[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread
- Status
Tbh I think Haza theoretically looks worse from that than Ultra. particularly the 'testing out some waters' line seems like something someone would say as scum as you'd subconsciously not want to create a binary of "the guy i know is town i will read as scum, and the guy i know is scum i will read as town.'
I'm still not sure I can justify Haza as red scum though given other stuff which is what makes his slot confusing.
I feel like Ultra's "bus Pero' post feels a bit too on the nose to be hiding in plain sight. But they did seem like an accomplished and confident player so its possible that it was intentional.
I'm still not sure I can justify Haza as red scum though given other stuff which is what makes his slot confusing.
I feel like Ultra's "bus Pero' post feels a bit too on the nose to be hiding in plain sight. But they did seem like an accomplished and confident player so its possible that it was intentional.
You guys are being so helpful going back and digging up old posts I REALLY didn't feel like looking for.
I think Arp saying he'll sheep Ultra is just not a thing he ever does - he'd be way too worried of being linked to him as a new player.
I'm gonna have to go back (or one of you two awesome people could do it for me >.>) and see why exactly Cal was saying he should be cleared today and how legitimate it actually is.
I think Arp saying he'll sheep Ultra is just not a thing he ever does - he'd be way too worried of being linked to him as a new player.
I'm gonna have to go back (or one of you two awesome people could do it for me >.>) and see why exactly Cal was saying he should be cleared today and how legitimate it actually is.
Not trying to brag or anything but I was kinda tuneled by purple D1 and literally said "vote xyz and lynch me if this is town" about both Arp and Pero. I really would try to look somewhere else if I were you.
Wasn't it Michelle? Something like "if it's really newbie, let's keep him to give him more game experience" or something. That's how I remember it.
Why not purple?
Unrelated but what struck me about Neeko is that he said something like "Chevy focus on some people when he's town but he get's more agressive when he's scum" or something, which let him to believe that Chevy was town. I may be biased but I thought he was pretty "agressive" towards me out of nowhere so I was pretty surprised he said Chevy is town based on that. Seemed to be bit contradictory.
This vote without anything to back it up reads basically as "I WILL NOT VOTE THIS PHASE".
Wasn't it Michelle? Something like "if it's really newbie, let's keep him to give him more game experience" or something. That's how I remember it.
Why not purple?
Unrelated but what struck me about Neeko is that he said something like "Chevy focus on some people when he's town but he get's more agressive when he's scum" or something, which let him to believe that Chevy was town. I may be biased but I thought he was pretty "agressive" towards me out of nowhere so I was pretty surprised he said Chevy is town based on that. Seemed to be bit contradictory.
This vote without anything to back it up reads basically as "I WILL NOT VOTE THIS PHASE".
Basically he made it look like he was leading the push against pero.
But in reality it was ekko who dueled pero..
Actually he was against ekko and wanted pero to not die.
See here.
So this is why its hella weird that he thinks he should get "town confirmed" for pero flipping scum when he was one of a few that wanted pero to not die.
And in d1 he was one pushing a counter wagon to pero/arp.
But in reality it was ekko who dueled pero..
Actually he was against ekko and wanted pero to not die.
See here.
So this is why its hella weird that he thinks he should get "town confirmed" for pero flipping scum when he was one of a few that wanted pero to not die.
And in d1 he was one pushing a counter wagon to pero/arp.
@Michelle
@bold pings me the most.
She definitely were against both the lynches.
This part and her few posts arround Pero at times gave me vibes she might not be alligned with him, but I've been wrong last game overthinking like that.
When Broki questioned what should be her vig targets she name these three and also agree with vigging Zolo in next post. She's clearly naming the ones that had the lowest post count aka inactivity.
But here she defends Cooler when sussed based on activity. If she believes Cooler inactivity is not sus why suggest vigging him off at all.
She do says so but it is all talks.
I don't remember she mentioned or talked about me, or tagged me,, asked reads at all before suggesting vigging me off.
There's also something off about the way she write some posts.
Anyhow i really don't think Town Kaguu would suggest vigging me off without interacting with me. Doing that to player she don't personally know add up but townie Kagu would try to figure me out, do some efforts to solve me anyhow.
I think she mentioned me again in her reads last day phase based on low inactivity despite my love for GOT flavour but no question on game stuff or reads at all. I'd definitely want her checked out.
@bold pings me the most.
She definitely were against both the lynches.
This part and her few posts arround Pero at times gave me vibes she might not be alligned with him, but I've been wrong last game overthinking like that.
When Broki questioned what should be her vig targets she name these three and also agree with vigging Zolo in next post. She's clearly naming the ones that had the lowest post count aka inactivity.
But here she defends Cooler when sussed based on activity. If she believes Cooler inactivity is not sus why suggest vigging him off at all.
She do says so but it is all talks.
I don't remember she mentioned or talked about me, or tagged me,, asked reads at all before suggesting vigging me off.
There's also something off about the way she write some posts.
Anyhow i really don't think Town Kaguu would suggest vigging me off without interacting with me. Doing that to player she don't personally know add up but townie Kagu would try to figure me out, do some efforts to solve me anyhow.
I think she mentioned me again in her reads last day phase based on low inactivity despite my love for GOT flavour but no question on game stuff or reads at all. I'd definitely want her checked out.
- Status