Okay the Nika thing I'll give you - but what is the point in me stalling endlessly about it? I could have simply just not paid it any regard.
The Reborn thing is silly. Essentially, you're holding it against me for voting a player who was an active scum read beyond one who was just *there*, would you rather I have postured and said "hmm well, I don't like cfds so I'll ignore this chance to flip my best bet for scum"
The claims argument is a meme frankly - I do lean on mechanics a good deal (despite what Magic claims for some reason) and I think the only one you can accuse me of being extra on is X, in which case, I'll point out that I settled for an explanation on his target. Your final point is ascribing motivation to me - I cannot possibly defend that hime.