In general when characters stick around for so long the odds are they will probably stay until the journey is over. But this is not necessarily the case here... Carrot doesn't seem to have any goal bar avenging her family... and all the surpruses the BPM caused. The other SHs have more reasons to keep staying. Regardless it can very well be that Carrot will keep staying in order to pay a debt or something.
General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
The focus was on Pedro when he died, Carrot had a support role to hear his final words and make the scene more impactful.. It was never about Carrot. If Carrot was meant to be special and become a Strawhat, once she went Sulong, she stated that Pedro trained her for that and it would have been shown on panel were she intended to be a Strawhat.. She was never central in the story, even the chapter where she goes Sulong is not named after her, she just there to introduce the Mink's trump card..
Nothing shows he told her specifically, he was talking outloud like someone making a stand or saying something deep for everyone to hear. Shishilian must have been there too and other minks..
He also didn't say that she will understand but THEY will understand as the Strawhats and her why its so important for them to keep going on..
Again it was never about Carrot, it was all about Pedro.
He also didn't say that she will understand but THEY will understand as the Strawhats and her why its so important for them to keep going on..
Again it was never about Carrot, it was all about Pedro.
If we are similarize between Pedro and Oden, and comparing with conditions of Carrot and Yamato;
1. Roger did pick Oden from WB but not Pedro (even as apprentice just like Shanks and Buggy)
2. Oden has specialties which is read and write ancient text. And strong enough to be part of the crew. Pedro only a little mink kid, which Roger already has mink people (Inu and Neko) within his crewmate.
Meanwhile, in Carrot-Yamato cases;
1. Yamato did request (insist) joining SH but iirc, Luffy has not yet given any promise to her. While, Carrot succeeded over her mentor Pedro by boarding Sunny with SH to WCI amd Wano. The chances for both of them being a permanent SH Crew is not yet affirm.
2. Yamato not needed to have speciality reading ancient wording. That's Robin job. I also predict that Zoro might obtain ability to carve a words at poneglyph later on. As for Carrot, her fighting style got room for improvement but as of now, her character-wise eclipse with Chopper e.g. Sulong form/Monster Point got conditional time or time limit.
So, now I believe both of them is red herring to be SH Crew.
I vote for somebody else will join SH e.g. Caribou/Drake
Vivi is an Honorary SH. Her role will be the same as Shirahoshi and Momonosuke, being a 'pilot' of ancient weapons Vivi (Pluton), Shirahoshi (Poseidon) and Momo (Uranus)
1. Roger did pick Oden from WB but not Pedro (even as apprentice just like Shanks and Buggy)
2. Oden has specialties which is read and write ancient text. And strong enough to be part of the crew. Pedro only a little mink kid, which Roger already has mink people (Inu and Neko) within his crewmate.
Meanwhile, in Carrot-Yamato cases;
1. Yamato did request (insist) joining SH but iirc, Luffy has not yet given any promise to her. While, Carrot succeeded over her mentor Pedro by boarding Sunny with SH to WCI amd Wano. The chances for both of them being a permanent SH Crew is not yet affirm.
2. Yamato not needed to have speciality reading ancient wording. That's Robin job. I also predict that Zoro might obtain ability to carve a words at poneglyph later on. As for Carrot, her fighting style got room for improvement but as of now, her character-wise eclipse with Chopper e.g. Sulong form/Monster Point got conditional time or time limit.
So, now I believe both of them is red herring to be SH Crew.
I vote for somebody else will join SH e.g. Caribou/Drake
Post automatically merged:
Vivi is an Honorary SH. Her role will be the same as Shirahoshi and Momonosuke, being a 'pilot' of ancient weapons Vivi (Pluton), Shirahoshi (Poseidon) and Momo (Uranus)
Last edited:
Idk if you’re trolling again or actually being serious but…
Sure in theory he could’ve been talking to anyone but the focus of those panels are on Pedro and carrot so that makes it pretty obvious he’s talking about her
The dialogue is a flashback to when they were talking right before carrot got on the ship and Pedro went after peros. Carrot says “what do you mean” and the pedro says “YOU’ll realize one day” meaning carrot specifically. The whole scene is Pedro passing his will onto Carrot, not the minks as a whole
Sure in theory he could’ve been talking to anyone but the focus of those panels are on Pedro and carrot so that makes it pretty obvious he’s talking about her
The dialogue is a flashback to when they were talking right before carrot got on the ship and Pedro went after peros. Carrot says “what do you mean” and the pedro says “YOU’ll realize one day” meaning carrot specifically. The whole scene is Pedro passing his will onto Carrot, not the minks as a whole
If I have to choose. I'd pick Yamato then.
