Bougya What if : every fake dead characters were really killed ? What would change in the story and plot ?
- Thread starter RayanOO
- Start date
I think if Pekoms had died too (as he should have been) PDA would have need someone to save the crew / to stall when Luffy vs Kata ended to stall the Cacao island BBP squad
so either he will make the Germa come sooner
or and it could have been fun : make half dead Pedro in sulong form come to stall and wreck havoc and really die this time
[automerge]1733397871[/automerge]
Pedro was dope
one of the best post skip side character with Cavendish
so either he will make the Germa come sooner
or and it could have been fun : make half dead Pedro in sulong form come to stall and wreck havoc and really die this time
[automerge]1733397871[/automerge]
If Pedro was allive One Piece would be better. 
one of the best post skip side character with Cavendish
- Pell nothing changes
- Bellamy slight change in Dressrosa but nothing big
- Robin wouldn’t be a straw hat
- Nothing Changes
- Big change in the story, Sabos death would alter too much
- Nothing changes so far
- Straw Hats would have zero way to get to WCI
- Nothing Changes
The deaths whether they’re real or not don’t change much of the narrative, but they give characters happy endings which is why Oda opts to make them survive.
- Bellamy slight change in Dressrosa but nothing big
- Robin wouldn’t be a straw hat
- Nothing Changes
- Big change in the story, Sabos death would alter too much
- Nothing changes so far
- Straw Hats would have zero way to get to WCI
- Nothing Changes
The deaths whether they’re real or not don’t change much of the narrative, but they give characters happy endings which is why Oda opts to make them survive.
Sabo’s fakeout is the only one that will have an impact. But I think Oda will just create a new right-hand for Dragon, the DR events will be most affected. Other shit that Sabo has done will just be transferred to the new right-hand.
Oda wants a Disney ending and tbh I don’t mind seeing characters I‘m attached to get such happy endings. That can still very satisfying for the majority of readers but some of these fakeouts are objectively bad from a writing perspective.
Oda wants a Disney ending and tbh I don’t mind seeing characters I‘m attached to get such happy endings. That can still very satisfying for the majority of readers but some of these fakeouts are objectively bad from a writing perspective.
Man I just like kuina and want to see a strong female swordsman
Also sabo and Saul’s fake out deaths don’t change how those “deaths” effected and molded Luffy or Robin
Also sabo and Saul’s fake out deaths don’t change how those “deaths” effected and molded Luffy or Robin
Luffy's and Robin's dreams aren't about a promise they made a deceased friend, that's a false equivalence.
Everything about Zoro's determination stems about Kuina being dead. His promise wasn't even about him becoming WSS, but about one of the two. Zoro knew Kuina was stronger than him back in the day and would have ultimately been fine with her growing to be the WSS. It's because she can't anymore that Zoro is proxy-carrying her dream through their promise.
Yes, Zoro has already been effected and molded, but he would still be cheapened as a character if it was suddenly all a lie. He could still save this angle by finally beating Kuina and carrying on, but the whole scenario would lose a ton of weight.
There's also a different angle: How far Zoro's gone for the memory of a friend... a friend that would have faked her death for absolutely no reason, and that for some reason didn't even trust him enough to let him know she was alive while Zoro was literally living for her in his own way.
Is there a satisfying way to write the plot out of that one without cheapening Zoro's character?
[automerge]1733413334[/automerge]
On the original run, yes. The solution to that for me was not taking DB's plot and death seriously.
I still try to take OP seriously (to a point).
When I watched in I kinda felt happy that he survived...Ofcourse It was early in series and he won't come back to story anyway.
Him suiciding gave the feels but also I wanted him to survive. It was early and first such thing so I was okay with it.
Why was he not killed after Jaya itself....who even thought it was a good idea to get this guy back...
Okay I guess...since it would play with Robin being a good person.
Worst...Ofcourse I expected atleast him being in a miserable condition in jail...but brah is free and leading 5.5....wtf
Doesn't matter much, but oda did not really make much use of him being alive. he is just a number..
Should have stayed dead...very forced entry back to story even though its not at all needed
Brah can't even remember this KEKW...
Should have died...wasted all his character. Imagine BM died but not this shit.....Her death was so bad his death was supposed to be so good....give it to oda to choose the worst decision he can
Though in the end majority of things(evven major ones) done in one piece so far turned out to be not at all important... I still can't think of anything which was absolutely necessary..and doing otherwise will mess up super badly..
Him suiciding gave the feels but also I wanted him to survive. It was early and first such thing so I was okay with it.
Why was he not killed after Jaya itself....who even thought it was a good idea to get this guy back...
Okay I guess...since it would play with Robin being a good person.
Worst...Ofcourse I expected atleast him being in a miserable condition in jail...but brah is free and leading 5.5....wtf
Doesn't matter much, but oda did not really make much use of him being alive. he is just a number..
Should have stayed dead...very forced entry back to story even though its not at all needed
Brah can't even remember this KEKW...
Should have died...wasted all his character. Imagine BM died but not this shit.....Her death was so bad his death was supposed to be so good....give it to oda to choose the worst decision he can
Though in the end majority of things(evven major ones) done in one piece so far turned out to be not at all important... I still can't think of anything which was absolutely necessary..and doing otherwise will mess up super badly..
Last edited:
Man I just like kuina
Her being alive doesn’t change their promise because zoro didn’t make that promise just because she died. The promise happened when she was alive and made it again to luffy
I just like kuina and what she represents
People thought and still think sabo and Saul being alive is dumb but here we are
Also zoro is the only character in the story besides kuina to strive to become wss. Zoro the only guy going for it was trained by the wss himself. Oda has gone out of his way to differentiate characters that use swords when fighting and actual swordsmen
If you want to complain about kuina potentially being alive diminishes zoro’s dream you gotta realize that oda’s already done worse
Her being alive doesn’t change their promise because zoro didn’t make that promise just because she died. The promise happened when she was alive and made it again to luffy
I just like kuina and what she represents
People thought and still think sabo and Saul being alive is dumb but here we are
Also zoro is the only character in the story besides kuina to strive to become wss. Zoro the only guy going for it was trained by the wss himself. Oda has gone out of his way to differentiate characters that use swords when fighting and actual swordsmen
If you want to complain about kuina potentially being alive diminishes zoro’s dream you gotta realize that oda’s already done worse