I didn't say seeing things with binoculars was good eye sight. I said was that she is usually the first to notice.
I'm not ignoring anything. Regarding your comment on the strawhat's intruding in Zou. It may not have been the smartest idea to take on 4 people by herself but she still noticed them first. Alarming people would have been smart, but she fought instead. I'd consider it a character flaw to carry the weight of taking down invaders on her own.
Nami was the first one to notice Reiju, not Carrot. She is “usually” the one to notice because Usopp is not there. During Sanji retrieval team before they met Sanji, who has haki? Only Luffy. If Sanji, or Usopp is there, she will be useless. Robin who currently doesn’t have haki can do a much better job simply by sprouting her eyes on any surface. I’ve given example like before entering Onigashima for Usopp’s case.
She took the paper because the mail seagull approached her. It has nothing to do with territorial, good eyes, nose, or whatever bullshit you made up. FYI you haven’t shown me anything about her being territorial. She was shown doing what she does because Usopp wasn’t there. Simple logic
"This is exactly what happened when you take too much copium. I was wrong to think that “probably at least one of Carrot fans here can be talked with.” only for you to prove me wrong. No wonder the sane & logical Carrot fan like Shift left this thread long time ago"
I was bullied here for having a name similar to carrot4nakama. I like Goku and I like Carrot, my name wasn't even related to word nakama. Random people harassed me just for liking carrot and advocating for her. It took the moderator "TheAncientCentirun" to stop this. Every time I mention carrot in any context 4 people consistently mocked me. Occasional extremely disrespectful people come around and call me names. Any sane person would leave these conditions by now. In addition to the bullies, I had one moderator against me as well using paraphrase quotes he heard adding in whatever details he wants to make himself right. Not only do I need to keep a straight face I had to carefully ask to give the actual proof.
Luckily I work a career that requires composure regardless of the request. Yes software engineer and business people do not get along, we are natural enemies. If you haven't noticed, I've only spoken to people that actual want to discuss. I've ignored everyone who only here to make me feel bad. My points being made have sometime been invalidated and that's okay. Out of everyone here I begruntley say you've won the most, certainly more than that lazy Moderator Van. Regardless my point is standing. The role she has been shown to do is what mirror every strawhat.
Most of those, I missed the part where that’s my problem. For the last sentence though, it was clear that she failed miserably. She failed to notice Bariete was missing earlier. She failed to notice Daifuku’s Genie approaching. And that’s why Usopp did what she was supposed to do once Usopp is on board anymore.
Nobody can read Poneglyph like Robin, and nobody has great navigation skill like Nami. If her role is like you said it is, why Oda drew Usopp doing what she was supposed to do before entering Onigashima instead of showing her did that?