Why?
Do you think Oda did him and the wsss justice?
Especially when no top swordman seeks to fight or beat Mihawk as pirates seek To challenge yonko or be PK
Also when WSS candidates Are PH Law and DR Zoro... This alone cancels any credibility that the title is really legit as even Admiral rank.
Oda treated the title just fine
It's the fans who want to find any excuse to shit on it for whatever agenda of their own powerscaling
- Mihawk has never been in Wano? First of, Headcanon! We don't know that... Just because Oda didn't mention it doesn't mean it didn't happen... hell, maybe when we get to see Mihawk's flashback waaaay later in story to see his journey, we see him entering Wano. So that's just headcanon with all respect
- He has never fought a Yonko version of Shanks, and Shanks was stated to have his biggest infamy and influence due to Mihawk, still... so basically Shanks was recognized for his strength due to Mihawk... in other words, he became recognized as a Yonko because of it. It's the same as how Garp became "hero of marine" because of Rocks...
- Has not faught any top tier swordsman? Not true, Shanks was top tier. Otherwise, Whitebeard wouldn't call their duels legendary... dude, YFM duels are not considered legendary by yonko.. yonko only recognize their equals to call them legendary. Just because Shanks didn't have the title of yonko then, it doesn't mean he's not as strong or at least SO much close that the gap is so thin that both Mihawk/Shanks closed it during the past 10+ years as both can grow, not just Shanks
- Has not beaten Vet swordsman like Vista...? Sure, that's cause you miss Mihawk's personality.... go rewatch his duel with Zoro, which he could have ended in one second, but then you will realize that because he's so bored, he wants a challenge, that he ends up giving the opponent all the time they need to show ALL their techniques... with Zoro? He went small knife, let Zoro use all his techniques, and then he finished him
With Vista, he told him "wouldn't show me the flower blade style, Vista" and Vista after he attacked, stated "what kind of flower should I make bloom next?" Basically means Vista still got SOOOOOO much techniques to show
And that's why Mihawk STILL didn't go for the kill, he wanted to see more from Vista before he goes serious for the kill
- Was easily replaced by the toys? You realize that Kaido made an alliance with another YONKO because of those toys... by his own god damn tongue! And not only that, he is going for Ancient weapons and One Piece also. To actually get the upper hand
You know nothing about what Vegapunk invented and what can this invention do
- Isn't considered a great pirate? Cause he has no crew... and he was never called a pirate... however he's called "Greatest and Strongest swordsman"
- Was not viewed as strong by Kaido? Crocodile? Marco?
First off, Croc attacked everyone with no concern. He attacked WB, Mihawk, Akainu! So basically Croc doesn't see those other two as strong huh
Secondly, with Marco that's headcanon, just because he asked Vista to back SH doesn't mean he didn't view him as strong as yonko... simply your crewmember is a swordsman like Zoro (Vista) who seeks to challenge the best from swordsmen, by Vista's own mouth he said every swordsman wants to face him... why wouldn't marco ask him to be the one interfering! Marco/Jozu/Vista were all shown to be almost on similar level, Marco stepped up to Kizaru, Jozu to Aokiji, Vista to Mihawk... don't know what you all complain about here
- Kaido? Kaido's words regarding the shichibukai is simply because the avarage level of shichibukai is not on level of yonko
By avarage, I mean that Shichibukai vary in strength, we start from buggy level to Moria/Croc/Jinbe/Law level to Doffy/Kuma/Hancock level to Weevle level to Mihawk level
Avarage is not the same as avarage for yonko captains who are all 4 almost similar in level so their avarage is so high compared to shichibukai
It simply doesn't mean that the top of shichibukai cannot compare to Yonko