- Status
It would of been tantalising to go after the Mafia Cop first, however 2 anti-town kills is a lot of an hassle when you also have a vig who might attempt to shoot someone and fail. But utmost important, when the Mafia Cop has got a 3/10 shot at discovering a townie power role at day, while the SK more or less equates that with a 3/11 shot at actually killing one at night.
This is a chicken-and-egg thing, you may want to overcome this logical problem by superposing the chicken to the egg in that it's the most harmful individual in this precise moment. The chicken matches the sketch of an SK in this set-up in my opinion.
This is a chicken-and-egg thing, you may want to overcome this logical problem by superposing the chicken to the egg in that it's the most harmful individual in this precise moment. The chicken matches the sketch of an SK in this set-up in my opinion.
Okay here is what I understood so far---
1)our first priority should be to avoid any wrong lynch. If we wrongly lynched a townie then that would mean by day 2 we may lose 3 townie as we have two night kills making it the worst scenario.
2)on further calculation, if we get sk asap then it's the best case for us because that means we only have one night kill threat.
But if we are unable to deduce who might be sk then we should not be blind to mafia as getting one of them means we are breaking the team work between them. That's huge win either way.
I would suggest we should give reads now as 17 hours are passed and scenario of no lynching would hurt us really bad because we may end up sacrificing two townie at night with zero headway on who could be mafia and sk.
My reads
Good/townie - Kiwipom, Celestia, gambit, TAC, final, Playa, and rej -hey all were very proactive in this game and are quite vocal which implies they aren't afraid. Only those are afraid in speaking boldly who have something to hide
Neutral - Naomi
Bad- Bogard/Haku /vonal (playing too safe and vary custiously)
How, it's an intuitive read so it's not something I will stick to but still I want to be clear on how I am seeing everyone here.
Unvote Rej
1)our first priority should be to avoid any wrong lynch. If we wrongly lynched a townie then that would mean by day 2 we may lose 3 townie as we have two night kills making it the worst scenario.
2)on further calculation, if we get sk asap then it's the best case for us because that means we only have one night kill threat.
But if we are unable to deduce who might be sk then we should not be blind to mafia as getting one of them means we are breaking the team work between them. That's huge win either way.
I would suggest we should give reads now as 17 hours are passed and scenario of no lynching would hurt us really bad because we may end up sacrificing two townie at night with zero headway on who could be mafia and sk.
My reads
Good/townie - Kiwipom, Celestia, gambit, TAC, final, Playa, and rej -hey all were very proactive in this game and are quite vocal which implies they aren't afraid. Only those are afraid in speaking boldly who have something to hide
Neutral - Naomi
Bad- Bogard/Haku /vonal (playing too safe and vary custiously)
How, it's an intuitive read so it's not something I will stick to but still I want to be clear on how I am seeing everyone here.
Unvote Rej
By mislynch, yes there is a reduced number of town but it doesn't end game there. By mislynch, we get info and that info will help us progress in the game by viewing who lowkey or subtly pushed for that misdirection or confusion to town.
Ofcourse it's priority, there's no denying how threat sk is. That role is a threat to both faction but mafia will try to leverage on that role by letting it do his thing; not to mention the sheer luck of not being hit randomly by sk. Sk at this point will try to scumhunt if not blend in well. He needs that in order to ave a calculated move at night by not hitting a scum. So at this point, we should look at the players who not only lurk but post alot.
Ofcourse it's priority, there's no denying how threat sk is. That role is a threat to both faction but mafia will try to leverage on that role by letting it do his thing; not to mention the sheer luck of not being hit randomly by sk. Sk at this point will try to scumhunt if not blend in well. He needs that in order to ave a calculated move at night by not hitting a scum. So at this point, we should look at the players who not only lurk but post alot.
Alright, here's my reads:
Town - Celestia, Naomi, Rej, Reborn, Finalbeta
Suspicious:
Playa - The way he was baselessly lynching people is a red flag for me. Maybe this is just a game strategy to start discussion, I wouldn't know better since this is my first game lol. If that's the case then yeah, he may just be townie. Nonetheless, I'm keeping my guards up
TAC - seems like a towny but those long essays to justify why we need to get the SK is a bit over-the-top trying to prove himself innocent imo, but that just seems like his playing style. Overall seems good but again, not totally convinced.
Bogard and Vonal - like Reborn said, I think they're being really cautious
Neutral - Gambit, Haku..not sure what to think yet
Town - Celestia, Naomi, Rej, Reborn, Finalbeta
Suspicious:
Playa - The way he was baselessly lynching people is a red flag for me. Maybe this is just a game strategy to start discussion, I wouldn't know better since this is my first game lol. If that's the case then yeah, he may just be townie. Nonetheless, I'm keeping my guards up
TAC - seems like a towny but those long essays to justify why we need to get the SK is a bit over-the-top trying to prove himself innocent imo, but that just seems like his playing style. Overall seems good but again, not totally convinced.
Bogard and Vonal - like Reborn said, I think they're being really cautious
Neutral - Gambit, Haku..not sure what to think yet
So you won't say who you're suspicious of?
I mean it's your choice, I don't have a lot to base my reads off of either but I think we need to start deciding if we're going to lynch anyone today, and if so, who
[automerge]1568945539[/automerge]
yeah but people came after him because he wanted to get people lynched lol
I mean it's your choice, I don't have a lot to base my reads off of either but I think we need to start deciding if we're going to lynch anyone today, and if so, who
[automerge]1568945539[/automerge]
yeah but people came after him because he wanted to get people lynched lol
Reading back,
Below is a lowkey omgus. Playa dropped an rvs on you and you suspected him back. A town wouldn't meltdown with this typical play but laugh it out. He wanted to have a response and he got what he wanted from you.. Scum behaviour point 1.
