Powers & Abilities Xebec used a slash, not a “shockwave”

[Fleet D. Admiral]

Mihawk upscale

 

[mly90]

Mihawk upscale

Every swordsman in the series exists to hype Mihawk

 

[Welkin]

Rootbeer the Haki Scholar has returned

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

The point is nowhere is it stated in Japanese nor in English that Rocks Sword Skill is a Shockwave, you can think that it is, but that's not a fact..

Why are you not providing the full text box translation.

why do you want to be believed but refuse to do the most basic shit to be

just give use the full word for word translation, you have it don’t you?

 

[ZippySpace]

BRO NO ONE GIVES A FUCK XEBEC>>>>MIDHAWKS

 

[Rootbeer]

Why are you not providing the full text box translation.

why do you want to be believed but refuse to do the most basic shit to be

just give use the full word for word translation, you have it don’t you?

Compare the Kanji, there's no Shougekiha 衝撃波 in there.. The only thing they have in common is the Geki 撃 which means attack..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Compare the Kanji, there's no Shougekiha 衝撃波 in there.. The only thing they have in common is the Geki 撃 which means attack..

Translate the entire panel, word for word

do you not have the translation?

I don’t understand, I thought you did.

 

[сука]

I do like how literally all the top tier sword users are conveniently "not swordsmen" according to the powerscalers, but that's a disservice to them if you ask me; why would you want your "top tier" to be like Roger, who did less damage to Garp than Captain Morgan did.

 

[Rootbeer]

Translate the entire panel, word for word

do you not have the translation?

I don’t understand, I thought you did.

I guess you're just disingenuous at this point.. I thought you sought the truth.. Read any english translation, there's no mention of shockwave..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

I guess you're just disingenuous at this point.. I thought you sought the truth.. Read any english translation, there's no mention of shockwave..

… do you not know how language works?

language requires contexts. You understand sentences by reading the entire statement or paragraph

if you are refusing the translate the entire sentence then I will simply go by the other people’s translations that do in fact translate the entire sentence.

It’s that easy. Either translate the whole thing like everyone else does or you lack credibility.

how it is this hard to understand. Find the full translation or shut up

 

[Rootbeer]

… do you not know how language works?

language requires contexts. You understand sentences by reading the entire statement or paragraph

if you are refusing the translate the entire sentence then I will simply go by the other people’s translations that do in fact translate the entire sentence.

It’s that easy. Either translate the whole thing like everyone else does or you lack credibility.

how it is this hard to understand. Find the full translation or shut up

Very disingenuous..

Here's a bare translation without the '' Ha, No, Wo or De '' particles..

Rokkusu(Rocks), Kengi(Sword Skill), Marude(As if), Kyodaina(Huge), Hanmaa(Hammer), Ka(or), Hougeki(Canon attack), You Ni(Similar to)..
Shuui(Surroundings), Subete(everything), Fukitobasu(blow away), Koto, Yuumei(famous), Datta(was)..

 

[Albino 👑]

What’s a sword duel?

A duel relegated to swordsmanship tho you don’t need to be a swordsman

 

[centurion]

Two hands = stronger swordsman

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Kengi(Sword Skill)

So yeah. It’s swordsmanship. Good job with translating the full sentence.

see how that cleared up this argument immediately

A duel relegated to swordsmanship tho you don’t need to be a swordsman

So the conclusion from your own statements is that basically anything to do with a sword is swordsmanship. To be “better at swordsmanship’s than another person you must have a “sword duel”

but then the question is, what about a “sword duel” makes you “better at swordsmanship”? Is it winning the sword duel makes you “better at swordsmanship”?

Is that it? Just winning makes you better? Are you sure?

what if one character is 10 times faster than another character. They start their sword duel and the fast character chops off the slower character’s head before he can even react.

The fast character has “won the sword duel”. Is the fast character now “better at swordsmanship”?

 

[Reborn]

Some people really took cope to next level.

Totally can imagine this

Oda- Shanks is a swordsman (literally spell each word in the Manga)

Those people which include Albino and Shiroryu - Oda said he's a swordsman and not that he fights like a swordsman. So, he's a swordsman who might not fight like one and developed new fighting style based on haki..

 

[Albino 👑]

So yeah. It’s swordsmanship. Good job with translating the full sentence.

see how that cleared up this argument immediately



So the conclusion from your own statements is that basically anything to do with a sword is swordsmanship. To be “better at swordsmanship’s than another person you must have a “sword duel”

but then the question is, what about a “sword duel” makes you “better at swordsmanship”? Is it winning the sword duel makes you “better at swordsmanship”?

Is that it? Just winning makes you better? Are you sure?

what if one character is 10 times faster than another character. They start their sword duel and the fast character chops off the slower character’s head before he can even react.

The fast character has “won the sword duel”. Is the fast character now “better at swordsmanship”?

Zoro is more skilled at swordsmanship than king or queen but if they can beat him just using their swordsmanship they’d be the stronger ones
Tho when it’s comes to characters that don’t even consider themselves swordsman idk if they’d really be challenged.
Like

• Daz while basically a sword man doesn’t consider himself one. Tho take away s-hawks sword he’d most likely still consider himself a swordsman
• Kaku while the best swordsman in cp9 doesn’t use his physical swords post timeskip. So idk if he still counts as a swordsman just by using his legs like the rest of cipher pol
• Pica uses a sword but diamanté was an actual swordsman