My Shadow of the Erdtree boss tier list:
I am glad to say that there were no F tier bosses in this DLC of the ones I experienced. Rellana came damn close but I think if they tweak her a little bit, she could be great. As things stand sheβs just too cracked for a colossal weapon enjoyer such as myself. The Golden Hippopotamus and its clones were also crap but at least they werenβt overly challenging.
For the most part, I think Elden Ringβs rememberance bosses for me sit around the B-A tier. The Putrescent Knight pushed C tier for his annoyance but overall I donβt think he was bad. The Lion Dance was also quite frustrating but my Scadutree blessing wasnβt leveled so maybe it wasnβt the boss itself.
The big three standouts were of course Messmer, Bayle, and the Consort.
Messmer was frustrating as hell to learn but once I learned him I loved him. His move set was super cool and he had some outrageous lore that completely shook up my understanding of all the lore.
Bayle was just so peak. I didnβt think FROM would surpass Midir for dragon fights but for me Bayle was that guy. His buildup and the battle itself was the most peak shit in the DLC.
Lastly, the consort. I struggled for a while on what I thought of this boss, but beating him was the most memorable experience in all of Elden Ring. I have my own problems with the lore of this battle, and heβs not a perfect boss, but for me he was the perfect combination of spectacle and difficulty. So I give him a tentative SS for now. Definitely either the best or second best boss in Elden Ring beside Bayle.