Another one. Below you just sheeped all the way hardly on TAC's arguments. This is also a scummy behavior and you already have 2 points there.. Can't you build your own case? Can't you read through people's post? Can't you say something your own words to contribute to town?
Let's see what else he saw.
You seem to be too afraid to touch someone here. That's my assumption. Why? In every posts, we can find even the slightest hint as to what the specific player's intention is. Points 3...
To sum it up, you're just posting for the sake of posting and acting like you are contributing but of less value. This is the most typical manner of a scum in order to blend in.. Looking at all the parameters I have mentioned above, you have just created your own grave..
Tryna blend in
Cwac posting
Omgus
Lowkey riding/sheeping
Afraid to touch someone..
Vote lynch Kiwiporn
Can u enlighten us how u arrived with this list?
This is your opener and you were tryna insinuate that you worry about inactivity and reads but you didn't actually contribute to advance the case. What you wrote here is a blatant cwac.
Later on, you dropped rvs on 3 people to tryna get players reaction, whereas Kiwipom has met your requirement. Nonetheless, it didn't bring any value onto the table. Scummy behavior point 1.
@Finalbeta i wasn't tryring to debunk TAC with his SK opener.. I was asking him why he didn't mention mafia right there. Reading his subsequent posts, I understand what he was implying although, both sk and mafia are threat to us and both a equally priority.. There has to be an equal treatment on how to detect them day and night... There should be no discretion which scum to locate first..
So far, can u tell what you think of reborn and kiwiporn?
[automerge]1568947174[/automerge]
Celestia and Naomi... Although I love the two girls.. Lmao.. They haven't posted any substantial material just yet and you read them as town.. If norikaflavor played then I would suspect that you'd also read the mod as a townie.. You're such a bias lad and I don't grasp how you arrive with this reads..
Below is a lowkey omgus. Playa dropped an rvs on you and you suspected him back. A town wouldn't meltdown with this typical play but laugh it out. He wanted to have a response and he got what he wanted from you.. Scum behaviour point 1.
Another one. Below you just sheeped all the way hardly on TAC's arguments. This is also a scummy behavior and you already have 2 points there.. Can't you build your own case? Can't you read through people's post? Can't you say something your own words to contribute to town?
Let's see what else he saw.
You seem to be too afraid to touch someone here. That's my assumption. Why? In every posts, we can find even the slightest hint as to what the specific player's intention is. Points 3...
To sum it up, you're just posting for the sake of posting and acting like you are contributing but of less value. This is the most typical manner of a scum in order to blend in.. Looking at all the parameters I have mentioned above, you have just created your own grave..
Tryna blend in
Cwac posting
Omgus
Lowkey riding/sheeping
Afraid to touch someone..
Vote lynch Kiwiporn
Can u enlighten us how u arrived with this list?
This is your opener and you were tryna insinuate that you worry about inactivity and reads but you didn't actually contribute to advance the case. What you wrote here is a blatant cwac.
Later on, you dropped rvs on 3 people to tryna get players reaction, whereas Kiwipom has met your requirement. Nonetheless, it didn't bring any value onto the table. Scummy behavior point 1.
@Finalbeta i wasn't tryring to debunk TAC with his SK opener.. I was asking him why he didn't mention mafia right there. Reading his subsequent posts, I understand what he was implying although, both sk and mafia are threat to us and both a equally priority.. There has to be an equal treatment on how to detect them day and night... There should be no discretion which scum to locate first..
So far, can u tell what you think of reborn and kiwiporn?
[automerge]1568947174[/automerge]
Celestia and Naomi... Although I love the two girls.. Lmao.. They haven't posted any substantial material just yet and you read them as town.. If norikaflavor played then I would suspect that you'd also read the mod as a townie.. You're such a bias lad and I don't grasp how you arrive with this reads..
Last edited:
I'll be honest, you ain't wrong. If you go check my sign ups...I didn't actually want to play because I said I'm not good at being suspicious of people and building my own case but I'm trying 
I totally understand why you would suspect me, I'm just trying to contribute since I feel like I didn't do much last game
idk what you're saying here lol
please don't butcher my name to that extend
I totally understand why you would suspect me, I'm just trying to contribute since I feel like I didn't do much last game
idk what you're saying here lol
please don't butcher my name to that extend
I don't think Kiwipom is a scum. She is being very proactive and vocal as I said earlier and not dodging anything that raise red flag. That's why I placed her in my good list.
Also as I said earlier, we must avoid any wrong lynch at any cost. The consequences are too much as it will affect our majority significantly. Losing 3 townie before day two begins is too much of a risk.
But no lynching should be our least priority. As we will still lose two townie at night.
We should try as much as possible to get some idea about who could be suspect. If we feel we have enough info then we can proceed with lynching or else we can dump the idea. Both scenario will help us in getting more experience.
Also as I said earlier, we must avoid any wrong lynch at any cost. The consequences are too much as it will affect our majority significantly. Losing 3 townie before day two begins is too much of a risk.
But no lynching should be our least priority. As we will still lose two townie at night.
We should try as much as possible to get some idea about who could be suspect. If we feel we have enough info then we can proceed with lynching or else we can dump the idea. Both scenario will help us in getting more experience.
- Status