Powers & Abilities Killer uses poisonous blades(Zoro vs Killer analysis)

yj

👑YNWA 👑
Not really, Luffy was hungry when he fought Katakuri that's not an excuse

Zoro was nerfed but Killer was more nerfed
Zoro:
Losing Shusui

Killer:
-Bandaged
-Not using his main weapon
Anyway Zoro is stronger than Killer nobody is denying that but for me they are around the same level
luffy almost died to a poisonous fish but when it comes to zoro it doesn’t count. ur agenda against zoro stinks.zoro whopped killer gtfo they ain’t equals for shit.
 
Well Zoro didn't say I was hungry when he wake up but blame himself for carelessness. Sooo Nope

This is basically the same when people were in denial with Sanji in Punk Hazard. What comes around turn around. Lolz
At least Sanji getting wounded has something to do with the "excuse" Sanji fans use, Caesar and the giant children actually hurt Nami in Sanji's body. And that was underlined at least two times in PH.

The reason behind Zoro's fainting being the fact that he was hungry when he lost conscience like 10 second after he was stabbed is completely absurd.
Being hungry or poisoned was never mentioned to be a problem for Zoro, he was completely fine before the blow
 
I quote a message from one of the best users in WG
Samurai are supposed to hide their hunger because showing it is considered shameful. In the Hagakure, it says a samurai should always have a toothpick so they can appear as if they just finished eating. It's important to hide your poverty or unmet needs when you're a samurai, because someone can use that against you. There's another bushido saying about how even if your stomach is empty, it's shameful to feel hunger.

All of the stomach issues and poisoned water and Bepo having the runs is just samurai story stuff, for real. That's why Otama was hiding her stomach pains, too. I think Momo has a similar line somewhere. You guys read Vagabond? The samurai diarrhea is real, man. Zoro was ignoring his stomach and gut problems for so long that he didn't even feel it, like a real samurai would. That's Zoro hype from Oda, not an insult. I don't get the controversy-- I'm not trying to be snarky. I just don't understand what the other side was arguing.
Zoro won't admit that he fainted due to hunger, he would rather say that he was too careless.
But that doesn't change that he actually fainted due to hunger (as showed in both anime and manga), no matter how harsh he can be to himself.
This is bushido
 
I mean it doesn't really matter:
It should be pretty obvious to any rational fan that Killer got stomped by Zoro.

Objectives: Killer's objective was to fulfill Orochi's orders so that his crew will be kept alive. So he needed to kill the girl.
Zoro's objective was a to save two random strangers he met.
Who completed their objective: obviously Zoro.

The fight itself:
1. Gyukimaru interferred with the fight, which caused Zoro to get hit.
2. Killer got one shotted by Zoro afterwards.
3. Zoro falls unconcious from the hit that was caused by Gyukimaru's interference. However, he completes his objective in saving Hyori and laughing girl

You can argue full strength or not all you want, but two facts remain.
Zoro one shoted Killer and he completed his objective. He's undisputed winner of the fight.

And who cares if Zoro fainted or not. He already completely his objective. People forget that One piece has a storyline and isn't entirely focused on 1 v 1 fighting. Characters often have inconsistent feats based on the storyline. For instance, we saw Crocodile get beaten by beginning of series luffy and then later do impressive things to top tiers during Marineford.

Now, if we want to get a little subjective, if Killer was on Zoro's level, shouldn't we expect him to at least last longer. He was in a better situation. Zoro has to guard the girl at all times. And finally, he landed a blow on Zoro. But he couldn't stop Zoro from one shotting him. Whats to say in a fair 1 v 1 fight, Zoro couldn't do the same. And Killer hasn't shown the ability to land a blow without help on Zoro.
 
S

SinOfGreed

How the fuck are people still being so obviously biased against Zoro? You denied it when manga happened and now the anime confirmed the truth, you will still blindly deny it.

Zoro had been consuming poisoned food/water. Getting stabbed obviously affected him but we've seen him stay standing from much worse.

Why add the detail of his stomach grumbling if it was not significant in him passing out? And you don't pass out from 'lack of skill' so idk why everyone uses Zoro's convo after the fight to explain why he fainted.

Poison+stab combo led to him fainting so his plot line with hiyori could continue. It isn't hard to understand
 
Not really, Luffy was hungry when he fought Katakuri that's not an excuse

Zoro was nerfed but Killer was more nerfed
Zoro:
Losing Shusui

Killer:
-Bandaged
-wasn't using his main weapon
Anyway Zoro is stronger than Killer nobody is denying that but for me they are around the same level
They are on the same level on a 2v1 where Killer got one shot and whete Zoro was hungry ?... can you explain your reasoning ?
Post automatically merged:

Zoro ate sushi and drink a booze earlier when he meet Yasuie, so how many days passed after he met yasu?
How many days passed for Luffy to look like a dried fruit in WCI after his Cracker fight ?
How many days have past before BM starts losing weight?
Post automatically merged:

his lack of skill got him hurt, how are you guys reading here that hunger played no factor in him passing out is beyond me though.
The worst part is that the ''glurg'' sfx was taking half the panel but didn't convince them...then a year later, the anime does it again with sound and still didn't convince them...
At this point, even if Oda says ''IT WAS HUNGER'', they will still deny it and find a way to downplay...
Post automatically merged:

if he wanted to show that Zoro passed out via some other reasons, he would have flat out have zoro state it. But no, Zoro never mentions that he was hungry or some bullshit. So what happened then?
Oh right !
Because drawing a ''hunger'' sfx on half the panel wasn't enough...
He needed to make Zoro say it, and why not 2 or 3 other characters confirm it just to please some people with reading/comprehension problems ?
 
Last edited:
The worst part is that the ''glurg'' sfx was taking half the panel but didn't convince them...then a year later, the anime does it again with sound and still didn't convince them...
At this point, even if Oda says ''IT WAS HUNGER'', they will still deny it and find a way to downplay...
like obviously the wound he received from killer was a factor as well, but if the author literally puts the same sfx from when luffy was starving in wci in that panel, thats no coincidence lmao.
 
Sorry but it doesn't really make a whole lot of sense. If Killer used poisonous blades, then it's not going to be some kind of weak poison that can just be slept off. Oda treats poison pretty seriously in the manga. Even Luffy who is supposed to be immune to many types of poison almost died from eating a poisonous fish.

There is also the fact that Killer wounded Hiyori, which I am assuming happened with his scythe, and she didn't pass out from poisoning. And if she poisoned also, but didn't pass out, then damn, she must be a beast.
 
Sorry but it doesn't really make a whole lot of sense. If Killer used poisonous blades, then it's not going to be some kind of weak poison that can just be slept off. Oda treats poison pretty seriously in the manga. Even Luffy who is supposed to be immune to many types of poison almost died from eating a poisonous fish.

There is also the fact that Killer wounded Hiyori, which I am assuming happened with his scythe, and she didn't pass out from poisoning. And if she poisoned also, but didn't pass out, then damn, she must be a beast.
I never understood this ''poison'' stuff; the 'sfx' was clearly hunger and as seen previously, it is no joke.
So this ''poison'' thing is either a strawman, Analphabetism or some kind of messed up plan to refute everything later lol
 
Top