General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[ConquistadoR]

"Carrot is still the best candidate for strawhat based on the narrative"

 

[Logiko]

"Carrot is still the best candidate for strawhat based on the narrative"

Yes. And thus despite the fact that she is nowhere to be seen in the story right now

 

[Staticshadic]

Yes. And thus despite the fact that she is nowhere to be seen in the story right now

what are you saying lack of screen time prove are point she not going join the crew.
Dj Khaled Congratulations GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

 

[Logiko]

what are you saying lack of screen time prove are point she not going join the crew.
Dj Khaled Congratulations GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

The lack of development is irrelevant if the development in the story is enough. Same for the lack of presence in the story. Do you feel like Sabo is irrelevant because he was not presented in the story for a long time ?

Probably not. That's why judging the character's importance in the future on the amount of presence is irrelevant

What do we have for Carrot? All the setup of whole cake and the words of both Pedro and Perospero. If Carrot was a irrelevant Character, Oda would have never bother taking the time to make Pedro say "one day you will understand why the survival of Luffy is important" and Pero say a whole monologue to Carrot to finish on "Go eat some grass, that's were you belong"

Those are called setups. Those are clews that there is a narrative purpose for Carrot beyond her simple presence.

The lack of panel time does not equal lack of future importance.

 

[RoronoaZorro]

List of 2020 c**e

1. Yamato can't join because Luffy calls her Yamao
2. Yamato doesn't fit 29
3. Yamato wont fit the girls' bed/Sunny
4. SH already has zoan
5. Yamato doesn't have a role
6. Yamato will sail alone/made her own crew
7. Yamato cant join because she knows too much
8. Yamato will die like Oden because of parallel

List of 2021
1. Yamato is too strong
2. Yamato will stay in Wano because she has Wano guardian deity DF
3. Mythical Zoan is too special for SH
4. SH already has ice user
5. Yamato didn't meet the SH

List of 2022
1. Yamato will be captured by WG because she's the DF they're talking about
2. Yamato interacts with Momo again and again
3. Yamato is worried about Momo so she stays

 

[jordin]

Look at that, the anime is hyping up the Yamato flashback and giving a special episode to herself with original scenes.

The same episode where Ace has to open up Yamato's heart so she can proudly declare she wants to leave and go to sea. I wonder if that means it's not something meant to be changed in her story. :zorothink:

 

[Logiko]

Look at that, the anime is hyping up the Yamato flashback and giving a special episode to herself with original scenes.

The same episode where Ace has to open up Yamato's heart so she can proudly declare she wants to leave and go to sea. I wonder if that means it's not something meant to be changed in her story. :zorothink:

You know that quoting the anime to state a so-called "hype for Yamato" when the anime had Carrot being shined for 7 minutes on no panel at all is kinda wobbly, right ?

Yamato is a very well appreciated character, like Oden at the time, it's logical for the anime to surf on the wave.

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

So it basically means it’s okay to use filler scenes of Carrot in anime to extend the anime length as an argument, but it’s not okay to use anime scene of Yamato which is actually based on manga as an argument.

logic of a banned user is really something.

 

[Adamxero]

You know that quoting the anime to state a so-called "hype for Yamato" when the anime had Carrot being shined for 7 minutes on no panel at all is kinda wobbly, right ?

Yamato is a very well appreciated character, like Oden at the time, it's logical for the anime to surf on the wave.

Carrot getting an extended filler scene before she gets negged is not the same as a promotion of an entire episode dedicated to Yamato.

Larrot has never had that and never will side characters don't get these type of things

 

[Fuckthis3]

So it basically means it’s okay to use filler scenes of Carrot in anime to extend the anime length as an argument, but it’s not okay to use anime scene of Yamato which is actually based on manga as an argument.

logic of a banned user is really something.

Nah you his miss his point basically "carrot get love in anime too who cares" lol.....

 

[Adamxero]

Nah you his miss his point basically "carrot get love in anime too who cares" lol.....

An extended filler to give context to a fight is not the same as a promotion for an episode for someone declaring they want to set out to sea.

If Larrot fans got this they'd be creaming their furry inspired pants.

 

[Fuckthis3]

An extended filler to give context to a fight is not the same as a promotion for an episode for someone declaring they want to set out to sea.

If Larrot fans got this they'd be creaming their furry inspired pants.

Yea so? Just like some Yamato fans doing cross the world somewhere right now lol

 

[Adamxero]

Yea so? Just like some Yamato fans doing cross the world somewhere right now lol

Yeah and rightfully so.

The point is Yamato fans are getting much more love from both Oda and Toei. We know Oda tells Toei stuff also so I've never seen a character hyped liked Yamato before.

Comparing Larrot and Yamato's love been given is laughable.

 

[Rottkins]

Yamato is the most likely to join since he has a rule that appeared a few times in one piece what is chronicler. Why do I think it might be it? Because Oden was WB's and then Roger's and as we know Yamato is Oden. If he won't, we will just see him as a captain of his own crew.

Carrot might travel with them too but it will be highly connected to what Wanda will decide since, despite everything that Carrot did, she still listens to her. Besides, Carrot wants to see the world, being sick of sitting on Zunisha.

Vivi..? Um... Not sure about it but tho it would be interesting, especially if she trained and got some tricks in her sleeves since she was pretty weak, and in the crew there can't be anyone weaker than Usopp in combat, remembering Oda's words.

Everyone else has their stuff to do so I don't even know why are they here since A. Wano squad has their country to take care of, and B. Alliance buddies are.. Alliance. Why do you need them too since they are already in the squad? and at the end C. Smoker has too high ego to join a pirate crew, faster he will be a part of SWORD if he isn't

 

[Logiko]

So it basically means it’s okay to use filler scenes of Carrot in anime to extend the anime length as an argument, but it’s not okay to use anime scene of Yamato which is actually based on manga as an argument.

logic of a banned user is really something.

No it means that saying that a anime is somehow favorising a Character is kinda wobbly.

 

[tan]

Zeus is the best option :unsure:

What people want to happen: Carrot eats Monet's fruit that respawned on Nami's tree, becomes a snow rabbit, and joins the crew.

Post automatically merged: Feb 24, 2022

Caesar is a scientist
Caribou a strategic if Law dies this arc then he is joining
And Nami hates Sanji too but he is in the crew

 

[Peroroncino]

I'm a rebel so neither carrot nor yamato are joining

 

[Ravagerblade]

I'm a rebel so neither carrot nor yamato are joining

 

[Roo]

Post automatically merged: Feb 24, 2022

Why would Law die in this arc

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Carrot fans in massive shambles since 2019.