AL sama

Red Haired
Is it better to be miserable with the truth or happy with lies? If someone has an issue, you can't lie to them and switch up definitions to make them feel better. They would constantly get rejected by society inciting more anger and depression over time. Nothing good comes from convincing someone to root their problems in lies.
I'd rather take the truth but that's just me
 
It's vital to accept people for who they are eg you're not going to make someone who is obese lose weight by bullying them for their weight. Pretending it's for their own good is disingenuous as it evidently affects mental health negatively, prompting them to overeat more and gain even more weight to cope with depression.
Obese people should lose weight because they want to improve their health for their own sake. But to reach a state where they value their own health they must first feel accepted and valued as human beings.
It's a tricky fine line to walk for the people in their lives. We can't force something on others even if we think it's for their own good and ultimately benefits them.

The same can be applied to all other issues
+1000

Is it better to be miserable with the truth or happy with lies?
About living with love and legitimacy ?

How important and wise do you believe you are to think that you are entitled to say to people how to live their struggle ?

They would constantly get rejected by society inciting more anger and depression over time.
How about starting not doing that in the first place by putting your own desire on their way of life ?


Nothing good comes from convincing someone to root their problems in lies.
There is only one lie in this situation and it reside in the mind of random people that think they know life so much better than people in difficult situation that they can coatch them out of of their own personal war. This is the lie of the savior. This is purely egotistical.

You want to know how to respect a person ?

Read One Piece

And act like Luffy. Do not tell people how they must live their struggle. Let them fight their OWN battle, don't interfere UNLESS they ask you for help or there are about to do something life threatening.

Remember than a fat person already knows that they are fat and that it is unhealthy

Love your family without condition.

Its the BEST way for you to show them your support.
 
There is only one lie in this situation and it reside in the mind of random people that think they know life so much better than people in difficult situation that they can coatch them out of of their own personal war. This is the lie of the savior. This is purely egotistical.
We should be less judgemental in general. It will create a better society for everyone.
Now, the toxic side of the self acceptance movement tells people to 1000% accept their current state of being and not do anything to improve their lives. Any attempt to improve their situation or better themselves according to their own wishes will be met with rejection, contempt and passive aggressive bullying.
 
Remember than a fat person already knows that they are fat and that it is unhealthy

Love your family without condition.
I have a parent that has struggled with obesity all their life. The tireless fat shaming from their childhood peers and their own family made everything much much worse and gave them severe depression. When I was in middle school and they'd picked me up after class they'd never step outta the car lest the other students saw them. They'd ask me random out of context questions such as "do the kids in your class talk about your fat parent? Do they bully you for it??" when the kids from my class didn't even know who my parent is.
It's kinda like continuously telling a chain smoker to stop smoking because of the health issues it causes. They won't stop smoking and only be annoyed by you.
 
the toxic side of the self acceptance movement tells people to 1000% accept their current state of being and not do anything to improve their lives
I've never seen anyone said that.

Accepting people is letting them fight their own battle while legitimizing them. It a double positive in order help everyone.


Any attempt to improve their situation or better themselves according to their own wishes will be met with rejection, contempt and passive aggressive bullying.
Which is normal. It must be their choice and only theirs. Its not up to anyone to tell a person how to live their life.


I have a parent that has struggled with obesity all their life. The tireless fat shaming from their childhood peers and their own family made everything much much worse and gave them severe depression. When I was in middle school and they'd picked me up after class they'd never step outta the car lest the other students saw them. They'd ask me random out of context questions such as "do the kids in your class talk about your fat parent? Do they bully you for it??" when the kids from my class didn't even know who my parent is.
It's kinda like continuously telling a chain smoker to stop smoking because of the health issues it causes. They won't stop smoking and only be annoyed by you.
Indeed, I hope your parent is ok.
Yeah.. that's the problem with fat shaming. The biggest element comes from behaviors that are given out of love by the family..

