I prefer him dead
It makes his whole presence and actions more impactful
He knew it was coming and still went with glory
At least a real death and not a weird fake out
Aye that's true, I really didn't like Oda confusing us with his status of being alive or not. A fake out would def very much worse too.
Gave us some of the best panels and dialogue, so much character in so few panels. Simplicity done right.
I really like these honorable characters especially on the evil side that show nuance to them too.
His line about that we only live once so let's not waste it, really hits different especially coming from a prestigious member of the most evil, oppressive faction in the series.
I guess like Yasuie, he shone bright whilst he lasted, brightest candles burn the fastest.
He really went out with honour, glory and pride as you said and left a truly lasting impact on us. Mr Goat indeed.
His dynamic with Drake whilst it lasted, was very interesting whilst it lasted so briefly too.