[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread
- Status
tbh charlie is not doing himself any favors there and just allowing himself to get dunked on by chevy for no reason lol. making it hard to discern how forced chevy is, but its clear he is going for an easy, low resistance path
dem caught red handed
his only saving grace is ratchet is not looking too townie himself
maybe both scum from diff faction kek
dem caught red handed
his only saving grace is ratchet is not looking too townie himself
maybe both scum from diff faction kek
Not really, I seen enough already from Arp and gauged his reaction, it's been over 30 pages. Nothing he can do will undo what has happened in the thread. Exposing ekko weak shade attempts is good.
You think it muddle things huh? How so exactly? It's fascinating that you think i laid out my full intentions when I thought it was clear from the get go what I was aiming for, but do elaborate.
You think it muddle things huh? How so exactly? It's fascinating that you think i laid out my full intentions when I thought it was clear from the get go what I was aiming for, but do elaborate.
updating the last one:
Village leans so far:
Michelle; I liked the early village leans as strong village will often look to find other village first and she was the first to do so.
Chevy(not so much for his questioning of me, but I like this exchange with charlie and the fact he's calling out someone that gave him a village lean because really scum have no incentive to do that).
Fuji has vibed town to me too.
Ratchet; had a similar reaction to chevy's questioning of me as I did and I like when people mindmeld!
Above reads are still pretty much consistent. I'd say Michelle belongs in a strong town core.
Ultra; I like his aggression, questioning, and his overall thoughts on arp as well as making sure people he's familiar with don't get away with any cheap explanations(i.e. going after lord meakor for saying something as vague as "these interactions are often T/T" and wanting more so it's not just him saying something to say something aka fake reasoning). I'm not sure how his wolf range otherwise I'd want to give him a strong village read honestly for his opening.
Lord Meakor; I liked his RESPONSE to said suspicion. rather than get spooked and backpedal he pretty much held his ground. i also do overall agree that to two are likely to have a back and forth early in game mostly nitpacking at each other wheras scum often latches onto a particular thing to nitpack and attempts to make that person look bad to everyone else(rather than just having a direct/extended one on one confrontation). obviously this means nothing towards me, but knowing I'm village it makes adds to chevy being village.
I can't recall who said I looked null after interacting with my suspicion on Ekko(not Mr. Ripped, after him), I think it was a she. I liked her too.
Kweh has also looked really town to me. His thoughts mostly line up with my own and I liked his prodding of ultra.
Ekko looks a bit better after coming back, but he's mostly been done catch up posts so far. I do look forward to seeing him interact when he's fully caught up and posting in real time. I don't really agree with the chevy wagon or vote nor do I look how he was shading arp just before voting chevy, but it is what it is.
I think ARP is still a good scum vote. I don't know much about Kagu but I wouldn't oppose her direction either as she didn't really make a notable impact on the day, but that's mostly a vibe.
Oh ya, I don't really like how Ripped has mostly talked about what not to do. Even after the initial setup vs. gameplay stuff from the beginning, he then went at me for my vote on Ekko and told me to "wait until he's back", etc. Ekko could have defended himself from said pressure rather than have had Ripped make those points. As Ripped likes to say it is really WEAK posting.
Village leans so far:
Michelle; I liked the early village leans as strong village will often look to find other village first and she was the first to do so.
Chevy(not so much for his questioning of me, but I like this exchange with charlie and the fact he's calling out someone that gave him a village lean because really scum have no incentive to do that).
Fuji has vibed town to me too.
Ratchet; had a similar reaction to chevy's questioning of me as I did and I like when people mindmeld!
Above reads are still pretty much consistent. I'd say Michelle belongs in a strong town core.
Ultra; I like his aggression, questioning, and his overall thoughts on arp as well as making sure people he's familiar with don't get away with any cheap explanations(i.e. going after lord meakor for saying something as vague as "these interactions are often T/T" and wanting more so it's not just him saying something to say something aka fake reasoning). I'm not sure how his wolf range otherwise I'd want to give him a strong village read honestly for his opening.
Lord Meakor; I liked his RESPONSE to said suspicion. rather than get spooked and backpedal he pretty much held his ground. i also do overall agree that to two are likely to have a back and forth early in game mostly nitpacking at each other wheras scum often latches onto a particular thing to nitpack and attempts to make that person look bad to everyone else(rather than just having a direct/extended one on one confrontation). obviously this means nothing towards me, but knowing I'm village it makes adds to chevy being village.
I can't recall who said I looked null after interacting with my suspicion on Ekko(not Mr. Ripped, after him), I think it was a she. I liked her too.
Kweh has also looked really town to me. His thoughts mostly line up with my own and I liked his prodding of ultra.
Ekko looks a bit better after coming back, but he's mostly been done catch up posts so far. I do look forward to seeing him interact when he's fully caught up and posting in real time. I don't really agree with the chevy wagon or vote nor do I look how he was shading arp just before voting chevy, but it is what it is.
