Incoming? You're taking too long
Why did he fall off your list?
Nat, my dinner. No rushing.
You said there are no fax here. I'm going to say his anger last day phase sounded genuine to me. What changed was that he started putting effort, maybe not good enough to you, that's fine. He has fallen off for the moment. He could come back depending on his next actions this DP.
These are some reads:
Cobra
He is borderline trolling - he looks awful at the moment. Everyone and their mother talked about this, unless he gets serious soon (really soon), he'll be absolutely nonredeemable and most likely lynched. Marimo's ready, Tris looks like it to, and is on everyone's radar. If he turns out good or bad, I think town will benefit from the lynch.
It's worth looking at the after effects of his lynch. If he's town, then it's one suspect down, and others that have hidden under his shadow can be put in the spotlight. If he's scum, same effect, but town is looking really good with 2/4 scum gone. His lynch seems like a good idea to me.
Fallen
He is often slipping in and out of the game. That doesn't make me feel good, he has to constantly catch up and has a hard time adding anything new. He has also more or less participated. He says he will participate now but has recycled news with Jew, now 2 times this game. Which he should address.
@Fallen Prince
Rayan
He has put a little effort but not enough to convince... Anyone really. Including myself. He falls low in the probable townie list and unless he comes up today with some hard work, he has shown himself to be scummy.
To be fair even if I don't put you at 100% scum and maybe town you did some shady things yesterday
Please say more than just this. "Weird things" is not anything specific. Are you just talking about what he has done or something else?
Humor me and just pick someone, anyone. If everyone hesitates, there will be no
lynch jutsuing to push.
My thoughts haven't changed. Gambit, Zara and Fallen are the targets this Konoha ninja accepts

Not sure what to think of you Rayan (which is why I'm asking for your thoughts), nor Yo.
Dodged this question as far as I have seen. Are you being too careful or are you that confused?
Marimo
I need more from him. He is also low on the town list for me. He likes to talk about mechanics and posts unrelated to solving this game. The only time I have seen contribution from him was when he gave his vote too late. I tried to pick a fight with him, I still am with that lynch. Also my hunch.
Reborn
He is himself. I'll be completely honest, I feel like it will take me a long time to decipher him/his reasons/his posts/his targets for interrogation.
I will say trying to guess how Al would handpick the roles is extremely unconvincing for someone that has never had Al as host. Doesn't convince me at all. Rest of what he said sounds like what I have seen of him before, so neutral at the moment. I want to spend more time looking at what he has done.
Tris
She is somewhat missing but putting in effort, doesn't look like first game scum to me.
Sera
He doesn't act in a suspicious way to me at the moment. His whole bit with Reborn, I'd say he was more convincing. I don't know their past history so I can't comment on reborn adding sera to his list of possible, handpicked by Al, bad roles.
It's baseless. Though at this point it's also pointless to argue about it over and over. We'll see when mafia is outed whether you have a point here.
These are exactly my thoughts. In that same quote Reborn says "it's not baseless because you [Sera] never played with all" I explained above why this is not relevant.
Yo Tan Wa
I'm not sure. His act yesterday confirms nothing, anybody would point out it was suspicious.
@Fallen Prince . Did you go through all my posts? My initial start yes was scummy, bt i think there are enough posts for you guys to town read me if you read em.
His start does not town clear him, nor paint him as scum.
Jew
He seems very careful about his susses in general, trying to dig evidence, looks good for now.
Reborn and Gambit...I’ve already gotten in trouble for speaking in support of the former, but that’s not the reason why I get a weird vibe from him. He’s being just as active as usual, but something feels off. Gambit also makes me uneasy, but with two scum left, I doubt we’ll have them both causing a scene like that.
Still need to go over everyone else again, but I won’t be able to do that for another five hours or so.
[automerge]1596049204[/automerge]
Also, shit, was Neutral killed at night or after the phase started?! How’d I miss that??
Does he follow up with his reborn "weird vibe"? Not at all. So in the case you forgot,
@Jew D. Boy how do you feel about reborn now? He has talked a bit more.
Drag
He works hard but his experience makes me want to stay neutral from the moment.
I disagree on the point of Gambit having done nothing to prove he is good nor bad. When you start a fresh game of mafia, everyone is suspicious. It is by their actions that you can lead conclusions. Many people have developed an opinion on his reactions. You haven't, so does this mean Nat's original lynch is not based on something you consider to tip him over either edge? His reactions to neutral watcher sussing him for the day 1 opinion (I personally don't think this one is)? You have shown Reborn's opinion on Gambit's emotional derailment is not something you are convinced of. I asked you the Nat question because it's the last thing, IIRC, that was on Gambit's case that seems logical to me.
Nat
She is convinced Gambit is bad, and seems like he is nonredeemable to her. A player like cobra I can understand. But why Gambit? Is your hunch really that great? Other than that I haven't seen much stand out from her. An experienced player I am also having a hard time reading
and am completely not intimidated by
These are my honest thoughts/hunches from reading the game. I'll be taking a small break for the moment.