General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Logiko]

The story itself shows Robin is an archaelogist only for you to deny with your self-made role. How does Robin guide & show the ROAD to the end? By revealing history inside the Poneglyphs. Yes.

Yes. Robin is an archeologist in surface. In reality, she a cape giver. Simple.

Her post is archeologist, her function is cape giver. But I already explained that to you already with storytelling evidences and you dismissed it with a hand shake.. There is really no point is discussing storytelling with someone who doesn't care about it.

Yeah, many times. By saying you are criticizing the system for banning you, and will report anything which you deem provocations and insults.

Nah, I was just replying to you all those times (in fact you are the only one who is bringing on the subject of my ban again and again.. and again.. and again...

... and again.. lol. Strange.

On my part.. I never contested the ban, in fact I would go as far as saying that in a way, I deserved it for being not clever enough to understand that I was a target the moment I talked about systemic toxicity.

Now I know and I won't make the same mistake twice!

Do I need to put those again? You can stop here before I embarrass you even further

Go! Don't mind me. Give it all you got dear!

First time I encountered that term...

First time you encounter me ;)

Post automatically merged: Mar 5, 2022

He can just explain and give the meaning of the job by giving link to google if it’s really an official job that exists in the world to be applied in fictional world, but he chose to use the victim card and run with tail between his legs.

I mean it’s not that hard for an “analyst” to prove his own words right? We live in modern days, access to internet is almost unlimited

Our generation is really lost on narrative subtext isn't she?

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Yes. Robin is an archeologist in surface. In reality, she a cape giver. Simple.

Her post is archeologist, her function is cape giver. But I already explained that to you already with storytelling evidences and you dismissed it with a hand shake.. There is really no point is discussing storytelling with someone who doesn't care about it.

No need to talk about storytelling. Just give me the link of information anything about CAP GIVER or CAPE GIVER whether it’s an official job in real world or not. You also didn’t say FUNCTION you say JOB. Do you even know the difference?

And which one is it? CAP or CAPE? Because objectively speaking those two are completely different items. And what is CAPE GIVER?

I’m pretty sure you don’t even know what you’re talking about and too embarrassed to admit it

Nah, I was just replying to you all those times (in fact you are the only one who is bringing on the subject of my ban again and again.. and again.. and again...

... and again.. lol. Strange.

On my part.. I never contested the ban, in fact I would go as far as saying that in a way, I deserved it by being not clever enough to understand that I was a target the moment I talked about systemic toxicity.

Now I know and I won't make the same mistake twice!

Ah about time you admit you’re not clever enough. And there is nothing to debate then
:cheers:

Go! Don't mind me. Give it all you got dear!

“Go! Don’t mind me. Give it all you got dear!”

Our generation is really lost on narrative subtext isn't she?

Nobody’s talking about subtext. I want you to just give me any link of information whether the job CAP GIVER or CAPE GIVER or whatever bullshit you made exists or not. Don’t you like proving someone else wrong? Now it’s your time

 

[Logiko]

No need to talk about storytelling. Just give me the link of information anything about CAP GIVER or CAPE GIVER whether it’s an official job in real world or not.

And which one is it? CAP or CAPE? Because objectively speaking those two are completely different items. And what is CAPE GIVER?

I’m pretty sure you don’t even know what you’re talking about and too embarrassed to admit it

Wow! You are really good! You just found another mistakes of mine. But don't stop there, I'm sure there is a lot of hidden grammar mistakes in my other post! Don't mind me, I'm giving you the persmission! Gotta catch them all!!

Ah about time you admit you’re not clever enough. And there is nothing to debate then

You got me! I'm completely overpowered by your might. :cheers:

lol

Nobody’s talking about subtext.

I am.. If you'd care to read lol

I want you to just give me any link of information whether the job CAP GIVER or CAPE GIVER or whatever bullshit you made exists or not.

It's "cap giver". Don't work yourself out, you won't find it on google. It's a neologism to describe the function of Robin.

 

[Animangaboy]

Can you quote that ?

Go read chapter 1020 or u didn't because Yamato was getting so much panel than carrot u skip it and start at chapter 1026 cause I look u don't read yamato chapters

 

[Logiko]

Yamato already states her goal already want to liberate wano and give it to the samurai and also want to go out to sea with luffy.

Can you quote that?

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Wow! You are really good! You just found another mistakes of mine. But don't stop there, I'm sure there is a lot of hidden grammar mistakes in my other post! Don't mind me, I'm giving you the persmission! Gotta catch them all!!

Nah I’ve been doing it many times. Never needed your permission to do it after all. There are too many on the point they will lower my intelligence level if I really want to find them all

You got me! I'm completely overpowered by your might. :cheers:

lol

“You got me! I’m completely overpowered by your might. Lol”

I am.. If you'd care to read lol

The fact that I’m so much better in grammar & vocabularies than you means I read. It’s not rocket science
:cheers:

It's "cap giver". Don't work yourself out, you won't find it on google. It's a neologism to describe the function of Robin.

