There's no established rule about how Sanji's super genes would manifest if it were to happen, Sanji losing inevitably his emotions is just an arbitrary rule you made up.
It's not a rule it's what judge did to ALL OF THEM. He manipulated them all the same. Sora's drug was supposed to stop the whole manipulation, not only the emotion part. So it makes no sense why only a part would manifest and not everything.
We already know he is very different from his brothers so if the theory is true, that would mean it doesn't have to work the exact same way for Sanj so it's pretty much up to Oda.
What do you mean? Sanji is different because he was lucky that the drug worked only on him. That doesn't mean that the manipulation would be different. It was even said everything worked on paper, so he was no different from his brothers, until the drug changed everything back to normal.
"It's up to Oda" is not an argument. Based on that you can say EVERY theory can happen, because Oda can do it...
I can also make a theory saying Luffy is gonna eat 3 DF's. That will never happend for many reasons. But hey! Oda can do it, so it's not impossible.
Oda doesn't care about my feelings or yours, Sanji getting the RS should be enough to stop expecting him to think like us.
Not really. There are alot of people who like the RS. The RS is a suit, not a manipulation.
Those things are not even comparable.
Oda spent a whole Arc making us clear that Sanji is a normal human. He is not as his siblings. Judge even used Sanji's wound when he got shot as a weakness, because he is not manipulated and has a exoskeleton, how he is too kind etc.
And Luffy said Judge is saying only the best things about Sanji. This whole Arc would be a waste of time, if Sanji stil ended up as his brothers.
If the whole manipulation DNA stil exist in Sanji's DNA, you think Judge and his scientists wouldn't have seen that and try to re-activate them?
A small fun fact, 2 chapters back Sanji could not use his CoA because he didn't want BM to get hurt. If he would have a exoskeleton he would always hurt every woman that would punch him. Ain't happening.