Yeah he is right. I didn't bother making a case about him when I casted my vote.
But in day one, Beta felt kind of off to me. It was mostly guts feelings so I voted Rej because of his chaotic posts. But then I saw Beta vote Rej...and from experience, being on the same page as Beta is usually a bad sign so I unvoted Rej.
And I later chose to cast vote on Finalbeta to see his reaction (if he will suss me back) and also because of what you said about Beta which I agreed with. And I don't feel any different about Beta today, that's why I casted the vote again on him again.