Okay, then you can just give evidence about neologism of CAP GIVER. Any link would work. Come on. It’s your time to shine. I know you can do it
:cheers:

 

[Logiko]

Nah I’ve been doing it many times. Never needed your permission to do it after all. There are too many on the point they will lower my intelligence level if I really want to find them all

Aww Too bad

“You got me! I’m completely overpowered by your might. Lol”

?

The fact that I’m so much better in grammar & vocabularies than you means I read. It’s not rocket science

And I'm sure that Tommy Wiseau has seen a lot of movies..

Okay, then you can just give evidence about neologism of CAP GIVER.

Searching evidence for the creation of a neologism is meaningless. I don't need evidence for that, I have narrative evidence for what this neologism is describing. But that was already explained to you. You just ignored it.

 

[Animangaboy]

Can you quote that?

Like I said go and read chapters 1016 - 1026 and u will see it cause ODA is the one that makes Yamato say and do everything in the story so if u read chapter 1016 u won't have this problem about Yamato leaving wano but I guess u have a bigger brain and better IQ than oda even a better writer too cause u always say what going to happen when no one predicts anything that u carrot fans been doing ODA can draw a panel with carrot smiling and u and the others will analyze and saying carrot is smiling because she is the ONE to guide the smiling rabbits WILL meanwhile ODA states that Yamato will leave wano and wants to go to sea with luffy but you guys saying it's not happening when ODA foreshow it so if I was u I will shut up cause there nothing showing or foreshow EVIDENCE or portrayal saying that carrot is joining the crew but I guess u know something WE dont as a reader

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Searching evidence for the creation of a neologism is meaningless. I don't need evidence for that, I have narrative evidence for what this neologism is describing. But that was already explained to you. You just ignored it.

I need to show this to my peers who are:

• An English language college instructor
• A graduate of Humanities with English major
• A graduate of Literature
• A mature One Piece fan who just enjoy the story

 

[Logiko]

I need to show this to my peers who are:

• An English language college instructor
• A graduate of Humanities with English major
• A graduate of Literature
• A mature One Piece fan who just enjoy the story

Oh? Ok! Go for it! And don't forget that the subject of this discussion is storytelling theory, story crafting and narrative deconstruction.. this should be right in their expertise!

 

[vikas]

I need to show this to my peers who are:

• An English language college instructor
• A graduate of Humanities with English major
• A graduate of Literature
• A mature One Piece fan who just enjoy the story

Let me show this thread to oda

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Searching evidence for the creation of a neologism is meaningless. I don't need evidence for that, I have narrative evidence for what this neologism is describing. But that was already explained to you. You just ignored it.

Wua? Who was talking about searching evidence for creation of a neologism? I was talking about you to give me proof of CAP GIVER whether it exists in neologism, and any link would work. If you know such thing exists, means that you know that is a source for that, and it doesn’t have to be from google. Books or any related books would do. Nobody was talking about any creation of it, I simply just want to know whether it exists or not.

You surely talk and write before you think, eh?

Post automatically merged: Mar 5, 2022

I need to show this to my peers who are:

• An English language college instructor
• A graduate of Humanities with English major
• A graduate of Literature
• A mature One Piece fan who just enjoy the story

C4N: “Robin’s job is not an archaeologist. Her job is Cap Giver”

Me: Cap Giver? What the fuck is Cap Giver?

C4N: I don’t have to explain to you because you don’t care

Me: well, you said that, so you need to prove whether that word exists or not

C4N: It’s a neologism

Me: okay then give me proof whether CAP GIVER exists in neologism or not

C4N: searching for the creation of neologism is meaningless

Me: who the fuck asking the creation of a neologism?

 

[Logiko]

Like I said go and read chapters 1016 - 1026 and u will see it cause ODA is the one that makes Yamato say and do everything in the story so if u read chapter 1016 u won't have this problem about Yamato leaving wano but I guess u have a bigger brain and better IQ than oda even a better writer too cause u always say what going to happen when no one predicts anything that u carrot fans been doing ODA can draw a panel with carrot smiling and u and the others will analyze and saying carrot is smiling because she is the ONE to guide the smiling rabbits WILL meanwhile ODA states that Yamato will leave wano and wants to go to sea with luffy but you guys saying it's not happening when ODA foreshow it so if I was u I will shut up cause there nothing showing or foreshow EVIDENCE or portrayal saying that carrot is joining the crew but I guess u know something WE dont as a reader

Done! And never Yamato says that her goal is to liberate wano and give it to the samurai. She only says (in chapter 1020) "I'm going to help the Samurai and protect this country from you, no more chains!! This country will open!!"

In fact Yamato is making my argument for me here..

Post automatically merged: Mar 5, 2022

Wua? Who was talking about searching evidence for creation of neologism? I was talking about you to give me proof of CAP GIVER whether it exists in neologism, and any link would work. If you know such thing exists, means that you know that is a source for that.