I know that situation all to well. People who want for you to get better (because they love you) will always try to push you. But in reality this behavior is only reaffirming your own inner belief that you don't do enough to get yourself out of this situation. And so it make things worse.

The best behavior to adopt is sadly not something that is enough teached in society and that is what I call the "Luffy behavior":

Loving without condition, trusting the people we love to get out of their own battles alive and well and if they ask us for help (because trust leads to trust in return) then we must help them without conditions.

Love is trust
.
 

Uncle Van

Bullets don't hurt. But Taxes do.
It's vital to accept people for who they are eg you're not going to make someone who is obese lose weight by bullying them for their weight. Pretending it's for their own good is disingenuous as it evidently affects mental health negatively, prompting them to overeat more and gain even more weight to cope with depression.
Obese people should lose weight because they want to improve their health for their own sake. But to reach a state where they value their own health they must first feel accepted and valued as human beings.
It's a tricky fine line to walk for the people in their lives. We can't force something on others even if we think it's for their own good and ultimately benefits them.

The same can be applied to all other issues
Said nothing about forcing things on people or pretending it's for their own good. I clearly said it's wrong to lie to people and create false expectations.

The point is that lying isn't kindness. People have to hope and have a sense of control in order to want to change. Lying to someone would always lead them to disappointment since what they're chasing doesn't exist. If someone had a problem that outside of their control, how exactly does lying to them lead to a better life in the end? They'll always be walking on ice.

You can be 100% supporting with the harsh truth. There's no bullying or dismissal here.
 
Which is normal. It must be their choice and only theirs. Its not up to anyone to tell a person how to live their life.
Maybe I used confusing wording. I meant to say "Anytime the person with the problem wants or expresses the desire to improve their situation or better themselves according to their own wishes will be met with rejection, contempt and passive aggressive bullying"

The point is that lying isn't kindness. People have to hope and have a sense of control in order to want to change. Lying to someone would always lead them to disappointment since what they're chasing doesn't exist. If someone had a problem that outside of their control, how exactly does lying to them lead to a better life in the end? They'll always be walking on ice.
This I agree with.
 
The point is that lying isn't kindness.
What you don't understand is that saying "you are perfect the way you are, I support and Love you" is NOT a lie. Its the truth. The person is perfect the way they are simply for existing. Wether or not they are fat or with a mental illness, they are legitimate therefore PERFECT the way they ARE.

Its up to them, to fight their battle. Its THEIR truth. Not ours.

If someone ask you for advice, then yes, do give them advice, but your "truth" is only hurtfull if its unsollicited.


You can be 100% supporting with the harsh truth
1. There is no "harsh truth", its only yours.

2. No, you can't. Unless people directly ask you for your help.


If someone had a problem that outside of their control, how exactly does lying to them lead to a better life in the end?
Its up to THEM to understand that they need to ask you for help. Unless the situation is desesperate and extremely urgent and life threatenning (like suicidal attempts), the only way you can help a person is to support them and EVENTUALLY give them ressources to be helped if they need any.

For example, its not up to you or any of my family members to tell to a person with my condition to go to a psychiatrist. But there is nothing wrong for you guys to tell me that you have the number of one of those doctor if I ever feel the need to call them. Its called support. You wouldn't force your point of view on me, you would just show me that if I need you, you would be there.

I took me 10 years to call a psychiatrist. The day I finally did it was the day my family finally accepted my struggle and my legitimacy. I felt trusted and therefore it gave me the strenght to call for help.

You can't help someone who doesn't want to be helped or is feeling unlegitimated. All you can do, is be ready to stop them in case they are doing something very self-destructive, stand by them and wait for their words. Because don't mistake calm with the lack of battle. People in difficulty are in a CONSTANT state of WAR. And if they understand that they are helpless and FEEL that you support them, then, they will definitely ask you for help.

