General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Also it was amusing to see Yamao totally entranced by Momo's development.
She was literally rendered speechless. We just got a bunch of ellipses and have yet to see what she properly thinks about all of it. Now we wait for the Momo/Oden human form reveal and that will likely be the moment where Yamao makes it clear she ain't ever leaving Momo.
She was literally rendered speechless. We just got a bunch of ellipses and have yet to see what she properly thinks about all of it. Now we wait for the Momo/Oden human form reveal and that will likely be the moment where Yamao makes it clear she ain't ever leaving Momo.
Or for the three arcs preceding it?? I’d say anyone who still wants to cling to this delusion can eat shit, but that’s probably tastier than the garbage they’re already willing to consume…
Anyway, I should have posted this yesterday, but I thought to myself, “There’s no way this will happen, even this nutjob has to see that it’s over”…and yet, here we are once again:
Post automatically merged:
Anyway, I should have posted this yesterday, but I thought to myself, “There’s no way this will happen, even this nutjob has to see that it’s over”…and yet, here we are once again:
Last edited:
The situation is: IF Perospero or Jack is defeated by Luffy, or any other Straw Hat, then Carrot surely has a chance of becoming a nakama. It has been never, ever, once that a potential nakama’s main villain, defeated by someone non-other than Luffy, or at least the consisting Straw Hats. Even Vivi, an honorary Straw Hat, her villain were Mr. 5 & Miss Valentine (when she was Miss Wednesday, and that was the time she joined), and both Mr. 5 & Miss Valentine were defeated by Luffy & Zoro.
Jack? Defeated by Inuarashi
Perospero? Defeated by Nekomamushi
both are supposedly Carrot’s main villains. Are Inuarashi & Nekomamushi Straw Hats? No.
I guess it really isn’t that hard to comprehend. It’s a thin line between hopeful & delusional.
Jack? Defeated by Inuarashi
Perospero? Defeated by Nekomamushi
both are supposedly Carrot’s main villains. Are Inuarashi & Nekomamushi Straw Hats? No.
I guess it really isn’t that hard to comprehend. It’s a thin line between hopeful & delusional.
Last edited:
You've already made it very clear that I mean the world to you. You don't need to share your excitement to read my "well crafted" and "interesting" posts each week. It's already well known that you're dizzy for me and you'll be reading them regardless. Just try and stay calm when faced with other opinions. It'll help your mental health and rein in your "fury".
I've never seen a SH disappear for majority of an arc, be completely separated from the main conflict, be defeated off screen by a supporting villain and still be defeated chapters later while the target of their grudge is taken out by another supporting character. The Toppi Roppo are beaten; an All Star is beaten; BM's only officer is beaten; what can Carrot do to get back into the main conflict and become SH material?
Once again, Carrot's execution is unlike anything that has ever happened before, and the hope is that Oda is doing the complete opposite for Carrot alone and is swerving us all. She needs some serious help.
Once again, Carrot's execution is unlike anything that has ever happened before, and the hope is that Oda is doing the complete opposite for Carrot alone and is swerving us all. She needs some serious help.
Difference is if the strawhats are getting a oden and/or apprentice parallel to roger momo would be the most fitting in both cases
Theres yamato but if anyone is truly the most oden its probably gonna be momo
He also lets us have an apprentice "child" that isn't constantly a danger to have on board
He doesn't have to join but i think its possible
Theres yamato but if anyone is truly the most oden its probably gonna be momo
He also lets us have an apprentice "child" that isn't constantly a danger to have on board
He doesn't have to join but i think its possible
You've already made it very clear that I mean the world to you. You don't need to share your excitement to read my "well crafted" and "interesting" posts each week. It's already well known that you're dizzy for me and you'll be reading them regardless. Just try and stay calm when faced with other opinions. It'll help your mental health and rein in your "fury".
Momo is not interested going on adventure just like father. Yamato on other hand she wants do that. The arc has always been built up for Momo to take leadership and role shogun of wano. Even some nine scabbard said, they would advise Momo on how to run the country. The straw hat defeating Kaido and Momo goes on journey with them defeats the purposes what everyone fought for and died for throughout this entire raid. If Momo wants learn swordsmanship he can learn from remaining samurai he doesn’t have do what father did. If he needs lead advisers to help him with leadership he has some of his fathers followers
Last edited:
Idk as much as I would love carrot to join over Yamato that’s clearly not happening… even if carrot joined it would be disappointing to me even as a fan of hers because what has she done this arc?
Even though some SHs didn’t get/win fights their joining arc, they still gave us some of the biggest emotional climaxes of the series. Yeah we have the Pedro moment but that doesn’t justify her being sidelined for as long as she has.
