General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Uncle Van]

This thread would make a perfect try not to laugh challenge. I would definitely fail.

 

[Ballel]

This thread would make a perfect try not to laugh challenge. I would definitely fail.

It's imperative to laugh here. Laughing is good for your health!

 

[Paperchampion23]

No, I was talking before Luffy and the crew arrived on Onigashima Yamato was a member of kaido crew then she switch to Luffy's side

I'm not sure I understand your point lol I'm sorry

I'm just saying Yamato counts because Luffy only has 11 people on his ship. Rockstar doesn't because Shanks has tons of random fodder and while Rockstar is strong (allegedly) and named, he's not an officer.

I'm just using the same logic we use for Blackbeard and his 10 captains.

 

[IIskandar1997]

"Subversive affirmation" though

 

[Garp the Fist]

Funny to think that for a good while Rockstar was one of the highest known bounties.

94 million when he was introduced was pretty huge. Slightly below Luffy/Dorry/Broggy, but above Crocodile, Zoro, Robin.

Course, the big ones then were Doffy and Kuma.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

@dizzy2341 still in here liking comments, wasn’t he gonna leave when Wano ended?? Doesn’t the cool guy have a rich, fulfilling offline life to get back to??

 

[ARMeni]

Like you guyz said, Yamato could be the weakest joining in the strawhats, that's for a good reason I already explained:

The non-presence of the refusal of the call to adventure.

- Zoro refused during his encounter
- Nami refused during Arlong park
- Usopp later refused to stay on water Seven, that refusal was prepared since the beginning.
- Sanji refused during baratie
- Chopper refused during Drum
- Robin later refused to leave with them during Ennie Lobby
- Franky refused during water seven
- Brook refused to take his shadow back on thriller bark
- Jinbe refused because of responsibilities during Fishmen Island

ALL the strawhat at one time refused to join the crew, that refusal sealed their future presence.

Yamato doesn't have that, worst she is doing the opposite.

This is why for now.. Yamato is still unlikely to join the crew.

But this is the subversive shit that you like!

It's unexpected! Yamato will be the first one that doesn't change her mind!

Or it doesn't count because it doesn't fit your fucking agenda?

 

[Logiko]

But this is the subversive shit that you like!

It's unexpected! Yamato will be the first one that doesn't change her mind!

Or it doesn't count because it doesn't fit your fucking agenda?

It's unlikely because the challenge of Yamato passed and that there is no trace of potential development for her in the future, so she is unlikely to refuse to stay with the crew in the future.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

It's unlikely because the challenge of Yamato passed

What challenge?

 

[Logiko]

What challenge?

Leaving the graps of her father and freeing herself.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Leaving the graps of her father and freeing herself.

How does that equate to him not joining?

 

[ARMeni]

It's unlikely because the challenge of Yamato passed and that there is no trace of potential development for her in the future, so she is unlikely to refuse to stay with the crew in the future.

That's a fat fucking lie, so let me help you with that.

- She could become the representative of Momo that will learn what his father did in Laugh Tale and then come back to inform him so that he can make the best decision concerning Wano's borders.
- We still don't know anything about Onis and Yamato could also play a role in wanting to learn more about it by travelling with the SHs. If at some point the Oni heritage becomes a point of contention for her and the crew, it could lead to a big Yamato moment.
- Above all else, SHE WANTS TO SET SAIL AND SEE THE WORLD.

There is enough things for her to have a development with, AND ONLY WITH, the SHs. Cope.

Post automatically merged: Jun 10, 2022

Leaving the graps of her father and freeing herself.

She was freed by Luffy, both directly (the cuffs) and indirectly (by defeating him and getting him out of Wano). And she played a role in freeing Wano and thus herself by containing Kaido while Luffy recovered and came back to the roof.

 

[Staticshadic]

It's unlikely because the challenge of Yamato passed and that there is no trace of potential development for her in the future, so she is unlikely to refuse to stay with the crew in the future.

