[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread
- Status
So Dofla isnt new or a troll? Lmao I thought This was another Midnight situation but dude is hilarious @DoflaMihawk welcome to WG mate.
Lost the response I was typing up to this so I'll keep it brief.
Here is where you turned heel on Neeko:
He provided you with a reads list and by your own admission you didn't have an impression on anyone he stated but you awarded him town points for supplying it.
It feels touch and go and low effort, and it makes it harder for me to buy the explanation you were trying to figure him out rather than just trying to go for what you perceived as low hanging fruit. Because your interest in him shrunk almost immediately and then you went straight after Charlie for what I see as a fairly contrived reason as well.
As for Charlie, tbd, but I didn't find any issue with what he said, and I'll have an answer for that by the end of today or I'm doing something seriously wrong, because he's usually not a hard read. No offense Charles.
Here is where you turned heel on Neeko:
He provided you with a reads list and by your own admission you didn't have an impression on anyone he stated but you awarded him town points for supplying it.
It feels touch and go and low effort, and it makes it harder for me to buy the explanation you were trying to figure him out rather than just trying to go for what you perceived as low hanging fruit. Because your interest in him shrunk almost immediately and then you went straight after Charlie for what I see as a fairly contrived reason as well.
As for Charlie, tbd, but I didn't find any issue with what he said, and I'll have an answer for that by the end of today or I'm doing something seriously wrong, because he's usually not a hard read. No offense Charles.
fuji seems townish
sk seems townish
i did not really like kweh's posts (at least the ones that i really noticed) at first reaction bc it seemed like they were just purely agreeing on things and offering nothing much of substance on their own but looking back and also recent posts have changed that view so im going with town lean
ripped cal is slight town lean... personally i did not like his early posts that much where he was trying to get town brownie points but other than that i agree with some of the stances hes taken and i like his general activity
neeko is now null read... i did like her activity and how she is constantly looking for ways to get the ball rolling for town but i didnt really like the ekko thing that much and what followed
in specific, i was not that fond of the bolded things here. i think that if her objective is to generate reactions for ppl to make reads off of, it doesnt make much sense to essentially tell ripped to stop
a reaction is a reaction, no matter who it's from... in fact, maybe if ripped was full on defending ekko for no reason here, maybe it could give us some insight as to potential scum mates or something else... who really knows?
anyways point being that i found it a bit weird (not necessarily alignment indicative) bc at this point of the game, discussion is all we really have
i didnt follow the chevy thing in close detail but i dont remember anything scummy seeming from him... maybe null to slight town lean
everyone else, i need to see more of
sk seems townish
i did not really like kweh's posts (at least the ones that i really noticed) at first reaction bc it seemed like they were just purely agreeing on things and offering nothing much of substance on their own but looking back and also recent posts have changed that view so im going with town lean
ripped cal is slight town lean... personally i did not like his early posts that much where he was trying to get town brownie points but other than that i agree with some of the stances hes taken and i like his general activity
neeko is now null read... i did like her activity and how she is constantly looking for ways to get the ball rolling for town but i didnt really like the ekko thing that much and what followed
in specific, i was not that fond of the bolded things here. i think that if her objective is to generate reactions for ppl to make reads off of, it doesnt make much sense to essentially tell ripped to stop
a reaction is a reaction, no matter who it's from... in fact, maybe if ripped was full on defending ekko for no reason here, maybe it could give us some insight as to potential scum mates or something else... who really knows?
anyways point being that i found it a bit weird (not necessarily alignment indicative) bc at this point of the game, discussion is all we really have
i didnt follow the chevy thing in close detail but i dont remember anything scummy seeming from him... maybe null to slight town lean
everyone else, i need to see more of
I mean that’s not the only reason I have for town points is it? I asked for reads and received them with reasoning behind the reads. I think that’s a good look and as I said to Charlie, that’s what I like. That partnered with the attitude Neeko’s carried through the game attempting to solve and creating content gave town points for the lean I have. Not exclusively just a reads list.
Arp comes across as pretty defensive even after having it explained to him that majority vote is actually harder to reach than plurality.
I certainly don't agree with giving him a pass just because he's new(ish?), just because he hasn't contributed proactively whatsoever, and that is the most obvious way to discern the alignment of a newer player.
That's a fair assessment of him. But considering you found his initial behavior suspect, it felt like your turnaround on him came rather easily.
I certainly don't agree with giving him a pass just because he's new(ish?), just because he hasn't contributed proactively whatsoever, and that is the most obvious way to discern the alignment of a newer player.
That's a fair assessment of him. But considering you found his initial behavior suspect, it felt like your turnaround on him came rather easily.
- Status