But I do kind of agree with Dizzy to an extent, we still haven’t gotten any payoff or catharsis for Carrot and the stuff that was set up for her at the end of WCI. But at the same time the Jack plot line makes it clear that sometimes Oda doesn’t care about payoff lol. I find it so stupid that this subplot was dragged out for over 100 chapters just for …this….. Peros might as well have died at the end of WCI, it would’ve saved me a lot of typing
Even though some SHs didn’t get/win fights their joining arc, they still gave us some of the biggest emotional climaxes of the series. Yeah we have the Pedro moment but that doesn’t justify her being sidelined for as long as she has.
But I do kind of agree with Dizzy to an extent, we still haven’t gotten any payoff or catharsis for Carrot and the stuff that was set up for her at the end of WCI. But at the same time the Jack plot line makes it clear that sometimes Oda doesn’t care about payoff lol. I find it so stupid that this subplot was dragged out for over 100 chapters just for …this….. Peros might as well have died at the end of WCI, it would’ve saved me a lot of typing
Well there you have it folks.
Carrot4Nakama is officially dead.
It’s pretty obvious now that Oda has been trying to write her out of the story.
What future SH gets completely sidelined in the arc they’re supposed to join?
The Perospero fight is where Carrot had the most emotional investment in and Oda took that away from her.
There’s literally nothing left for her to do in this arc.
She’s no more important to the plot than Wanda is.
The Mods can go ahead and lock this thread now.
Carrot4Nakama is officially dead.
It’s pretty obvious now that Oda has been trying to write her out of the story.
What future SH gets completely sidelined in the arc they’re supposed to join?
The Perospero fight is where Carrot had the most emotional investment in and Oda took that away from her.
There’s literally nothing left for her to do in this arc.
She’s no more important to the plot than Wanda is.
The Mods can go ahead and lock this thread now.
Idk as much as I would love carrot to join over Yamato that’s clearly not happening… even if carrot joined it would be disappointing to me even as a fan of hers because what has she done this arc?
Even though some SHs didn’t get/win fights their joining arc, they still gave us some of the biggest emotional climaxes of the series. Yeah we have the Pedro moment but that doesn’t justify her being sidelined for as long as she has.
But I do kind of agree with Dizzy to an extent, we still haven’t gotten any payoff or catharsis for Carrot and the stuff that was set up for her at the end of WCI. But at the same time the Jack plot line makes it clear that sometimes Oda doesn’t care about payoff lol. I find it so stupid that this subplot was dragged out for over 100 chapters just for …this….. Peros might as well have died at the end of WCI, it would’ve saved me a lot of typing
Even though some SHs didn’t get/win fights their joining arc, they still gave us some of the biggest emotional climaxes of the series. Yeah we have the Pedro moment but that doesn’t justify her being sidelined for as long as she has.
But I do kind of agree with Dizzy to an extent, we still haven’t gotten any payoff or catharsis for Carrot and the stuff that was set up for her at the end of WCI. But at the same time the Jack plot line makes it clear that sometimes Oda doesn’t care about payoff lol. I find it so stupid that this subplot was dragged out for over 100 chapters just for …this….. Peros might as well have died at the end of WCI, it would’ve saved me a lot of typing
and let’s see the female pattern joining:
- Nami joined, after all of Arlong crew were defeated by Straw Hats, each. Main villain: Arlong. Defeated by: Luffy
- Robin joined, after all of Baroque Works officer agents were defeated by Straw Hats, again. Main villain: Crocodile. Defeated by: Luffy
in Carrot’s case, Carrot’s main villain is either Jack, or Perospero. Both Jack & Perospero, are not defeated by any of Straw Hats or potential Straw Hat. Yamato on the other hand, has the same recruitment pattern with Nami & Robin. Jack & Perospero don’t have any subordinates to be defeated by Straw Hats, if the case is that Carrot’s main villain is Jack / Perospero. Also, Carrot wasn’t shown to have any terrible past (which is the definite condition of any Straw Hat joining). Pedro’s death happened in current timeline.
The 5-10% chance of Carrot joins, if it turns out that there is another main villain in waiting for her, and if her terrible past is finally shown post joining, like Robin.
what Carrot is lacking as a nakama, if we see Nami & Robin:
- no terrible past
- no special 1 on 1 interaction with Luffy
- she has 2 main villains, and sadly enough both are not defeated by Luffy, not even by any of the Straw Hats
- some say that her strongest chance is her role as a lookout. Weak trio are very proficient in their own role, and their role compensate their weakness in battlefield. Nami is very good at navigation skill, Chopper is also very good at being a doctor. Usopp, while he’s considered the weakest, he at least has haki; and again he is very good at sharp-shooting.
unless if Carrot’s case is like Robin, where Robin’s ability to read Poneglyph was shown near the end of Alabasta arc, Carrot’s chance is extremely slim. She needs to show something she is very good of, if she joins & she needs another main villain to be defeated by Luffy, same like what happened to any other Straw Hats.
Last edited:
- Status