There is a lot of potential development for Yamato to develop in the future what the hell are you talking about.
Robin was a former enemy to the strawhats. There still mystery that surround that her character. Keep mind when she joins the crew at the end of alabasta Zoro was only person who did not trust her just yet. When she travels went on her adventures with the strawhats she would experience a lot of character development throughout the story when she alongside with them.. Yamato is no different except she was not former enemy of theirs she more of ally who help throughout the raid.

Even though Yamato has not grown eighty chapters she has been the story with strawhats. She still has room to grow as a character if she ends up traveling with them. Think about of like this ussop back than always call himself captain ussop even though he is not the captain of the crew. He always use that to boast confidence. After the events enis lobbv ussop he no longer call himself captain ussop. Chance our if yamato does goes on adventure with the strawhats she might not call herself oden anymore.

 

[Logiko]

How does that equate to him not joining?

Because like I said: Every strawhats once refused the call for adventure. Yamato will never refuse the adventure concerning the strawhat.. so them joining is unlikely.

That's a fat fucking lie, so let me help you with that.

- She could become the representative of Momo that will learn what his father did in Laugh Tale and then come back to inform him so that he can make the best decision concerning Wano's borders.
- We still don't know anything about Onis and Yamato could also play a role in wanting to learn more about it by travelling with the SHs. If at some point the Oni heritage becomes a point of contention for her and the crew, it could lead to a big Yamato moment.
- Above all else, SHE WANTS TO SET SAIL AND SEE THE WORLD.

There is enough things for her to have a development with, AND ONLY WITH, the SHs. Cope.

A lot of headcanons, nothing setups by the story.. Pass..

She was freed by Luffy, both directly (the cuffs) and indirectly (by defeating him and getting him out of Wano). And she played a role in freeing Wano and thus herself by containing Kaido while Luffy recovered and came back to the roof.

That's not what I'm talking about. I'm referring to her cahracter arc. Something each character must pass through. Like Usopp accepting that hid behavior got the better of him in water seven.

There still mystery that surround that her character.

No there is not.

 

[Ballel]

Because like I said: Every strawhats once refused the call for adventure. Yamato will never refuse the adventure concerning the strawhat.. so them joining is unlikely.

Yamato is nakama
Larrot
Won't
Join

 

[ARMeni]

A lot of headcanons, nothing setups by the story.. Pass..

YOU?

YOU HAVE THE NERVE TO SAY THAT I'M MENTIONING HEADCANONS?

 

[Butters]

Because like I said: Every strawhats once refused the call for adventure. Yamato will never refuse the adventure concerning the strawhat.. so them joining is unlikely.




A lot of headcanons, nothing setups by the story.. Pass..




That's not what I'm talking about. I'm referring to her cahracter arc. Something each character must pass through. Like Usopp accepting that hid behavior got the better of him in water seven.



No there is not.

Ignored, here's why.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Because like I said: Every strawhats once refused the call for adventure. Yamato will never refuse the adventure concerning the strawhat.. so them joining is unlikely.

So Oda can't suddenly change it up?

 

[Staticshadic]

Because like I said: Every strawhats once refused the call for adventure. Yamato will never refuse the adventure concerning the strawhat.. so them joining is unlikely.




A lot of headcanons, nothing setups by the story.. Pass..




That's not what I'm talking about. I'm referring to her cahracter arc. Something each character must pass through. Like Usopp accepting that hid behavior got the better of him in water seven.



No there is not.

Yes there is, we don't know much Yamato's mom, we do not know much about the oni race, we have no idea where Yamato's was born, and we definitely do not know why Kaido refer Yamato's as son and how she was before she saw oden.

 

[Logiko]

YOU?

YOU HAVE THE NERVE TO SAY THAT I'M MENTIONING HEADCANONS?

I always talk about thing that have narrative ground in the story, if you are inventing setups, it's on you.

So Oda can't suddenly change it up?

Unlikely

Yes there is, we don't know much Yamato's mom

So the fact that we don't know Carrot's parent is a mystery for Carrot by your standard ?

we do not know much about the oni race

Is this even a race ?

we have no idea where Yamato's was born

Onigashima most probably.

why Kaido refer Yamato's as son

Because he actually listens to her

how she was before she saw oden.

Why should this matter ?