's not that simple my dear. This thread is not the center of the world ;)
Yes we can
Ger introduction goes from the beginning of zou all the way toward chapter 823. And whole cake is here to etablish her relationship with the crew.
And nothing negates what happens so Carrot is at the same point now that Robin was just before joining the crew. Even more in front in fact.
So not only we can completely compare Robin and Carrot in that matter but we can also compare their status just before joining. The point is not to count the arc before the introduction, the point is the STATUS of the character before joining the crew definitively.
No. Right now Momo has more reason to stay in Wano than to go we Luffy compared to Carrot and Zou.
------
Like always you are ALL forgetting a foundamental rule of storytelling:
Characters are humans.
This means that characters acts like humans do. And are.. like human falling under the rule of development inertia I conceptualized here.
"But how does this applies to Carrot ?" you may ask after reading this.. well..
Carrot is a 15 years old girl (who never left her island) who sent herself into the most EXITING & WONDERFUL adventure there is on the planet. Basically it's like if a 15 yo teenagers who never left his backyard went out and discovered the most exciting roller coaster there is.
So.. here come your reasonning: After having a bit of fun, you are asking this 15 year old teenager NEVER to return on that adventure ever again and stay in his backyard for the rest of his life
Well that's where development inertia comes into plays : When there is an inertia in a development (let's say Anakin is becoming a Jedi..) there must be an EQUAL opposite force to make the development of the character go into the opposite way (Meaning that Anakin can't become Dark Vader over night, there must be STRONG reasons to make him follow the opposite pass of the jedi). That's how human works. We don't change over night unless there is an amazing amount of force put behind the development.
So like a real human who will never go back home and pass on the chances to have more fun for no reason a character like Carrot who choose the pass of adventure and discover an entire world of wonder CAN'T NARRATIVELY change pass to go back home without a strong reason.
I hope this is clearer now. Because as the saying goes: "Once a pirate.. ALWAYS a pirate".
To make Carrot go back home, Oda needs to give her a reason to go back or it will feel strange.
To make Carrot become a captain in the fleet, Oda needs to start making Carrot act as a leader or it will feel strange.
That's why the dialogue from Carrot (because the death of Pedro and her defeat):
"Luffy, I can't go with you, I would be useless, I'm not meant to be a pirate".. would feel STRANGE and would be the sign that this dialogue is a subversion dialogue. The same kind of dialogue screamed by Chopper "but I'm just a monster" just before being recruited.
In this thread maybe.. in the community it's not that simple my dear. This thread is not the center of the world ;)
Yes we can
Ger introduction goes from the beginning of zou all the way toward chapter 823. And whole cake is here to etablish her relationship with the crew.
And nothing negates what happens so Carrot is at the same point now that Robin was just before joining the crew. Even more in front in fact.
So not only we can completely compare Robin and Carrot in that matter but we can also compare their status just before joining. The point is not to count the arc before the introduction, the point is the STATUS of the character before joining the crew definitively.
No. Right now Momo has more reason to stay in Wano than to go we Luffy compared to Carrot and Zou.
------
Like always you are ALL forgetting a foundamental rule of storytelling:
Characters are humans.
This means that characters acts like humans do. And are.. like human falling under the rule of development inertia I conceptualized here.
"But how does this applies to Carrot ?" you may ask after reading this.. well..
Carrot is a 15 years old girl (who never left her island) who sent herself into the most EXITING & WONDERFUL adventure there is on the planet. Basically it's like if a 15 yo teenagers who never left his backyard went out and discovered the most exciting roller coaster there is.
So.. here come your reasonning: After having a bit of fun, you are asking this 15 year old teenager NEVER to return on that adventure ever again and stay in his backyard for the rest of his life
Well that's where development inertia comes into plays : When there is an inertia in a development (let's say Anakin is becoming a Jedi..) there must be an EQUAL opposite force to make the development of the character go into the opposite way (Meaning that Anakin can't become Dark Vader over night, there must be STRONG reasons to make him follow the opposite pass of the jedi). That's how human works. We don't change over night unless there is an amazing amount of force put behind the development.
So like a real human who will never go back home and pass on the chances to have more fun for no reason a character like Carrot who choose the pass of adventure and discover an entire world of wonder CAN'T NARRATIVELY change pass to go back home without a strong reason.
I hope this is clearer now. Because as the saying goes: "Once a pirate.. ALWAYS a pirate".
To make Carrot go back home, Oda needs to give her a reason to go back or it will feel strange.
To make Carrot become a captain in the fleet, Oda needs to start making Carrot act as a leader or it will feel strange.
That's why the dialogue from Carrot (because the death of Pedro and her defeat):
"Luffy, I can't go with you, I would be useless, I'm not meant to be a pirate".. would feel STRANGE and would be the sign that this dialogue is a subversion dialogue. The same kind of dialogue screamed by Chopper "but I'm just a monster" just before being recruited.
See.. mods are triggered by someone calling out the toxicity in others.. But nothing is problematic here.. nooo Lmao xD
Like I said.. the OP community is being infiltrated by the conservatist and political confusionists.. thinking that they own the place.. It goes all the way to the top as you can see here.
Like I said.. it's no wonder that no one reacting to a mod Banthreatening someone calling out the sexism in other when you have literally youtubers (the influencers of the community) using sexism and transphobia and being acclamed for it.
But this type of behavior won't have it's way much longer. One way or another. This BS we be given a ticket for the door.
Like I said.. the OP community is being infiltrated by the conservatist and political confusionists.. thinking that they own the place.. It goes all the way to the top as you can see here.
Post automatically merged:
Like I said.. it's no wonder that no one reacting to a mod Banthreatening someone calling out the sexism in other when you have literally youtubers (the influencers of the community) using sexism and transphobia and being acclamed for it.
But this type of behavior won't have it's way much longer. One way or another. This BS we be given a ticket for the door.
Last edited:
:cheers:
- Status