Game 01: Generic Mafia [Game Thread]

[Reborn]

also, both made a follow up post about how this was all part of their 'strategy' and how it worked....even though imo, it seemed a bit far-fetched. None of those strategies contributed to catching the SK and Gambit just jumped on the Celestia wagon to save himself at the end

That's more of a reason to believe that neither of them could be scums.
There was no strategy involved in catching Celestia. So anyone claiming it doesn't lead us to catching scum.

Tbh, It could go either way with these two. But gambit is more active and very vocal

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

Okay I did some little research....

Playa last post here and a general post was made here 10 hours ago.

Now, the best case could be that he went busy in real life.

But I checked profile post section where he liked a profile made at around 7 hours ago.

And, then I clicked on profile post of Playa and found that he was last seen 3 hours ago. This imply he was active on Worst gen forum but then why he didn't care to post here?

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

@Kiwipom @Naomi @TheAncientCenturion @Vonal what you think of above little research of mine

 

[Kiwipom]

And, then I clicked on profile post of Playa and found that he was last seen 3 hours ago. This imply he was active on Worst gen forum but then why he didn't care to post here?

Before we jump to conclusions, there is the possibility that he has time to check the quick threads but not enough to catch up with this thread and post...that happened to me in the last game

I think he is choosing to not be involved though, I’m not gonna iterate, we all know why he might be scum and purposely taking the back seat

How many votes for him right now? Not to forget, there is also a vote on TAC

 

[Naomi]

That's more of a reason to believe that neither of them could be scums.
There was no strategy involved in catching Celestia. So anyone claiming it doesn't lead us to catching scum.

Tbh, It could go either way with these two. But gambit is more active and very vocal

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

Okay I did some little research....

Playa last post here and a general post was made here 10 hours ago.

Now, the best case could be that he went busy in real life.

But I checked profile post section where he liked a profile made at around 7 hours ago.

And, then I clicked on profile post of Playa and found that he was last seen 3 hours ago. This imply he was active on Worst gen forum but then why he didn't care to post here?

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

@Kiwipom @Naomi @TheAncientCenturion @Vonal what you think of above little research of mine

could be busy, or he just lurking. though i do know people find vanilla roles to be less motivating.

 

[Haku]

I think it's natural to be suspicious. Aren't you suspicious of those who still haven't posted?

Well yes, I guess it makes sense, is a bad strategy on mafias part but i have seen staying quiet work for mafia. So I don't blame you

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

could be busy, or he just lurking. though i do know people find vanilla roles to be less motivating.

I personally don't mind vanilla roles, they just boring during the NP. during DP they are the same as almost every role...

 

[Kiwipom]

Day phase is ending soon, I’ll log off with this:

Vote Lynch Rej

Vonal temporarily cleared my suspicion

Playa seems like an easy target for mafias to redirect our attention to so I’m not jumping on the bw just yet

My other suspect is Gambit but I’ll just keep an eye on him for now.

Rej however, I think he is unpredictable and he votes on players that imo don’t show any suspicious signs

 

[Reborn]

@Rej @Gambit @Naomi @Bogard @Finalbeta @playa4321 @TheAncientCenturion @Haku @Vonal

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

Here are votes so far

Playa has two votes from Bogard and tac

Tac has one vote from rej

Rej has one vote from kiwi

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

Only less than one and a half hour left before day 2 concludes.

It's high time that all of you give your final opinion now instead of being inactive or lurking

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

 

[Tyki_Mikk]

Sry for no having time but even If I probably get lynch here, I gonna help against the villians with this post.

The first Lynch count(I don't get the second)
Rej >Rej>TheAncientCenturion>Bogard>TheAncientCenturion>Bogard
Reborn > Rej
Playa4321 > Kiwipom
Gambit > Kiwipom
Naomi > Gambit
TheAncientCenturion > Gambit
Kiwipom > Gambit

Vote Count

Rej - 1 vote
Gambit - 3 votes
Kiwipom - 2 votes
Bogard - 1 vote

Non Voters

Vonal
Celestia
Haku
Finalbeta
Bogard

As we know we take on the serialkiller in the first day, I would focus on the guys who vote don't vote in the first day and the one who vote against Gambit.

Tac is suspect since the first day, he already vote without any reason against Gambit, but I think he doesn't seems to me like a villian. From the users who don't vote in the first place, my vote would go against Vonal. He vote against me after seeing many user vote against me aswell. Not even any reason in his vote.

Vote Lynch Vonal

 

[Reborn]

Is this the way mafia game is played? If yes, then it's hell boring. And, if no, then this is embarrassing game play by us.

Logging out now.

 

[Tyki_Mikk]

Last 8 minutes, seems like everyone going into sleeping modus. To save my life I Unvote Vanol for first and give my Vote Lynch Kiwipom

Is this the way mafia game is played? If yes, then it's hell boring. And, if no, then this is embarrassing game play by us.

I can understand why wo many players are inactive, probably their first mafia game and they want to check first. Or they having no much time. Even I don't get much time yesterday. Look forward Im sure user gonna getting their fun when they understand this game.