You surely talk and write before you think, eh?

Well then those proof have already been given to you. You just need to check the historic back a little.

Post automatically merged: Mar 5, 2022

C4N: “Robin’s job is not an archaeologist. Her job is Cap Giver”

Me: Cap Giver? What the fuck is Cap Giver?

C4N: I don’t have to explain to you because you don’t care

Me: well, you said that, so you need to prove whether that word exists or not

C4N: It’s a neologism

Me: okay then give me proof whether CAP GIVER exists in neologism or not

C4N: searching for the creation of neologism is meaningless

Me: who the fuck asking the creation of a neologism?

The problem in that tirade, is that you are forgetting that I have already explained that term multiple times here. So you just make a little effort, and go read the gosh damn explanation if you want to understand

 

[Rootbeer]

No. I'm doing a simple thing: Adding the relevancy for the REAL moment where Carrot will join the crew for something else that going on a fun adventure.

If you want to compare All those arc to the relevancy of Carrot, you will have to wait that One Piece ither finishes or arrives at a point where Carrot shine before being recruted.

There will be no real moment, Wano was Carrots last chance..

Future Strawhats won't be irrelevant in their introduction arc or any arc that they're in.. Carrot was insignificant in Zou, mostly irrelevant to the plot in WCI and again irrelevant in Wano.. Its over for Carrot she never gave main protagonist vibes...

Saying "this happened" but it is not relevant. Is the most higher level of direspect for the story. You are literally ignoring what is happening. There is no excuses for it.

Also "Big Moments" are not "Shining moments" they are "Big Moments" they are moments where the characters is highlited. If you want example of the scale of importance:

"Normal moments" - Carrot is chilling with the strawhat as part of the groupe
"Big Moments" - Carrot is highlited for a bit of panels
"Shining moments" - Carrot is the focus of the action of the chapter
"Decisive strawhat moment" - Carrot is the emotionnal focus of the chapter in relation to he character arc and her recruitment (this did not happened yet, this is what Robin "I want to live" scene + Flashback are)

To join the crew, you only need "Normal" and "big" Moments. Everything more is not a necessity for the narration when the character JOINS. But the character needs ALL 4 before being recruited.

Carrot has ENOUGH to join the crew. in fact Yamato also has enough to join the crew. The sole difference is that there are clews taht Carrot will get recruited afterward, and those clews are NON-existent for Yamato.

What you qualify of big moments are just normal moments and all those are negligible, they have no impact on the moving plot..
The Sanji and Carrot scene is meaningless, Oda has never established their bond it doesn't exist, everything about Carrot is all Smoke and Mirrors..

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

Well then those proof have already been given to you. You just need to check the historic back a little.

The problem in that tirade, is that you are forgetting that I have already explained that term multiple times here. So you just make a little effort, and go read the gosh damn explanation if you want to understand

I don’t give a fuck to your explanations. I just need to know whether CAP GIVER exists in neologism or not

 

[Animangaboy]

Yamato is making my argument for me here.

Please tell me where did it show that Yamato is staying in wano same what luffy say to kaido in chapter 1041 that he will draw out kaido out of wano so u trying to say that yamato is staying in wano to protect it where there are the samurai and the minks Idk what's with u saying Yamato "NEED TO"

 

[Uncle Van]

So Robin is no longer her canon position? Is that the new thing if I'm following correctly?

 

[Logiko]

There will be no real moment, Wano was Carrots last chance..

Future Strawhats won't be irrelevant in their introduction arc or any arc that they're in.. Carrot was insignificant in Zou, mostly irrelevant to the plot in WCI and again irrelevant in Wano.. Its over for Carrot she never gave main protagonist vibes...

Wano is indeed Carrot's last chance to stowaway. But the probability for this to happen is around 80-95% so I'm not afraid that Carrot will have a lot more time to shine later ;)

What you qualify of big moments are just normal moments and all those are negligible, they have no impact on the moving plot..
The Sanji and Carrot scene is meaningless, Oda has never established their bond it doesn't exist, everything about Carrot is all Smoke and Mirrors..

Every moments have an impact on moving the plot. Every last one of them.

I don’t give a fuck to your explanations. I just need to know whether CAP GIVER exists in neologism or not

A neologism is something that don't exist already my dude... Lmao xD

So Robin is no longer her canon position? Is that the new thing if I'm following correctly?

Robin is still an archeologist, that's her official post. But her real function is Cap giver.

Please tell me where did it show that Yamato is staying in wano same what luffy say to kaido in chapter 1041 that he will draw out kaido out of wano so u trying to say that yamato is staying in wano to protect it where there are the samurai and the minks Idk what's with u saying Yamato "NEED TO"

Don't move the goal post please. The discussion was about the words of Yamato.

 

[Animangaboy]

The discussion was about the words of Yamato.

I am asking u where did it states that yamato is staying in wano Minster analyze

 

[Logiko]

I am asking u where did it states that yamato is staying in wano Minster analyze

In the subtext.