General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Yamato fans headcanon:
We'll definitely get a big reaction out of her once Luffy defeats Kaido
Reality:
haha :) *looks at momonosuke*
Yamato fans headcanon:
She'll get to interact with the crew once they go looking for luffy
Reality:
Luffy in already in bandages somewhere with a wooden floor, Yamato already left Luffy, and is inside the skull dome leading the beast pirates and talking about Momo being her general
Most likely, Chopper is the one that bandaged luffy since:
1.He was close to Franky inside the dome
2. Franky was close to the Beast Pirates that wanted to fight
Interaction with the crew status:
SKIPPED
We'll definitely get a big reaction out of her once Luffy defeats Kaido
Reality:
haha :) *looks at momonosuke*
Yamato fans headcanon:
She'll get to interact with the crew once they go looking for luffy
Reality:
Luffy in already in bandages somewhere with a wooden floor, Yamato already left Luffy, and is inside the skull dome leading the beast pirates and talking about Momo being her general
Most likely, Chopper is the one that bandaged luffy since:
1.He was close to Franky inside the dome
2. Franky was close to the Beast Pirates that wanted to fight
Interaction with the crew status:
SKIPPED
Don't worry, if an L happen I will take it, now is not the time. But I think you should also be prepared to take a huge one..
You see, If I'm wrong, I still win, my conclusion would be wrong, but the setup and everything I noticed in the story is still here so my reasonning minus the conclusion would still holds a cadle in term of narration and possibilities of the story...
But if I'm right, I'm not only proving my point, I'm proving that EVERYBODY here was completely and utterly IGNORANT on the subject and completely full of themselves. I would be creating an earthquake so strong on that thread that it would be ripping a hole in all your missconceptions about storytelling in the span of a mear second..
So.. yes I'm prepared.. but don't forget that it could go my way too.. and if that happens.. I wouldn't want to be in your embarassing shoes.
Yes it do changes things, in fact the difference of treatment do changes things.
Rebecca was a main Arc character, the comparison with Carrot is therefore completely irrelevant.
You know that narratively, Morj was actually right to expect the fail of the raid. He just didn't take into account the development of the Gear 5.
Strange, I see the opposite
Luffy will probably not reject her, she will just change her mind
Damn, there are actually good mods on reddit. No wonder worstgen is becoming the place for the right wing confusionnist mascus and incel part of the One Piece fanbase if people like you guys find yourself at home here. Glad I'll be gone soon. Eww it stinks.
There are, you are just missing them
Yeah lol. Been the case for ages back on the OJ threads. You and many others were often arguing against me, yet never once did I genuinely consider that any of you (bar a special someone) may have previously been in an asylum.
Yet here we are, and we've somehow got the feet lickers, the mentally ill, and ravagerblade all united on one side. By default, simply being opposed to that makes you unquestionably in the right.
Got clowns whom I didn't even know existed until today, wallowing about the impact I've had on their lives. Utterly jobless doesn't begin to describe it lmfao
Ur right it truly isn't a surprise how they became so enamoured for Yamao. A retarded 28 year old, living in her parents' basement who's deluded herself into thinking she's someone that matters. You can see why they took so quickly to the character
Yet here we are, and we've somehow got the feet lickers, the mentally ill, and ravagerblade all united on one side. By default, simply being opposed to that makes you unquestionably in the right.
Got clowns whom I didn't even know existed until today, wallowing about the impact I've had on their lives. Utterly jobless doesn't begin to describe it lmfao
Ur right it truly isn't a surprise how they became so enamoured for Yamao. A retarded 28 year old, living in her parents' basement who's deluded herself into thinking she's someone that matters. You can see why they took so quickly to the character
Last edited:
Normally I don't bother into Nakama discussion because people are already set into their own thinking and point of view, that they skew everything without regard to anything else. But I'll humor you.
In your post, you glorify each character's traits and actions, so that it fit their Job/Role. But why can't you do the same to Yamato?
According to your technique, I will apply your reasonings to Yamato:
YAMATO - You could argue that Yamato is just a "combattant", but narratively, Yamato is much more than that: she has the Guardian of Wano Devil Fruit. The guardian DF is supposed to have enough strength to take the role as guardian/defender/protector if necessary. In theory, they are also here to not just defend, but also attacks offensively, which mean she as a combatant needs to go to... combat. The fact that Yamato is the one choosed by Oda and designed for that role is not innocent. Yamato is a woman driven by justice. In Wano, she is a functional combatant and guardian, and everything from her GUARDING Momo, stalling Kaido, defuse the bomb, motivate Momo, to her abilities of putting off the flames, freeze the bomb, enhanced mythical zoan durability to defend, are enhanced to reaffirme that characterization: The theme of the guardian, the combatant, her backstory. Everything in the story of her repressed childhood, idolizing Oden, loves freedom, wanting to set sail, is created so that she can guard Momo, Wano, and everything. That's why Yamato is fit for the job of Combatant and/or Guardian and the protector of Luffy.
YAMATO - Yamato is the Log Keeper. But she is not "just" a Log Keeper. Her entire characterization is designed to make her a great Log Keeper: Yamato is characterized as one who loves freedom. This trait of character is what permits her to go adventuring and explore the world, and write them down. Making her amazing for the job. But the post is not only enhanced through Yamato's cahracterization, it was enhance by the entire arc Yamato was in, a shackled and repressed character who wants freedom so that she can explore the world and WRITE all of it. The concept of "being a Log Keeper" was designed to be impactfull because Momo found confidence by reading his father's Log Book and the need for it to be urgent, because Yamato know some helpful info about reaching Laugh Tale from Oden's Log Book. All of that made the post very relevant in term of Narration.
