[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Michelle]

You gon look real bad if cooler flips scum

Do i look like i care about that?
I want to lynch scum.

Give me your reason to town read Neeko

 

[Michelle]

Real good if neko flips scum tho.

But we gotta get rid of cooler.
None wants him
He doesnt have any intent in playing.

I know. But scum who plays the game is easier to lynch with more townies alive

 

[Michelle]

Cooler's play doesn't make sense as either alignment

 

[Ratchet]

The Tyler Perro slot needs to perish. Vigs, please.

 

[Michelle]

The Tyler Perro slot needs to perish. Vigs, please.

Have you read the Iso?

 

[RippedCal]

The Tyler Perro slot needs to perish. Vigs, please.

He was online yesterday so he's at least lurking. He needs to claim if he's gonna stay silent tho

I'd say if he doesn't claim tomorrow we give the vig a green light though

Might be silly to off him without a claim. May be PT role as he was very against claiming last phase

 

[Ratchet]

Have you read the Iso?

Yeah I just glanced over it. He shows up when his name gets mentioned a bit, tries to buddy you who was his main interlocutor at the time, and then when the heat passes goes back to being disengaged again without any evidence of even trying to get himself into the game. Hasn't posted anything in nearly a week.

 

[Ratchet]

He was online yesterday so he's at least lurking. He needs to claim if he's gonna stay silent tho

I'd say if he doesn't claim tomorrow we give the vig a green light though

Might be silly to off him without a claim. May be PT role as he was very against claiming last phase

Can you evidence this charity you've extended to him to anyone else in this thread? I don't care much for any of this post Cal.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

Might be silly to off him without a claim. May be PT role as he was very against claiming last phase

How is this different from Cooler who also refused to claim btw?

 

[Grammaton]

Day 3 Vote Count 4

Cooler 12 - Tpein, Ekko, Ratchet, Charlie, Hime, YTW, Kweh, Wakanda, Lethal, Rippedcal, Kagurashii, Blue, Pot Goblin
Nana 1 - Melkor
Neeko 2 - Michelle, Soulkiller
Melkor 1 - Dofla

With 27 alive, 14 votes to lynch. You have approx 22 hours remaining.​

 

[RippedCal]

How is this different from Cooler who also refused to claim btw?

Cooler has at least claimed no actives

Rugrat hasn't and I've also played with town inactive rugrat many times, I've never played with cooler

 

[RippedCal]

Can you evidence this charity you've extended to him to anyone else in this thread? I don't care much for any of this post Cal.

See above

 

[Lord Melkor]

I haven't commented on what I think of Cooler at all, I just made an observation on Charlies post.

So what do you think of Cooler? It seems like you do not want to take a stance.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

Cooler has at least claimed no actives

Rugrat hasn't and I've also played with town inactive rugrat many times, I've never played with cooler

Cooler claiming that he has no actives has zero credibility. It's equivalent to saying nothing.

 

[RippedCal]

Cooler claiming that he has no actives has zero credibility. It's equivalent to saying nothing.

What's your point?

 

[Kagu Nyan]

What's your point?

Both Cooler and Tyler refused to claim.

Cooler claiming no abilities doesn't give him any extra points and it certainly doesn't imply that Tyler must be PT.

Both are equally unhelpful and no one should be overlooked.

 

[Underworld Broker]

Why yall ppl so impatient with day having 48h

 

[RippedCal]

Both Cooler and Tyler refused to claim.

Cooler claiming no abilities doesn't give him any extra points and it certainly doesn't imply that Tyler must be PT.

Both are equally unhelpful and no one should be overlooked.

Cooler claiming no abilities means in a world where he and Tyler are both town , we stand to lose less by lynching him.

Nobody has ever said Cooler claiming no abilities implies Tyler must be PT, what a weird way to twist what I said.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

Cooler claiming no abilities means in a world where he and Tyler are both town , we stand to lose less by lynching him.

Nobody has ever said Cooler claiming no abilities implies Tyler must be PT, what a weird way to twist what I said.

No I don't imply that. You said Tyler may be a PT because he refused to claim.

However, Cooler and Tyler are both basically doing the same thing - refusing to claim. So none of them should be overlooked. Makes sense now?

From your words, it seems you are not in favor of lynching either Cooler or Tyler since in some world they might both be town- and lynching any of them, we end up losing more. Who else do you want to lynch instead?

 

[RippedCal]

No I don't imply that. You said Tyler may be a PT because he refused to claim.

However, Cooler and Tyler are both basically doing the same thing - refusing to claim. So none of them should be overlooked. Makes sense now?

From your words, it seems you are not in favor of lynching either Cooler or Tyler since in some world they might both be town- and lynching any of them, we end up losing more. Who else do you want to lynch instead?

I'm voting for Cooler. I'm suggesting rugrat shouldn't be vigged without a claim first