 
What you don't understand is that saying "you are perfect the way you are, I support and Love you" is NOT a lie. Its the truth. The person is perfect the way they are simply for existing. Wether or not they are fat or with a mental illness, they are legitimate therefore PERFECT the way they ARE.

Its up to them, to fight their battle. Its THEIR truth. Not ours.

If someone ask you for advice, then yes, do give them advice, but your "truth" is only hurtfull if its unsollicited.



1. There is no "harsh truth", its only yours.

2. No, you can't. Unless people directly ask you for your help.



Its up to THEM to understand that they need to ask you for help. Unless the situation is desesperate and extremely urgent and life threatenning (like suicidal attempts), the only way you can help a person is to support them and EVENTUALLY give them ressources to be helped if they need any.

For example, its not up to you or any of my family members to tell to a person with my condition to go to a psychiatrist. But there is nothing wrong for you guys to tell me that you have the number of one of those doctor if I ever feel the need to call them. Its called support. You wouldn't force your point of view on me, you would just show me that if I need you, you would be there.

I took me 10 years to call a psychiatrist. The day I finally did it was the day my family finally accepted my struggle and my legitimacy. I felt trusted and therefore it gave me the strenght to call for help.

You can't help someone who doesn't want to be helped or is feeling unlegitimated. All you can do, is be ready to stop them in case they are doing something very self-destructive, stand by them and wait for their words. Because don't mistake calm with the lack of battle. People in difficulty are in a CONSTANT state of WAR. And if they understand that they are helpless and FEEL that you support them, then, they will definitely ask you for help.

Wait what are y'all arguing about
 

Uncle Van

Bullets don't hurt. But Taxes do.
Wait what are y'all arguing about
I said:
I ain't reading all that for nothing.

I'll stick to telling people that they can always improve themselves and change, and not be so reliant on the approval of other people. Telling people that they are perfect(aka hit their limit and a blatant lie) and need the approval and acceptance of other people to live a human being is stupid as fuck.
Logiko took it as me being cruel and dismissing people's struggles, and how much he cares for people.
 
Logiko took it as me being cruel and dismissing people's struggles, and how much he cares for people.
Again.. you are speaking with your biases and as always - sigh - deforming what I say.

I did not say that it was cruel. I said that it was toxic.

Toxic means that the word you use have a toxic effect on people you uses them on. (that's why I often use the term "toxicity" on this forum). You can perfectly have a toxic behavior out of love.

I truly believe that you are well intentioned. But the reality is that no matter how much love you have for a person. If you explain to them how to live or fight their struggle at their place, it will result in a systematic negative effect.

Let people come to you for advice. Love people without conditions and trust them to find their own way in life.
 
Again.. you are speaking with your biases and as always - sigh - deforming what I say.

I did not say that it was cruel. I said that it was toxic.

Toxic means that the word you use have a toxic effect on people you uses them on. (that's why I often use the term "toxicity" on this forum). You can perfectly have a toxic behavior out of love.

I truly believe that you are well intentioned. But the reality is that no matter how much love you have for a person. If you explain to them how to live or fight their struggle at their place, it will result in a systematic negative effect.

Let people come to you for advice. Love people without conditions and trust them to find their ways in life.
If it were up to you, everything could be considered Toxic. That's another reason I can't stand, You're always up in arms for any little slight. Which is hilarious because that in itself is toxic.
 
If it were up to you, everything could be considered Toxic.
No. There is a few people here that I don't consider toxic. Don't make your case a generality mate. Also, I have a vision based on movement, which means that I only remember toxic behavior during a few week then there is a big chance that I forget about it.

(unless you are a special case like Bob)


You're always up in arms for any little slight
If by "little slight" you mean proper toxic behavior, then yes.
Which is hilarious because that in itself is toxic.
Oh the famous antipolitical and fallacious argument : "you are toxic because you report toxicity".

Its funny because I was threadbanned for that once.

Ahhh... The good old time.. When I was still very naive about the moral righteousness of the staff here


 
Top