Carrot is fucking useless comic relief which there is too much already on the ship.
Even her Sulong form is useless. She couldn't even scratch someone like Perospero and Luffy is meant to attack more and more powerful top dogs.
No time for babysitting trash like Carrot, Nami, or Tama.
Carrot is fucking useless comic relief which there is too much already on the ship.
Even her Sulong form is useless. She couldn't even scratch someone like Perospero and Luffy is meant to attack more and more powerful top dogs.
No time for babysitting trash like Carrot, Nami, or Tama.
At this point of the story. Characters like Nami, Usopp are just fucking useless. The amount of plot armor and inconsistency Oda went thru to keep them alive is fucking insane.
Nami who is fragile and weak as all hell tanks hybrid Ulti's headbutt which almost pushed Luffy to G4 if not for Yamato.
The same Ulti that tanks CoC infused punch from a Yonko and still stands up after just to be finished by a fucking lightning from comic relief talking cloud.
Tell me that this manga is not going childish downhill....
But to the point. Carrot is just a useless character that brings nothing but more comic relief to the crew. She would become new weakling trio with usopp and Nami.
Nami who is fragile and weak as all hell tanks hybrid Ulti's headbutt which almost pushed Luffy to G4 if not for Yamato.
The same Ulti that tanks CoC infused punch from a Yonko and still stands up after just to be finished by a fucking lightning from comic relief talking cloud.
Tell me that this manga is not going childish downhill....
But to the point. Carrot is just a useless character that brings nothing but more comic relief to the crew. She would become new weakling trio with usopp and Nami.
The focus is more on Pedro, the first line he's adressing to Shishilian by saying, soitsu meaning that one and indirectly speaking of Carrot. And that's for this reason Shishilian reponds by telling Pedro not to but in..
The second line he's talking generally not involving Carrot, The means matters not, one must become a strong warrior. Steel yourself! Someone's turn will definitely come!!
Its sort of the reverse proverb of, the end doesn't justify the means..
Again he's talking in a broadly manner while Carrot listening and questioning without direct reply.
Someday it will be understood how much important it is for Luffy's group to survive and continue their journey!! Listen, you lot must keep going forward!!
SHE, Carrot doesn't have to personally uncover the meaning, its Pedro's final words via a sort of prophecy for the readers.. He didn't pass on his will to Carrot, that's absurd..
The second line he's talking generally not involving Carrot, The means matters not, one must become a strong warrior. Steel yourself! Someone's turn will definitely come!!
Its sort of the reverse proverb of, the end doesn't justify the means..
Again he's talking in a broadly manner while Carrot listening and questioning without direct reply.
Someday it will be understood how much important it is for Luffy's group to survive and continue their journey!! Listen, you lot must keep going forward!!
SHE, Carrot doesn't have to personally uncover the meaning, its Pedro's final words via a sort of prophecy for the readers.. He didn't pass on his will to Carrot, that's absurd..
The focus is more on Pedro, the first line he's adressing to Shishilian by saying, soitsu meaning that one and indirectly speaking of Carrot. And that's for this reason Shishilian reponds by telling Pedro not to but in..
The second line he's talking generally not involving Carrot, The means matters not, one must become a strong warrior. Steel yourself! Someone's turn will definitely come!!
Its sort of the reverse proverb of, the end doesn't justify the means..
The second line he's talking generally not involving Carrot, The means matters not, one must become a strong warrior. Steel yourself! Someone's turn will definitely come!!
Its sort of the reverse proverb of, the end doesn't justify the means..
not sure what you mean in that last line
Again he's talking in a broadly manner while Carrot listening and questioning without direct reply.
Someday it will be understood how much important it is for Luffy's group to survive and continue their journey!! Listen, you lot must keep going forward!!
SHE, Carrot doesn't have to personally uncover the meaning, its Pedro's final words via a sort of prophecy for the readers.. He didn't pass on his will to Carrot, that's absurd..
Someday it will be understood how much important it is for Luffy's group to survive and continue their journey!! Listen, you lot must keep going forward!!
SHE, Carrot doesn't have to personally uncover the meaning, its Pedro's final words via a sort of prophecy for the readers.. He didn't pass on his will to Carrot, that's absurd..
I actually think it’s more absurd that you’re trying to make carrot irrelevant in a moment that was very clearly about her and Pedro, just because you dont
want her to have any sort of character arc since that would hurt your argument against her lmao
- Status