 

[Noctis]

Votes Are locked

Give me a filler post.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

 

[Reborn]

Last 8 minutes, seems like everyone going into sleeping modus. To save my life I Unvote Vanol for first and give my Vote Lynch Kiwipom

Kiwi pom has no vote. Check my second last post.

It's tac and rej who have one vote. And, I think could be townie (60-40)in your favor. But your lack of activity became huge hindrance to save you

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2019

Oh it's locked... I think Playa is lynched then

 

[Tyki_Mikk]

It's tac and rej who have one vote. And, I think could be townie (60-40)in your favor. But your lack of activity became huge hindrance to save you

Yeah sadly I don't get the time yesterday, but this could help you very much I trink, I would check up Tac and Bogard, they are very suspect since the first day. Gambit is also a think,he start to opening the possiblty of me beeing a villian yet he don't vote in the end. But in that case probably he was just inactiv as me because that he couldn't vote.

For my last words, I would check up the first day and second day who vote against who, probably you guys can get informations about the gameplay of the villians.

 

[Noctis]

Final Vote Count​

Votes

Rej >TheAncientCenturion
Playa4321 > Vonal> Kiwipom
TheAncientCenturion > Playa4321
Kiwipom > Rej
Bogard > Playa4321

Vote Count

Playa4321 - 2 vote
Rej - 1 votes
Kiwipom - 1 votes
TAC - 1 vote

Non Voters

Vonal
Haku
Reborn
Gambit
Finalbeta
Naomi

-----------------------------------------------------------

Playa4321 will get lynch this phase

His role is Vanilla Town​

NP2 has officially started. Please submit your action within the time limit. The NP will be about 12 hours long.

Players :

1. @Reborn
2. @playa4321
3. @TheAncientCenturion
4. @Finalbeta
5. @Kiwipom
6. @Bogard
7. @Haku
8. @Vonal
9. @Gambit
10. @Rej
11. @Naomi

 

[Rej]

Filler

 

[Noctis]

NP2 has officially ended. With that,

@Gambit has been killed, his role is Mafia Blocker.

@Finalbeta has been killed, his role is Macho Cop.​

The Day Phase will be about 24 hours long.

1. @Reborn
2. @TheAncientCenturion
3. @Finalbeta
4. @Kiwipom
5. @Bogard
6. @Haku
7. @Vonal
8. @Gambit
9. @Rej
10. @Naomi

Note: @Haku and @Rej vote will not be counted in this phase due to not completing the post requirement last phase. 2nd offense either will mod kill or sub out

 

[Vonal]

Nice one Vet.
Bad that we lost 2 townies, including the cop.
Sorry Playa for suspecting you.
Now that my 2 main suspects are gone, I get back to square one.
I know that it’s a bit off but I will say anyway, back in DP1 Gambit could choose between Celestia and Bogard to go to RNG with, he chose Celestia, maybe bcuz Bogard can be his scumbuddie? :unsure: I know it’s a bit off and actually it’s a rather weak ass case, I’m not saying Bogard is scum and I won’t vote him for that but it’s just a reminder.
Anyway, we have work to do, now that the cop is out it will be a bit more difficult do catch the other scum.

 

[Bogard]

Sorry for doubting you @playa4321 , but you were just too suspicious in my eyes, with your inactivity not helping, but luckily we got the mafia blocker this night. I'd do whatever it takes to correct that mistake

It's bad we lost the cop though especially a good one like FB

I know that it’s a bit off but I will say anyway, back in DP1 Gambit could choose between Celestia and Bogard to go to RNG with, he chose Celestia, maybe bcuz Bogard can be his scumbuddie? :unsure: I know it’s a bit off and actually it’s a rather weak ass case, I’m not saying Bogard is scum and I won’t vote him for that but it’s just a reminder.
Anyway, we have work to do, now that the cop is out it will be a bit more difficult do catch the other scum.

Gambit almost made me suspicious when asking me why I wanted to wait for others to post that could potentially help me to find mafia, because I talked about the cop. Would be a stupid work from mafia if it was the case. At the beginning of DP1, mafia had no way to know who was town or SK, so whoever he chose at that moment would have been like a gamble. With that said I do think that mafia letting me alive could have been part of their plan though since they would know I'd become an easy target due to initiating a mislynch on Playa, but for anyone who would look deeper into my posts, you'd see that I gave multiple chances to Playa to defend himself before voting him. That's because I wasn't sure myself but since he was very inactive, and that I was about to go to sleep, decided to gamble on it. Unfortunately it was a wrong gamble

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Oh shit I'm sorry @playa4321. Your strategy just seemed really off to me. T be fair I also doubted Gambit for the same strat but I thought since he talked so much, you were sketchier.

 

[Naomi]

Sorry guys for not sticking to killing gambit day 1. (gawd damn it lol) but final got celestial sk. and was not here for end phase because i was sleeping.


So 1 mafia left. This is good, but we lost final T_T