General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Nuit Rouge]

True, though after Yamato told Momo he was crucial in bringing the dawn to the world, it seems as if that may end up being Yamato’s dream, while Carrot is just focused on kicking Perospero’s ass for Pedro, so we’ll have to see.

I was talking about Carrot...

 

[Un-amed]

Yamato is not free if follows Luffy because of a prophecy.
Yamato is a Barto 2.0 Buut with believing Luffy is the chosen one, and that's great for a side-character, but not for a Mugi at all.
+Yamato has no inherited will, no dream no nothing about it's own character.
IS STILL IN PROGRESS, so she could easily NOT join.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Yamato is not free if follows Luffy because of a prophecy.
Yamato is a Barto 2.0 Buut with believing Luffy is the chosen one, and that's great for a side-character, but not for a Mugi at all.
+Yamato has no inherited will, no dream no nothing about it's own character.
IS STILL IN PROGRESS, so she could easily NOT join.

The only reason she won't join is because she is the most obvious choice and oda likes to subvert our expectations

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Yamato is not free if follows Luffy because of a prophecy.
Yamato is a Barto 2.0 Buut with believing Luffy is the chosen one, and that's great for a side-character, but not for a Mugi at all.

This may be the only decent reason I’ve heard against Yamato. I see what you mean. All straw hats believe in Luffy, not n in some prophecy

 

[Nuit Rouge]

This may be the only decent reason I’ve heard against Yamato. I see what you mean. All straw hats believe in Luffy, not n in some prophecy

Maybe she'll change her view on him later.
I think it's a good point for Carrot. For Carrot, Luffy is the boss of the crew who literally saved her country. But in WCI, she saw him as a simple human.

 

[Electricmastro]

Yamato is not free if follows Luffy because of a prophecy.
Yamato is a Barto 2.0 Buut with believing Luffy is the chosen one, and that's great for a side-character, but not for a Mugi at all.
+Yamato has no inherited will, no dream no nothing about it's own character.
IS STILL IN PROGRESS, so she could easily NOT join.

Yeah, I can understand against joining just because he’s Ace’s brother and the presumption that he’s part of a prophecy. I get the feeling it will develop into Yamato joining because of Luffy’s own character and is worth going along with because she genuinely wants to though.

 

[Un-amed]

Yeah, I can understand against joining just because he’s Ace’s brother and the presumption that he’s part of a prophecy. I get the feeling it will develop into Yamato joining because of Luffy’s own character and is worth going along with because she genuinely wants to though.

I won't be """upset""" if he/she joins after being more developed...But i do not see that happening, Yamato is actually "cool" how it is right now...All the chances the character has to be a "mugi"... to """"Be""" , are present because of the way the character is, changing the Oden dynamic and his personal conflict about who the character is, can easily kill this ambition to sail with Luffy, or move the plot to somewhere unexpected...

 

[Paperchampion23]

Random thought, but i never understood why Oda made the Funk Brothers bad. They are the only major characters in DR that didn't end up becoming part of the fleet, yet had one of the coolest duo powers. Like I'm surprised they didn't join the group with Ideo. That one was simply a band of rag tag villains essentially.

Technically Elizabello and Dagama aren't either, but they are 100% going to be supporting kingdoms in the final war with Dressrosa.

Shame tbh

 

[Kurodiamondo]

Random thought, but i never understood why Oda made the Funk Brothers bad. They are the only major characters in DR that didn't end up becoming part of the fleet, yet had one of the coolest duo powers. Like I'm surprised they didn't join the group with Ideo. That one was simply a band of rag tag villains essentially.

Technically Elizabello and Dagama aren't either, but they are 100% going to be supporting kingdoms in the final war with Dressrosa.

Shame tbh

Yeah they got some good teamwork there

I think they did not join because they dont have gratitude or loyalty to their savior. Maybe oda think he need atleast one that is on opposition side just to make it sounds real
Weren't they the one that trap luffy?

Maybe oda saved them for later
[automerge]1625242542[/automerge]
Anyway, no one want to push wsw to join? lol. He got some good start with jinbe there.

 

[Rootbeer]

Carrot's train wreck moving onward to chapter 1019 and counting.:cheers:

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Anyway, no one want to push wsw to join?

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

Yeah they got some good teamwork there

I think they did not join because they dont have gratitude or loyalty to their savior. Maybe oda think he need atleast one that is on opposition side just to make it sounds real
Weren't they the one that trap luffy?

Maybe oda saved them for later
[automerge]1625242542[/automerge]
Anyway, no one want to push wsw to join? lol. He got some good start with jinbe there.

Why? WsW to join? He can become a captain of fleet is more easily to him

 

[Garp the Fist]

Carrot's train wreck moving onward to chapter 1019 and counting.:cheers:

Wouldn’t it’s moving forward. She’d have to actually appear and do something for it to move.

It’s more like the wreck of a train that has already crashed, burnt and lying desolate by the side of the tracks, rusting and covered with moss.

 

[Finalbeta]

Carrot's train wreck moving onward to chapter 1019 and counting.:cheers:

No avenging Pedro No withdrawal

 

[BOCCHI]

Eother Zoro gets bumped up to official first mate and Yamato becomes the fighter, or she gets the funny job of being an apprentice.

Don’t see chronicler at all.

Yamato may get a weird job, but even if she doesn’t nothing says she can’t be another fighter for the crew without an official role in the ship.

 

[Afroking]

Yamato may get a weird job, but even if she doesn’t nothing says she can’t be another fighter for the crew without an official role in the ship.

Might as well let everyone join if that is the case...
No she needs to have a proper one,even if it isn't deemed necessary,but at least she is better at it than the rest of the crew members..

 

[Garp the Fist]

Yamato may get a weird job, but even if she doesn’t nothing says she can’t be another fighter for the crew without an official role in the ship.

No, she’ll have her own role. It’s what Oda’s done for the other ten, it’s what will happen to Yamato.

 

[BOCCHI]

Might as well let everyone join if that is the case...
No she needs to have a proper one,even if it isn't deemed necessary,but at least she is better at it than the rest of the crew members..

She doesn’t have to. All that’s needed for Luffy to see Yamato’s worth and good attention/personality.
[automerge]1625262684[/automerge]

No, she’ll have her own role. It’s what Oda’s done for the other ten, it’s what will happen to Yamato.

i guess we will go with Yamato having a useless and funny role to satisfy this need you guys see necessary.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

yamato will be a strawhat member. the apprentice
grandfleet?
perhaps the samurai, azakaya nine ,
none of the executives on kaido's side seem redeemable.

 

[Garp the Fist]

i guess we will go with Yamato having a useless and funny role to satisfy this need you guys see necessary.

Yeah, we want Yamato to actually fit in with the crew and have her own unique thing, not jsut a half-assed “oh, she can do the same thing as Zoro, I suppose.”

This should not be a controversial opinion, lol, every Strawhat has their own role, so will Yamato. We don’t know what it is yet, but it’ll be uniquely hers, the same way she’ll have her own colour, her own animal, her own role in the family, her own country, all this trivia that Oda has given every other Strawhat so they stand out in the crew.