I think ARP is still a good scum vote. I don't know much about Kagu but I wouldn't oppose her direction either as she didn't really make a notable impact on the day, but that's mostly a vibe.
Oh ya, I don't really like how Ripped has mostly talked about what not to do. Even after the initial setup vs. gameplay stuff from the beginning, he then went at me for my vote on Ekko and told me to "wait until he's back", etc. Ekko could have defended himself from said pressure rather than have had Ripped make those points. As Ripped likes to say it is really WEAK posting.
You popped out of nowhere and the one post you decided to reply to was a post that was non relevant to the game, you don't seem like you have any intentions to contribute in the game or move forward.
Don't worry about pero here, be more concerned about yourself, you are in my scum read and pero is not. So I get to be picky on who I pressure here.
You planning on giving reads? or just gonna play the victim card here.
Don't worry about pero here, be more concerned about yourself, you are in my scum read and pero is not. So I get to be picky on who I pressure here.
You planning on giving reads? or just gonna play the victim card here.
Oh this also reminds me, I was on board with chevy's push of Charlie. Charlie seemed a bit starstruck over the pushing.
As far as "low hanging fruit" goes. I have no idea about charlie and since Chevy said he's new I'd assume he doesn't either. You can't really tell who is and who isn't low hanging fruit when you're new to a site and unfamiliar with people.
As far as "low hanging fruit" goes. I have no idea about charlie and since Chevy said he's new I'd assume he doesn't either. You can't really tell who is and who isn't low hanging fruit when you're new to a site and unfamiliar with people.
No worries, I'm here only because it's GoT.
Welp, so far I like Usopp this game. Looks like he's poking different people to get reaction and go somewhere from there. He's iffy on me, but he was like that (even more) last game and he's town.
About LM I can't really say much. I'm always wrong about him. Last time I amped his abilities and he was GF. He seems bit scummy for me rn, so he'll probably turn out to be town.
I don't have problem with either SK or Kagura rn, but I'm assuming if one of them is mafia, another one won't be. You can buss your own teammate, but the way to make them look good in the end I think.
Idk about Arp. He got overprotective quite easily, but so did I, so maybe that's just how he is.
Tbh, I'm getting used to getting called out over nothing D1. Have you played together? Do you think he'd risk starting wrong wagon D1 as scum? From what I've seen so far, most of the time they'd rather find already existing wagon and jump on it. Like, it doesn't matter who gets lynched that early on, as long as it's not one of them. That'd be bold move imo.
Well, he was indie. Zolo said he's going after indies. That's the first person I'd go after too.
I mean, there was this discussion with me too.
Welp, so far I like Usopp this game. Looks like he's poking different people to get reaction and go somewhere from there. He's iffy on me, but he was like that (even more) last game and he's town.
About LM I can't really say much. I'm always wrong about him. Last time I amped his abilities and he was GF. He seems bit scummy for me rn, so he'll probably turn out to be town.
I don't have problem with either SK or Kagura rn, but I'm assuming if one of them is mafia, another one won't be. You can buss your own teammate, but the way to make them look good in the end I think.
Idk about Arp. He got overprotective quite easily, but so did I, so maybe that's just how he is.
Tbh, I'm getting used to getting called out over nothing D1. Have you played together? Do you think he'd risk starting wrong wagon D1 as scum? From what I've seen so far, most of the time they'd rather find already existing wagon and jump on it. Like, it doesn't matter who gets lynched that early on, as long as it's not one of them. That'd be bold move imo.
Well, he was indie. Zolo said he's going after indies. That's the first person I'd go after too.
I mean, there was this discussion with me too.
Fair!(for the bold)
It doesn't muddle things if you got everything you want from it! If you hadn't and were still waiting for more info for the reaction or your read was still subject to change from further pushing then there was more of a point to my post. Since that doesn't appear to be the case my point is moot! That point being laying out your full intentions prior to getting the info you want from a reaction then allows the reactee to adjust to what you want to see, which as village you never want to do, and the only reason to fully lay out your plans prior to getting the full amount of reaction you're waiting for is to defend yourself(and as I said previously, scum is the one most concerned with their image opposed to their scumhunting).
Let me know if this makes sense!
It doesn't muddle things if you got everything you want from it! If you hadn't and were still waiting for more info for the reaction or your read was still subject to change from further pushing then there was more of a point to my post. Since that doesn't appear to be the case my point is moot! That point being laying out your full intentions prior to getting the info you want from a reaction then allows the reactee to adjust to what you want to see, which as village you never want to do, and the only reason to fully lay out your plans prior to getting the full amount of reaction you're waiting for is to defend yourself(and as I said previously, scum is the one most concerned with their image opposed to their scumhunting).
Let me know if this makes sense!
- Status