YAMATO - Yamato is the Apprentice. At first sight, the milking of the relationship between her characterization and that post is not obvious, but a closer look is helpfull. In reality, the post is also an extension of Yamato's characterization and narrative. Yamato is one of the least experienced of the crew (they are 3, Chopper(Naivety)/Usopp(Cowardice)/Nami(Timidity)), she acts as a little sister of the crew. In a sence, Yamato is very similar to Chopper but when Chopper's thematic is focused around naivety, Yamato's thematic is more focused around inexperience. She is the one that doesn't know a lot about real pirate in outside world works. This is why Yamato is not only a Apprentice litterally but also figuratively. Yamato is the ones who observe and learn. She is the curious one and the one you need to teach when everything is burning around you. All of this thematic is extented by the fact that Yamato is from the Wano, she directely witnessed oppression and is guided by one thing Oden's Log Book: to help FREE Wano and explore the sea LIKE ODEN as Apprentice. You can also add to that that the role of the apprentice was her motivation and goal in helping the war during the raid of Onigashima.. and you got here the perfect job for Yamato. Making sence narratively because by helping the alliance wins the war, she can free Wano and set sail outside AS APPRENTICE and in term of characterization, a Princess who is jailed all her life to learn about the outside world, AS APPRENTICE.
---
See? I used your words to back my argumentts.
If you just put the correct words to everything AND have an open-minded thinking, you won't reject Yamato as much as you do.
In your post, you glorify each character's traits and actions, so that it fit their Job/Role. But why can't you do the same to Yamato?
According to your technique, I will apply your reasonings to Yamato:
YAMATO - You could argue that Yamato is just a "combattant", but narratively, Yamato is much more than that: she has the Guardian of Wano Devil Fruit. The guardian DF is supposed to have enough strength to take the role as guardian/defender/protector if necessary. In theory, they are also here to not just defend, but also attacks offensively, which mean she as a combatant needs to go to... combat. The fact that Yamato is the one choosed by Oda and designed for that role is not innocent. Yamato is a woman driven by justice. In Wano, she is a functional combatant and guardian, and everything from her GUARDING Momo, stalling Kaido, defuse the bomb, motivate Momo, to her abilities of putting off the flames, freeze the bomb, enhanced mythical zoan durability to defend, are enhanced to reaffirme that characterization: The theme of the guardian, the combatant, her backstory. Everything in the story of her repressed childhood, idolizing Oden, loves freedom, wanting to set sail, is created so that she can guard Momo, Wano, and everything. That's why Yamato is fit for the job of Combatant and/or Guardian and the protector of Luffy.
YAMATO - Yamato is the Log Keeper. But she is not "just" a Log Keeper. Her entire characterization is designed to make her a great Log Keeper: Yamato is characterized as one who loves freedom. This trait of character is what permits her to go adventuring and explore the world, and write them down. Making her amazing for the job. But the post is not only enhanced through Yamato's cahracterization, it was enhance by the entire arc Yamato was in, a shackled and repressed character who wants freedom so that she can explore the world and WRITE all of it. The concept of "being a Log Keeper" was designed to be impactfull because Momo found confidence by reading his father's Log Book and the need for it to be urgent, because Yamato know some helpful info about reaching Laugh Tale from Oden's Log Book. All of that made the post very relevant in term of Narration.
YAMATO - Yamato is the Apprentice. At first sight, the milking of the relationship between her characterization and that post is not obvious, but a closer look is helpfull. In reality, the post is also an extension of Yamato's characterization and narrative. Yamato is one of the least experienced of the crew (they are 3, Chopper(Naivety)/Usopp(Cowardice)/Nami(Timidity)), she acts as a little sister of the crew. In a sence, Yamato is very similar to Chopper but when Chopper's thematic is focused around naivety, Yamato's thematic is more focused around inexperience. She is the one that doesn't know a lot about real pirate in outside world works. This is why Yamato is not only a Apprentice litterally but also figuratively. Yamato is the ones who observe and learn. She is the curious one and the one you need to teach when everything is burning around you. All of this thematic is extented by the fact that Yamato is from the Wano, she directely witnessed oppression and is guided by one thing Oden's Log Book: to help FREE Wano and explore the sea LIKE ODEN as Apprentice. You can also add to that that the role of the apprentice was her motivation and goal in helping the war during the raid of Onigashima.. and you got here the perfect job for Yamato. Making sence narratively because by helping the alliance wins the war, she can free Wano and set sail outside AS APPRENTICE and in term of characterization, a Princess who is jailed all her life to learn about the outside world, AS APPRENTICE.
---
See? I used your words to back my argumentts.
If you just put the correct words to everything AND have an open-minded thinking, you won't reject Yamato as much as you do.
Except the is no difference besides panel time, wich you still have to provide evidence to why that makes her any different than the other girls
Again, so was Carrot, you keep insisting that she was something different when that perfectly explains how Oda handled her prior and after Whole cake, she was the main female ally of that arc and thats that
Again, so was Carrot, you keep insisting that she was something different when that perfectly explains how Oda handled her prior and after Whole cake, she was the main female ally of that arc and thats that
- Status