[FNZ] Role Madness Valentine's Mafia Game: Be My Valentine

[DoflaMihawk]

Yeah, there will only be one correct solution.

Rn, I think my best guess is Doc + 1 from Twilight 1 fake death + 1 from Twilight 2 fake death.

I think we can reasonably make every kill work from there, except maybe Jessica? Bc maybe the person who killed Doc couldn’t have got that far ahead of them.

The witch Epitaph poem thing may indicate there are 4 culprits? Tho that could be a stretch.

What a coincidence, my theory has 4 culprits nfufu

 

[Charlie]

Only way is if Ghodi lied, and it wasn’t locked and Shannon unlocked an already not locked door and didn’t realize (seems unlikely)

he'd have to kill both though

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Yeah, there will only be one correct solution.

Rn, I think my best guess is Doc + 1 from Twilight 1 fake death + 1 from Twilight 2 fake death.

I think we can reasonably make every kill work from there, except maybe Jessica? Bc maybe the person who killed Doc couldn’t have got that far ahead of them.

The witch Epitaph poem thing may indicate there are 4 culprits? Tho that could be a stretch.

Also, the door was locked when they got to Doc unless one is lying.

So if whoever killed Doc left and ran to wait on Jessica, he probably didn’t lock the door behind him/her.

 

[Ultra]

No, I'm thinking Krauss killed Natsuhi within the room, so Shannon was right to say the door was locked because it was.

So why does that make Ghoti a culprit again? lol

 

[Dr_Professor83]

he'd have to kill both though

Yeah probably. I think it was just one of the two in the room lol. Simplest solution and has the most going for it.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

So why does that make Ghoti a culprit again? lol

He’s tunneling

 

[DoflaMihawk]

So why does that make Ghoti a culprit again? lol

If doc is lying, he has to kill at some point. I have him killing everyone at T1 so Godha and Krauss would have to lie about the T1 room being locked

 

[RippedCal]

Ripped one is here

 

[Charlie]

The witch Epitaph poem thing may indicate there are 4 culprits? Tho that could be a stretch.

The witch shall praise the wise and bestow four treasures.
One shall be all the gold from the Golden Land.
One shall be the resurrection of all the dead souls.
One shall be the resurrection of the love that was lost.
One shall be to put the witch to sleep for all time.

financial motive? Natsuhi killing broke husband and faking her own death seeing that people are trying to kill everyone who could inherit all this money?
person "dying" T1 killing someone?
love motive?
revenge motive? killing someone who killed already? someone killing doctor because he killed someone who he wasn't supposed to kill?

idk, i don't think it adds up

 

[Charlie]

If doc is lying, he has to kill at some point. I have him killing everyone at T1 so Godha and Krauss would have to lie about the T1 room being locked

let's assume doctor killed guys at T1

who survived though?

 

[RippedCal]

Looking for love

Who wants to intertwine in the sands of time with the revered one

 

[DoflaMihawk]

let's assume doctor killed guys at T1

who survived though?

Does someone need to have survived?

 

[RippedCal]

O Valentine o valentine wherefore art thou valentine, deny thy father and refuse thy name, and I'll no longer be the Ripped one

I will become ripped beast once more

 

[Charlie]

Does someone need to have survived?

2 people who died, didn't really die

 

[Ultra]

let's assume doctor killed guys at T1

who survived though?

If you assume someone outside of the room killed them then I don't think there's incidental survivor - there's only a survivor if one is a culprit hiding.

 

[DoflaMihawk]

2 people who died, didn't really die

Oh I thought you meant in T1 lol

Krauss and Godha survived

 

[Charlie]

If you assume someone outside of the room killed them then I don't think there's incidental survivor - there's only a survivor if one is a culprit hiding.

i mean, basically

 

[RippedCal]

Sweets & Café Lycoreco

Your friendly neighbourhood cafe. You can join this cafe to relax and have a good time during the night. We have Frappucino, Cappucino, all types of Cinos, snacks, boardgames,skewers and even beer as cold as you Ex's heart.

Quote this post to visit LycoReco Cafe

Spoiler

1- @Pot Goblin
2- @Psylocke
3- @T-Pein™
4- @Ultra
5- @Alwaysmind
6- @Dr_Professor83
7- @Apollo
8- @kavotino
9- @Peroroncino
10- @Flower
11- @Fujishiro
12- @Charlie
13- @Gambit
14- @Kiku
15- @AL sama
16- @Juliet
17- @RippedCal
18- @Indigo
19- @hime
20- @DoflaMihawk
21- @xenos5
22- @Pew
23- @Yo Tan Wa
24- @Reborn
25- @DarkestKnightofSpoilers
@Ratchet

Ripped one will take a seat in the cafe

 

[Charlie]

so let's say it's Godha killing people T1 (noone survived), Krauss/Natsuhi killing someone T2 (2nd person survived)

that means doctor had to kill someone, i guess Shanon?

then Godha kills Kumasawa and fakes own death

then Godha kills Doctor and Jessica

does it make sense purple-wise?

 

[DoflaMihawk]

so let's say it's Godha killing people T1 (noone survived), Krauss/Natsuhi killing someone T2 (2nd person survived)







that means doctor had to kill someone, i guess Shanon?







then Godha kills Kumasawa and fakes own death







then Godha kills Doctor and Jessica







does it make sense purple

-wise?

Jess would have to kill to since she lied about Godha dying, so she can kill Shannon